Red Pill Reports

Red Pill Reports

Forensic Analysis – Bombshell Proof Of Election Machine Manipulation

Forensic analysis of the drive image of Mesa County, Colorado’s Dominion Voting Systems Election Management System server

Bombshell Proof Of Election Machine Manipulation

Page 1 of 88 March 19 2022
G1130 Mesa County
Colorado
Voting Systems
Report #3
Election Database and Data Process Analysis

Page 2 of 88
Table of Contents
Executive Summary ……………………………………………………………………………………………………3
Introduction………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..5
Definition of Terms…………………………………………………………………………………………………….7
Analysis ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….9
Discussion…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………26
Conclusions………………………………………………………………………………………………………………28
Appendix A – Batches in Original Adjudication Database…………………………………..31
Appendix B – Batches in New Adjudication Database…………………………………………38
Appendix C – EMS User Log Events in November 2020………………………………………59
Appendix D – EMS User Log Events in March 2021…………………………………………….68
Reference A – Databases and Tables…………………………………………………………………….73
Reference B – Scanner Speed………………………………………………………………………………..75
Reference C – Scanners Used by Mesa County…………………………………………………….76
Reference D – Data Movement from Batches to Votes ……………………………………….77

Page 3 of 88
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This report documents the findings of an examination of tabulated vote
databases based on forensic analysis of the drive image of Mesa County,
Colorado’s Dominion Voting Systems (DVS) Election Management System (EMS)
server. The findings in this report were prepared by the authors as consultants
to the legal team representing Tina Peters, the Mesa County Clerk and Recorder,
pursuant to her statutory duties as Mesa County’s Chief Election Official. The
findings provide evidence of unauthorized and illegal manipulation of tabulated
vote data during the 2020 General Election and 2021 Grand Junction Municipal
Election. Because of this evidence, which led to the vote totals for those elections
being impossible to verify, the results and integrity of Mesa County’s 2020
General Election and the 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election are in question.
This analysis was performed using the forensic image of the EMS server, which
was backed up before Colorado Secretary of State and DVS overwrote the hard
drive with D-Suite version 5.13.
Findings and Implications:
1) There was an unauthorized creation of new election databases during early
voting in the 2020 General Election on October 21, 2020, followed by the
digital reloading of 20,346 ballot records into the new election databases,
making the original voter intent recorded from the ballots unknown. In
addition, 5,567 ballots in 58 batches did not have their digital records
copied to the new database, although the votes from the ballots in those
batches were recorded in the Main election database.
2) The same unauthorized creation of new election databases occurred
during the 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election on March 30, 2021,
followed by the digital reloading of 2,974 ballot records, making the
original voter intent recorded on those ballots unknown. In addition,
4,458 ballots in 46 batches did not have their digital records copied to the

Page 4 of 88
new database, although the votes from the ballots in those batches were
recorded in the Main election database.
3) The absence of secure hash algorithm (.sha) files for each digital ballot
image makes the authenticity of each digital ballot image, and the ballotlevel record for those ballots, impossible to verify.
4) The true total vote count in Mesa County, Colorado cannot be accurately
calculated for the 2020 General Election or the 2021 Grand Junction
Municipal Election from records in the databases of the county’s voting
system.
5) There is no function or feature on the EMS server that could
be executed inadvertently or deliberately by a local election official that
would cause this combination of events to occur, especially within the time
frame that these events occurred. Given the complex sequence of data
manipulations and deletions necessary to produce the digital evidence
described in this report, this combination of events could not have been the
result of either deliberate or inadvertent actions by those officials.
6) Dominion’s installation of the Trusted Build update on the EMS in May of
2021, as ordered by the Colorado Secretary of State, destroyed all data on
the EMS hard drive, including the batch and ballot records that evidenced
the creation of new databases and reprocessing of ballot records described
in Findings 1 and 2 above. This destruction of all data by the trusted build
is described in the “Mesa County, Colorado Voting Systems Forensic
Examination and Analysis Report”.
7) The fact that such ballot record manipulation has been shown
demonstrates a critical security failure with the DVS EMS wherever it is
used. The manipulation would not be identifiable to an election official
using the voting systems, nor to an observer or judge overseeing the
election conduct, much less to citizens with no access to the voting systems;
without both cyber and database management system expertise, and

Page 5 of 88
unfettered access to database records and computer log files (many of
which were destroyed by the actions of the Secretary of State) from the
EMS server, the manipulation would be undetectable.
INTRODUCTION
The use of computerized election management systems is now nearly universal
across counties in the United States. While the use of these systems is touted as
“efficient”, potentially decreasing manpower costs and time to produce election
results, it also greatly reduces the transparency of the election process and
exposes our elections to extraordinary vulnerability from both inadvertent and
deliberate misconfiguration or misuse. Americans’ right to free and fair elections
is inalienable, but that right is infringed by lack of transparency, and by whatever
lies behind that opaque curtain.
Without free and fair elections and the transparency to see it for themselves,
without relying on the assertions of any other person or organization, Americans’
consent and the legitimacy of our government, at all levels, is in doubt. If
Americans’ votes are to be recorded and counted by machines, every aspect of
those machines’ operation, configuration, and data must be recorded,
immediately available at no cost or administrative burden to citizens and their
independent examiners and confirmed 100% accurate through that independent
verification. The absence or shortfall of any of those three imperatives (recorded,
available, and independently verified) should immediately cause the public to
distrust both the purported result from those machines, and also anyone who
insists that they accept those results.
Numerous Federal and State laws attempt to safeguard our voting rights and
the integrity of our elections. Title 52 USC provides for much of the Federal
guidance in this area, and Colorado Revised Statute (CRS) Title 1 covers most of
the Colorado state guidance.
a) 52 U.S. Code § 10307 prohibits any person acting under color of law to
“…willfully fail or refuse to tabulate, count, and report…” the vote of any
person entitled to vote.

Page 6 of 88
b) 52 U.S. Code § 10308(a) prescribes penalties for any person depriving or
attempting to deprive any person of voting rights under Federal statute.
c) 52 U.S. Code § 10308(c) prescribes penalties for conspiring to violate or
interfere with secured voting rights.
d) 52 U.S. Code § 20701 mandates the preservation of all election records for
22 months after an election for Federal offices.
1,2
e) 52 U.S. Code § 20702 prescribes penalties for theft, destruction,
concealment, mutilation, or alteration of § 20701 election records.
f) 52 U.S. Code § 21081 requires that voting systems used in elections for
Federal office meet the standards of that section, including that the voting
system shall produce a record with an audit capacity for such system, and
that “the error rate of the voting system in counting ballots…shall comply
with the error rate standards established under section 3.2.1 of…” the
Federal Election Commission 2002 Voting System Standards (VSS).
3
g) CRS §1-5-601.5 requires that voting systems and equipment in Colorado
meet 2002 VSS standards, at minimum.
h) CRS §1-7-802 requires the preservation of election records for 25 months
after elections.
i) CRS §1-13-111 prescribes penalties for destroying, removing, or delaying
delivery of election records.
Title 52 clarifies that the “every officer of election” is responsible for maintaining
the election records.
1 U.S. Department of Justice Publication “Federal Law Constraints on Post-Election ‘Audits’,” July 28, 2021, states that “The
materials covered by Section 301 extend beyond ‘papers’ to include other ‘records.’ Jurisdictions must therefore also retain and
preserve records created in digital or electronic form.”
2 The Federal Election Commission’s 2002 Voting System Standards, the standards of which are mandatory minima for certification
of voting systems under Colorado state statute § 1-5-601.5., specifies that a voting system which “…provides access to incomplete
election returns and interactive inquiries before the completion of the official count…shall: a. …be designed to provide external
access to incomplete election returns only if that access for these purposes is authorized by the statutes and regulations of the using
agency…b. Use voting system software and its security environment designed such that data accessible to interactive queries resides
in an external file, or database, that is created and maintained by the elections software under the restrictions applying to any other
output report, namely, that: 1) The output file or database has no provision for write-access back to the system. 2) Persons whose only
authorized access is to the file or database are denied write-access, both to the file or database, and to the system,” and states that the
Standards are “intended to address…risks to the integrity of a voting system…,” including “…Changing calculated vote totals;…” and
“Preventing access to vote data, including individual votes and vote totals, to unauthorized individuals;…”
3 2002 VSS, para 3.2.1 specifies “d. For central-county systems…: Consolidation of vote selection data from multiple counting
devices to generate jurisdiction-wide vote counts, including storage and reporting of the consolidated vote data…a target error rate of
no more than one in 10,000,000 ballot positions.” A ballot position is each and every choice (e.g. a “bubble” which can be marked or
filled-in) on a ballot selectable by a voter to convey their voting choices.

Page 7 of 88
Mesa County, Colorado, uses software and hardware provided by DVS and for the
2020 General Election and the 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election,
specifically used “D-Suite 5.11-CO.” The primary voting system EMS server, which
contains the raw tabulated vote information used to produce official election
reports, makes use of Microsoft SQL Server 2016 databases running on the
Microsoft Windows Server 2016 operating system. The forensic image used for
the analysis, created on May 23, 2021, has been validated as authentic (see
“Report #2, Forensic Examination and Analysis Report” by D. Gould for the
methods used to validate the forensic image).
DEFINITION OF TERMS
“Ballot”: Mesa County used two-sided paper ballots in the November 2020
General Election and the 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election. A ballot is a
device used to cast votes in an election. In Colorado, ballots are pieces of paper
defining races and issues, and reflecting the choices of individual voters from
among the options available for each race and issue. A digital image of each
paper ballot is created by the DVS D-Suite voting system during the processing
of ballots, as described below, and that ballot image is stored on the designated
“NAS (Network Attached Storage device)” of the D-Suite voting system.
“Adjudication”: A term used to describe the process of determining voter intent
from a voter’s ballot marks, where ballot markings are ambiguous. According to
Dominion’s Democracy Suite Use Procedure Manual, adjudication is “the process
of examining voted ballots to determine, and, in the judicial sense, adjudicate
voter intent”. In the DVS D-Suite, adjudication refers to the operation and use of
a software component called “EMS Adjudication,” and the process of using that
software component to manually or automatically interpret voter intent from
scanned ballot images, and then to record that interpretation as the record of
the vote choices for the affected ballots, in both “result files” and ballot images.
Depending on software configuration choices, individual ballot images/result
files, entire batches of ballot images/result files, or all ballot images/result files
can be subjected to automatic or manual adjudication on the basis of
“exceptions” or “outstack conditions” (e.g., “overvotes”, where too many choices

Page 8 of 88
are marked for a race or issue; or “marginal marks” when ballot choice ovals are
not adequately filled in), or by the arbitrary decision of EMS administrators.
“Manual Adjudication”: Either all ballot images, or individual ballot images, or
those from particular batches or tabulators, in which voter intent for any race or
issue is flagged by the EMS Adjudication software module as not being
determinable (or as having “exceptions”), are, in theory, sent to “Manual
Adjudication” stations where officials called “Adjudicators” view the digital
images of the ballots and decide the voter’s intent. In this Report we sometimes
use the terms “manual adjudication” and “machine adjudication” to clearly
distinguish the process of human judging of voter intent from the process of the
DVS EMS Adjudication software’s determining of voter intent.
“Adjudication database”: The DVS D-Suite version used in Mesa County during
the November 2020 and April 2021 elections maintains a separate SQL Server
database, called an “AdjudicableBallotStore,” created by DVS software, for each
election which contains records of all batches and ballots scanned into the voting
system through ImageCast scanning workstations, and any batch and ballot
records manually entered. The database maintains critical information about
each batch and ballot, most importantly the ballot Adjudication status and the
file location of the ballot image. A batch can have any of the following
adjudication statuses in the adjudication system: In-Progress, Read Error,
Review, Pending Submission, Submitted, or Submission Error.
4 Throughout,
“Adjudication database.”
“Main election database”: The DVS D-Suite version used in Mesa County during
the November 2020 and April 2021 elections maintains a database for each
election, called an “ElectionStore” by DVS, which contains information defining
an election, including contest, candidate, and ballot definitions as well as
aggregated vote information which is used to produce all election reports
generated by County officials. Throughout, “Main database.”
4 In-Progress batches have been acquired by the system (e.g. through scanning at an ICC) and have ballots being served to clients
(Adjudication); Read Error batches are those which encounter errors while being loaded into the system; Review are batches with all
ballot adjudication complete, including batches with no adjudication required; Pending Submission are batches submitted to tally, but
which have not yet completed that transmission to the tally process; Submitted are batches which have completed the transmission to
the tally process; Submission Error are batches that were submitted to the tally process, but which were unsuccessfully submitted.

Page 9 of 88
“Tabulation database”: The DVS D-Suite version used in Mesa County during the
November 2020 and April 2021 elections maintains a database for each election,
called a “TabulationStore” by DVS, which contains the timestamps and ballot
counts for each batch of ballots, which duplicates that information contained in
the Adjudication database. It contains other tables which are not used by Mesa
County’s elections. Throughout, “Tabulation database.”
“Reprocessed”: For the purposes of this Report, the term “reprocessed” means
that one or more data records which had already been created, presumably by
scanning of paper ballots through an ImageCast Central (ICC) workstation,
though also technically possible through manual entry of records, within the
databases associated with an election, were loaded into the system
again to a
different database, and that this re-loading was not performed in connection
within any documented, authorized election-related operations procedure or
function. A comparison with the log files of the respective ICC workstations might
reveal whether the reprocessed paper ballots were, in fact, rescanned at the ICC,
but many of those log files have been destroyed by the Secretary of State’s
“Trusted Build.”
ANALYSIS
I. Evidence of ballot record data manipulation – November 2020 General
Election
Our analysis shows manipulation, which was neither initiated nor authorized by
Mesa County election clerks, of the batches and ballots processed during the
first three days of ballot processing in the November 2020 General Election.
The following timeline of events, beginning October 19, 2020, when Mesa County
began processing ballots in the General Election, demonstrates this
manipulation of ballots.
October 19, 2020 – October 21, 2020, 2:14 PM
Page 10 of 88
On these first three days of ballot counting in Mesa County, up until 2:14 PM on
October 21, 2020, 267 batches, consisting of 25,913 ballots, were physically
processed (physically scanned on DVS ICC scanners with voters’ choices, in the
form of marks on the ballots, scanned and interpreted by software) through
three tabulators, internally identified in the Main database as tabulator IDs 4, 7,
and 10. Mesa County election clerks reported no unusual activity or errors
encountered during the processing of these 267 batches. The Adjudication
database used at this time contains records of all batches with a sequential “load
order” of 1 to 267, and other tables within it record the information about each
ballot, for instance the time it was entered into the database, the tabulator used,
and the adjudication status. Those which were selected for Adjudication have the
proper status records indicating that the normal adjudication steps occurred.
The initial 10 batches processed through tabulator 10, containing a total of 941
ballots, had timestamps indicating that they were all entered into the database
within 47 seconds (total – not 47 seconds per batch, but 47 seconds for 10
batches). (See Appendix A for a list of the batches and their timestamps in the
original Adjudication database.) The Canon DR-G1130, which according to
purchasing documents and Colorado Secretary of State voting equipment
inventories is the model of scanners used by Mesa County (see Reference C and
the Colorado Secretary of State website
5), operates at approximately 100 pages
per minute (ppm), duplex, meaning that scanning both sides of each ballot would
take no less than 0.01 minutes, which is 0.6 seconds, per ballot. 941 ballots at
0.6 seconds per ballot should have taken a minimum of 564 seconds, or slightly
under 9 and a half minutes, a significantly longer interval than 47 seconds, which
is physically impossible. Mesa County election clerks were unaware of these
batch timestamps, or any issue which could explain them.
October 21, 2020 – 2:14 PM
According to the data contained in the EMS SQL Server Database, new Tabulation
and Adjudication databases were created on the EMS server at 12:18:50 PM
October 01, 2020. These databases initially contained no data records.
5 CO SecState Voting Equipment Inventory at: https://archive.ph/RQS91
Page 11 of 88
Figure 1. “Before” Screenshot of Databases on the Mesa EMS Server

One Adjudication database and one Tabulation database were listed, with
creation times before the counting in Mesa County began on October 19, 2020.
Figure 2. “After” Screenshot of Databases on Mesa EMS Server

Two Adjudication databases (“AdjudicableBallotStore”) and two Tabulation
databases (“TabulationStore”) are now listed, one set of which had creation times
before the date and time ballot scanning and tabulation began in Mesa County
on October 19, 2020 and the other set of which the EMS server data indicate
were created two and a half days
after ballot scanning and tabulation began.
It has been observed that a clerk giving the EMS system a command to stop and
then restart adjudication in an election again creates new Adjudication and
Tabulation databases. Mesa County clerks are very certain that they did not
initiate any such action in either the November 2020 or the April 2021 elections.
Therefore, it is likely that a procedure internal to the DVS software had to
perform a stop and restart of the adjudication services in order to perform the
batch and ballot manipulation which occurred later (see below).

Page 12 of 88
There are only a few possibilities which would explain how the database copying
process was initiated.
1. Direct action by Mesa County personnel
The client application used by election clerks does give them the ability to
stop and restart adjudication, which would create the new databases.
However, Mesa County personnel are very clear that they did nothing of the
sort and explained that they would only do such a thing in an extreme
emergency, as the process would have made the production of legally
mandated reports very difficult.
2. Triggered remotely
“Report #2, Forensic Examination and Analysis Report” by D. Gould
identifies numerous security vulnerabilities in the DVS EMS server. A
signal, or external trigger,
6 giving instructions to software inside the EMS
server could have been sent to and received through any of the open
communication ports, or through the port 80 Web Server port, which has
been demonstrated to be open on the server and accepting commands via
an application programming interface (API).
7 This signal, along with other
information, could have been received via a local network connection
(from any device connected to the EMS server’s internal network), from a
remote network connection (if the EMS server’s internal network has been
bridged to the external internet), or via an internal cellular modem (if one
was installed in any DVS system). If the EMS Server was connected to a
wireless network, it is feasible that even a cell phone outside of the
6 E.g., an “external trigger” most people are familiar with is the function whereby their smartphone’s wi-fi connection is turned on in
response to detecting the proximity of a saved, pre-approved wi-fi network. The external trigger satisfies the criteria of an internal,
saved rule for application behavior, and the application then executes the correlated command or function. We likely don’t think of
“Do Not Disturb” mode on our smartphones as being similarly controlled by an external trigger, but if our smartphones are configured
to “use network time,” meaning the time signal transmitted by the cellular carrier network, then our smartphones’ “Do Not Disturb”
mode isn’t turned on at the time we set, per se, but when our cellular carrier tells our phone that the specified time is reached.
7 An API is a specification for interaction which allows computer applications to communicate with, make requests to, and issue
commands to other computer applications. I.e., API enables machine-machine communication, coordination, and command and
control, depending on the permissions and allowable exchanges of the specific API specification.

Page 13 of 88
building, but still within the wireless signal radius, could have been used
to trigger the events.
This option is plausible but infers a degree of external, time-sensitive
control over the DVS equipment in use in Mesa County. This control might
be considered undesirable by the perpetrators responsible for
manipulating the election data, because it was a possibility that any
unauthorized network connections, whether they be via standard ethernet,
wireless network connection, or cellular modem, could have been
discovered during the election period.
3. Algorithmically Triggered
A software algorithm8 running inside the DVS computer systems in Mesa
County could have made the decision to perform the new database
creations and the selected record manipulation which followed based on
preprogrammed criteria related to the election results at the time.
Given that this method requires the least amount of external control and
monitoring, this option would seem to be the most likely. The decision to
copy the Adjudication and Tabulation databases and re-process the ballot
records would be made by software running inside the Dominion EMS (or
inside another connected machine running Dominion software) based on
unexpected voting patterns.
October 21, 2020, 2:30 PM – 2:34 PM
During this time period, 209 out of the original 267 batches (containing a total
of 20,346 ballots) were digitally – not physically – loaded into the new
Adjudication and Tabulation databases. Specifically, records for batches with
load order 2 through 59 were not reloaded and do not appear in the new
8 An “algorithm” is simply a set of rules for logical, sequential consideration of inputs (e.g. a contingent variable state, like “the switch
is off” or “the switch is on,” or the value of field/memory location “X” is “1” or is “Not 1”) to produce a consistent, expected output.
In this case, a simple, hypothetical algorithm might have been something like “IF (‘numberofbatches’>50) AND
(“ElectionProjectActive”=TRUE) AND (“EMSAdminUserLoggedIn”=FALSE) AND
(VOTETOTAL,“InternalMachineID:01”>VOTETOTAL,“InternalMachineID:02”) AND (SYSTIME>20201019) AND
(SYSTIME<20201103) THEN COPY:BATCHID030010:BATCHID030059 AND INSERTINTO “adjudicableballotstore,” etc.

Page 14 of 88
Adjudication database in any form. The timestamps of the 209 batch records
(load order 1 and load orders 60 through 267) show an impossibly short
processing time (approximately 4 seconds each) for these batches to have been
physically processed into the newly created Adjudication and Tabulation
databases. As described above, because of the minimum scanning time of one
minute per batch for the Canon DR-G1130 scanner-based tabulator, it is not
possible for these 20,346 ballots to have been physically rescanned (i.e., the
paper ballots were not reloaded into the scanning hardware), but rather the
digital batch and ballot records were directly added to the new Adjudication
database. This indicates that the batches could only have been loaded into the
newly created Adjudication and Tabulation databases by using software code or
a script running within the EMS server. See Appendix B for a list of all batches
and their timestamps in the new Adjudication database. See Appendix C for a list
of all commands executed prior to and after the database copy, which provides
a precise timeline of the effects of those commands on the database copy.
It is important to note that this unauthorized procedure only copied the records
of selected batches of ballots, indicating that this was an intentional act.
Below is a screenshot of the beginning of the list of batches recorded in the
original Adjudication database, sorted by the order that they were loaded:
Figure 3. List of Batches Recorded in the Original Adjudication Database, Sorted by Load Order

Page 15 of 88
Note that there is a sequential order with all load order numbers represented.
Below is a screenshot of the same table in the newly created Adjudication
database:
Figure 4. List of Batches in Newly Created Adjudication database


While the record of the batch with load order 1 was copied, there is a gap of 58
batches before the second line, which is a record of the batch with load order

Page 16 of 88
60. Batch load order numbers 2 through 59 were not copied, and never existed
in the new Adjudication database.
The data records describing the batches and the ballots contained within them
in the new Adjudication database, specifically the time stamps shown in
Appendix B as well as statements by Mesa County election officials, indicate that
the paper ballots and batches were not physically re-scanned. Therefore, it
appears the process of scanning these ballots was simulated, and the records of
the batches and the ballots contained within them were electronically
transferred from the original Adjudication database into the new Adjudication
database.
For example, below is the sequence of events detailing the processing of batch
4024 (whose ballots and records were
not copied to the new Adjudication
database) and batch 4025 (whose ballots and records were copied to the new
Adjudication database). This will illustrate the contrast between copied and
uncopied batch and ballot records.
Batch 4024 is recorded in the original Adjudication database as being created
at 4:09:34 PM on October 19. It contained 100 ballots and was scanned by
tabulator 10. Ten of these ballots from batch 4024 were subsequently
manually adjudicated. The ballot numbers in the batch which were manually
adjudicated were 4, 8, 13, 14, 30, 48, 63, 87, 88, and 90. Then, the votes
contained on all 100 ballots were recorded in the appropriate tables in the
Main database (see Reference A for a list of these tables). When the new
Adjudication database was created, no records from Batch 4024 were copied
to it, and thus there was no reprocessing or physical rescanning of the ballots.
Adjudication history for the 10 ballots which were manually adjudicated was
no longer available to the Mesa County clerks, and the original voter intent of
these ballots is unknown.
In contrast, Batch 4025 is recorded in the original Adjudication database as
being processed at 4:12:23 PM on October 19. This batch contained 99 ballots
and was also scanned by tabulator 10. Fourteen of these ballots were

Page 17 of 88
subsequently manually adjudicated. The ballot numbers in the batch which
were manually adjudicated were 3, 10, 13, 21, 22, 23, 34, 40, 49, 59, 66, 79,
97, and 99. Then, the votes contained on all 99 ballots were recorded in the
appropriate tables in the Main database.
After the new Adjudication database was created, a record of Batch 4025
appeared in its tables at 2:20:26 PM on October 21. It is still listed as having
99 ballots and from tabulator 10. In the new Adjudication database, however,
only 6 of the batch 4025 ballots (8 less than the first time these batches were
entered into the original Adjudication database), were
again manually
adjudicated. The individual ballot numbers were 3, 21, 22, 40, 59, and 66. At
this point, the vote records from at least those 6 ballots and possibly all 99
would have been recorded in the appropriate tables in the Main database,
replacing the votes which were already in that database from those ballots.
Adjudication history for the 14 ballots which were manually adjudicated was
no longer available to the Mesa County clerks, and the original voter intent of
these ballots is unknown.
The selected batches in the new Adjudication database (batch 1 and batches 60
through 267) appeared in the same serial order that they were loaded into the
original Adjudication database, with the same batch numbers, ballot counts, and
load order numbers (compare Appendix A and Appendix B).
October 21, 2020, shortly after 2:34 PM
At this point, as reported by Mesa County election officials, some Mesa County
adjudication officials began noticing that they were being asked to look at ballots
that they had already adjudicated. This is consistent with these ballots and
batches being reprocessed in the new Adjudication database. When the new
Adjudication database was created, and the selected records described above
were copied and reprocessed, there were outstanding ballots from the last set
of batches scanned before the event. As some of these ballots were sent to
manual adjudication again after the batches were reprocessed, this caused a
situation where the same ballot was in the manual adjudication process twice.

Page 18 of 88
This caused confusion among the election staff who were assigned the duty of
manual adjudication, since when a ballot was adjudicated the second time the
master count of adjudicated ballots, which is displayed by the Dominion system
and is used by the election clerks to track the overall adjudication process, did
not change. This caused the Adjudication officials to assume that there had been
an error and, in some cases, to attempt additional manual adjudications of the
same ballot with the same unsatisfactory result.
According to several Mesa County election officials, DVS support was contacted
at approximately 4PM on the 21
st of October, and while the support
representative claimed to not have a solution for the issue Mesa County was
seeing, that issue ceased soon afterwards. This indicates that DVS may have
performed or caused to be performed an operation unknown to Mesa County
election officials (and outside of their control) to address this problem which
manifested after the unauthorized database manipulation.
Of the 209 batches which were processed twice (batches 1 and 60 through 267),
the ballot counts match between the old and new Adjudication database.
However, DVS software marked 2,166 ballots for manual adjudication the first
time they were processed in the original Adjudication database, but when
reprocessed in the new Adjudication database the software marked only 965
ballots for manual adjudication.
The same ballots run through the same hardware and evaluated by the same
software should have had the same resulting ballots marked for adjudication,
but they did not. This leads to the logical critical conclusion that not all the
ballots in the batches processed after the database copy were the same and had
the same votes as the ballots in the same batches processed before the database
copy. There is no record remaining of the votes originally recorded from the
ballots, and therefore there can be no certainty that the votes now recorded are
the same. In essence, the chain of custody has been broken for these votes in
the database.

Page 19 of 88
The 58 batches which were not duplicated in the new Adjudication database
must also be seen as suspect, as their chain of custody has also been broken via
the fact that no record of them or their adjudication exists in the Adjudication
database in use at the end of the election. A clerk wishing to view the
adjudication status of a ballot in any of the 58 batches would be unable to do
so, as no information about those batches exists in the new Adjudication
database.
Thus, all 25,931 ballot records processed before 2:14 PM on October 21, 2020,
comprising over 25% of the County’s total over the entire election, cannot be
verified and should not have been counted.

II. Evidence of Ballot Manipulation – April 2021 Grand Junction Municipal
Election

Our analysis shows a nearly identical manipulation of the batches and ballots
processed during the first six days of ballot processing in the April 2021
Municipal Election in Grand Junction, Colorado.
The timeline of events beginning March 24, 2021, when Mesa County Election
clerks began processing ballots in the 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election,
follows.
March 24, 2021 – March 30, 2021, 2:43 PM
On these first seven days of counting, up until 2:43 PM on March 30, 2021, 88
batches of ballots, consisting of 8,540 ballots, were processed. County Election
clerks report no unusual activity or errors encountered
at any time during the
election counting process. The Adjudication database used at this time contains

Page 20 of 88
records of all batches with a sequential load order of 1 to 88, and other tables
within it record each ballot. Those which were selected for Manual Adjudication
(339 in total) have the proper status records indicating the normal adjudication
steps occurred.
March 30, 2021, 2:58 PM
According to the data contained in the EMS server, new Adjudication and
Tabulation databases were created and registered within the DVS system as the
associated databases for the election. As in the circumstance previously
described in the early voting period for the November 2020 election, these two
databases initially contained no data.
See Appendix D for a list of all commands executed prior to and after the
database creation in the April 2021 Municipal Election, which provides a precise
timeline of the effects of creating the new databases and copying the batch and
ballot records.
It is important to note that this unauthorized procedure copied the records of
only selected batches of ballots, indicating that this was an intentional act.
Below is a screenshot of the beginning of the list of batches recorded in the
original Adjudication database, sorted by the order that they were loaded:

Page 21 of 88
Figure 5. List of Batches Recorded in the Original Adjudication Database, Sorted by Load Order

Below is a screenshot of the same table in the newly created Adjudication
database, sorted by creation time:

Page 22 of 88
Figure 6. List of Batches in the Newly Created Adjudication Database, Sorted by Creation Time

March 30, 2021, 3:00 PM – 3:03 PM
During this three-minute time period, records of 42 batches and the 4,082 ballots
contained within them, previously processed into the original Adjudication
database, were copied into the new Adjudication database. According to the time
stamps, the records of the batches appeared in the new Adjudication database
in intervals of a fraction of a second between them, much too quickly for the
ballots contained in the batches to have been physically scanned (per the
maximum scanning speeds discussed above). Mesa County election clerks state
that they did not take any action to reprocess or re-scan any batches on that
day, nor did they at any time stop and restart the Adjudication software process.
Only 39 ballots in these 42 batches went through manual adjudication after
being copied to the new database, and database records indicate that the
adjudication process was completed successfully on those 39 ballots.

Page 23 of 88
Unlike what was found in the November 2020 General Election records described
above, the records for these 42 batches which were copied to the new database
do not appear in the new Adjudication database in exactly the same order as
they had originally been loaded; 12 batch records are out of order when the
records in the original Adjudication database and the new Adjudication database
are compared.
No further anomalies are shown in the Adjudication database records during the
Election counting process, nor did Mesa County election clerks encounter any
unexpected issues.
Of the 42 batches which were processed twice (batches 45 through 49 and 51
through 88), the ballot counts (total number of ballots) match between the old
and new Adjudication databases. However, DVS software sent 339 ballots to
manual adjudication the first time they were processed in the original
Adjudication database, but when reprocessed in the new Adjudication database
the software sent just 39 ballots to manual adjudication.
The same ballots run through the same hardware and evaluated by the same
software should have had the same resulting ballots marked for adjudication,
but they did not. This leads to the logical critical conclusion that not all the
ballots in the batches processed after the database copy were the same and had
the same votes as the ballots in the same batches processed before the database
copy. There is no record remaining of the votes originally recorded from the
ballots, and therefore there can be no certainty that the votes now recorded are
the same. In essence, the chain of custody has been broken for these votes in
the database.
The 46 batches which were
not duplicated in the new Adjudication database
must also be seen as suspect, as their chain of custody has also been broken via
the fact that no record of them or their adjudication exists in the Adjudication
database in use at the end of the election. A clerk wishing to view the
adjudication status of a ballot in any of these 46 batches would be unable to do

Page 24 of 88
so, as no information about these batches exists in the new Adjudication
database.
Thus, all 8,540 ballots processed before 2:58 PM on March 30, 2021, comprising
over 49% of the total votes in the entire 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election,
cannot be verified and should not have been counted. These 8,540 ballots
represent more than twice the winning margin in any of the four City Council
races that occurred in this election.
III. Comparison of the November 2020 General Election Findings and the
April 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election Findings
Comparing the above findings for the two elections shows numerous similarities
and also critical differences.
Similarities:
In both elections, a software process running within the DVS system
performed an unauthorized creation of new Adjudication and Tabulation
databases.
In both elections, database records of selected batches and of the ballots
within those batches were copied into the new databases and were
reprocessed.
In both elections, selected batches were not copied to the new Adjudication
and Tabulation databases, making adjudication information invisible to the
Mesa County election clerks.
Differences:
In the November 2020 General Election, records of a sequential series of
batches and the ballots contained within them were copied from the original
Adjudication and Tabulation databases to the new Adjudication and
Tabulation databases, and the batches were copied in the same order as in
the original databases. In the April 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election,
records of a non-sequential series of batches and the ballots contained within

Page 25 of 88
them were copied, and they appear in the new Adjudication database in a
different order than in the original database.
In the April 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election, the EMS User Logs
(which show events and commands which were executed) show reference to
a batch 89. As there were 88 batches in the original Adjudication database,
this would have logically been the next batch received from the scanners.
However, no record of a batch with the load order ‘89’ exists in either
Adjudication database, and there are missing load orders between 88 and 114
as well.
The similarities lead to the conclusion that the same method was used to alter
the database records in both elections.
The differences lead to the conclusion that there is a degree of control in the
method used to alter the database records which used parameters unique to
each election.
IV. Summary Impact of Above Findings
This manipulation of batch and ballot records described above is significant for
three reasons.
First, when the ballots were reprocessed as described above, including readjudication, it is logical to conclude that whatever votes had been initially
recorded could well have been replaced by the reprocessed votes in the Main
election database. The differences in the Manual Adjudication numbers certainly
supports this possible conclusion. Thus, this procedure could change votes in the
Main database without leaving any evidence to indicate changes had been made,
or any way to determine the nature of the changes or what the original vote data
was.
Second, the adjudication status (including the timestamps of adjudication
events, the results of the adjudication, and the user who performed the

Page 26 of 88
adjudication) of any ballots in the batches not copied to the new Adjudication
database would not be viewable through the DVS client software applications.
Third, an examination of the EMS server which was less rigorous than ours would
not likely have caught the fact that the Adjudication and Tabulation databases
used at the end of the elections were not the same, nor did they contain the
same records, as the databases used at the beginning of the elections. This leads
to the possible conclusion that some batches and ballots were excluded from the
new databases so as to inhibit the possibility of their being audited or examined.
V. Lack of Referential Integrity in DVS Database Tables
Most modern database designs include a concept called “referential integrity.”
For example, if you have one table of data that has information about “people,”
and another table that has information about “colleges,” you might have a field
in an individual record in the “people’s” table that can contain an id, or pointer,
to the college he or she attended. Referential integrity, in this case, would mean
that if “John Smith’s” record had a pointer to the “University of Pittsburgh”, the
system should give an error if you try to remove the item “University of
Pittsburgh” from the “colleges” table. It would not allow you to do this action
because a field in “John Smith’s” record refers to the college “University of
Pittsburgh” and deleting that entry in the “colleges” table makes “John Smith’s”
record invalid.
However, some of the DVS Election Management System data structures have no
such referential integrity built into them. Therefore, batch records in one
database could be deleted without any consequence to records that point to that
batch in another database, and without any detection of the error. This lack of
referential integrity means that vote or ballot information could easily be added
or removed from one part of the database without any warnings or errors
occurring in other parts of the various databases.
It is, for example, possible to change the fields with vote counts in one table of
the Main election database without having that change affect any other tables

Page 27 of 88
or cause a referential integrity violation. This is a fundamental and critical breach
of sound database design, particularly considering the importance of chain-ofcustody and audit trail evidence for the provenance of ballot record and
tabulated vote information in a voting system.
Please see Reference D for an example of how the batch and ballot data moves
through the various databases and tables in the Dominion EMS.
VI. Digital Ballot Images are Obfuscated and Unverifiable
An attempt was made to investigate the conditions of the digital ballot images
to corroborate the findings above. This avenue of research is greatly hindered
because the ballot IDs or sequence numbers in the batches are not relatable to
their images, not even within the DVS databases themselves. This is an additional
example of a lack of referential integrity within the system.
Additionally, the digital ballot images do not have the accompanying “.sha” files
which are meant to prove the authenticity of the ballots. Therefore, any findings,
including the integrity and authenticity of ballot images, related to the digital
ballot images cannot be absolutely validated because there is no proof that the
images are the ones created at the time the ballots were first processed.
Finally, code running within the EMS server that has the system access rights to
create and alter SQL Server database records could be used to alter the stored
digital ballot images themselves. The EMS Adjudication module software already
has the capability of altering scanned images and legitimately does so for each
manually adjudicated ballot.
DISCUSSION
The events described above show a significant manipulation of a large number
of batch, ballot, and vote records in the DVS EMS Database in Mesa County, and
there are only a few possible explanations for the manipulation.

Page 28 of 88
1. Human Error
Extensive questioning of Mesa County election clerks has ruled out human
error as the reason for the unauthorized creation of election databases on
October 21, 2020, followed by reprocessing of 20,346 ballots. These
personnel have a strong recollection of the events of October 21, 2020, and
because of the timelines established both by their recollection and
corresponding database time stamps, it is evident that any and all unusual
actions they might have taken on that day were in response to the new
database’s creation having already occurred, and batch records being
copied into the new database, which affected their ability to complete
adjudication on some in-process ballots. Similarly, Mesa County election
officials have a strong recollection of the events of March 30, 2021. They
state that they did not take any steps that would have given rise to the
unauthorized creation of new election databases during the 2021 Grand
Junction Municipal Election on that day, followed by the reprocessing of
2,974 ballots,.
2. Software Failure
While an error or failure in the DVS EMS server is a possibility, it strains
credulity that any error could cause the numerous specific events which are
documented above. In particular, the non-sequential reloading of the
batches during the 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election, when
compared with the sequential reloading in the November 2020 General
Election, makes it inherently impossible for the same error to have caused
both chains of events.
However, as noted in the section above labelled “Algorithmically Triggered”,
the DVS EMS server (or another connected machine running Dominion
software) could have been preprogrammed to perform the unauthorized
new database creations and the selected record manipulation which
followed based on preprogrammed criteria related to the election results
at the time. This would be the result of advance planning in the deliberate

Page 29 of 88
design of the software to alter outcomes when unexpected voting patterns
were detected.
3. Network Breach or Pre-Installation of Manipulating Software or
Algorithm
A device external to the DVS D-Suite network could have connected to the
DVS D-Suite and to the EMS server, using the open SQL Server port 1433,
open Web Services port 80, or through any other open port directly into the
DVS Software. As outlined in “Report #2, Forensic Examination and Analysis
Report” by D. Gould, there are numerous flaws in the security of the server,
many of which could provide an outside entity with direct access to the SQL
Server Database or the Application itself. The DVS D-Suite makes use of
“SOAP” messaging protocol API calls through its web server, so malicious
procedures could be triggered by simple port 80 access.
All Windows log files which would show these network accesses are
configured, as specified by DVS manuals published by the Colorado
Secretary of State as mandatory technical procedures for County election
officials, to keep only a small amount of log entries before they are
overwritten. Therefore, no record of external access to the DVS D-Suite is
available in Windows logs.
Regardless of whether the voting system was connected to an external
network or device, even momentarily, or whether a pre-installed software
or algorithm was triggered by an external command or complex set of
variable conditions, the execution of manipulating software or algorithm
could plausibly be responsible for the results described in our findings.

Page 30 of 88
CONCLUSIONS
1. Unauthorized creation of new Tabulation and Adjudication databases
occurred during the counting of the November 2020 General Election, along
with the selective copying of batch and ballot records from the original
databases to the new ones. This manipulation places all 25,913 initial
ballots counted into a state where they cannot be validated – some because
it is possible that their vote information was changed, and unverifiable that
it was not, and the rest because their “chain of evidence” has been
intentionally obfuscated. Even if the count and content of ballot images
match the numbers and counts reported by the database, there is no
method to validate those ballot images due to missing “.sha” files, which
are intended to provide such validation.
2. Unauthorized creation of new Tabulation and Adjudication databases
occurred during the 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Election, along with
the selective copying of batch and ballot records from the original
databases to the new ones. This places all 8,540 initial ballots counted into
a state where they cannot be validated – some because it is possible that
their vote information was changed and unverifiable that it was not, and
some because their “chain of evidence” has been intentionally obfuscated.
3. As we have found evidence that thousands of ballot records have had their
validity placed in serious question, none of the election results from the
2020 General or 2021 Grand Junction Municipal Elections in Mesa County
can be considered trustworthy. If Mesa County has preserved the respective
paper ballots, as they are required to do by law, and those ballots were
forensically authenticated with confirmed chain-of-custody from eligible
electors to sworn county election officials (not possible retrospectively, nor
under current election procedures in Colorado), then a hand-count of paper
ballots might support a verifiable, trustworthy conclusion about the countylevel results of these two elections.
4. Because the unauthorized methods used to alter batch and ballot-level
information described above are available within the DVS EMS server, this

Page 31 of 88
system cannot be considered reliable for use in any election. An
investigation, involving all physical and cyber evidence, including a source
code audit of the exact, verifiable version of all DVS-supplied executable
and library files, is necessary to identify the exact software methods used
to produce the manipulation and to determine other potential unauthorized
actions that the code is able to cause or enable.
5. The Dominion Voting System’s database structure stores actual vote
information in only one table, in aggregated form, so alterations made to
vote counts or candidates in just that table, create a single point of attack
or failure for the entire vote reporting process (see Reference D).

Page 32 of 88
APPENDIX A – BATCHES – ORIGINAL ADJUDICATION DATABASE
(WITH TIME BETWEEN BATCHES) – NOVEMBER 2020 ELECTION
TabulatorId BatchId LoadOrder Creation Date

Creation Time
12:07:41 PM
12:07:44 PM
12:07:48 PM
12:07:51 PM
12:07:54 PM
12:08:12 PM
12:08:16 PM
12:08:20 PM
12:08:24 PM
12:08:28 PM
12:23:35 PM
12:30:26 PM
12:32:30 PM
12:36:20 PM
12:43:25 PM
1:50:29 PM
1:54:19 PM
1:58:24 PM
2:03:29 PM
2:06:33 PM
2:10:23 PM
2:14:28 PM
2:18:33 PM
2:22:23 PM
2:26:27 PM
2:30:32 PM
2:34:23 PM
2:36:27 PM
2:40:30 PM
2:44:20 PM
2:48:25 PM
2:51:29 PM
2:57:21 PM
2:59:26 PM
3:05:31 PM
3:06:20 PM
3:09:24 PM
3:10:28 PM
3:12:33 PM
Prior
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:03
0:00:03
0:00:18
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:15:07
0:06:50
0:02:04
0:03:50
0:07:05
1:07:03
0:03:50
0:04:05
0:05:05
0:03:05
0:03:50
0:04:05
0:04:05
0:03:50
0:04:05
0:04:05
0:03:51
0:02:04
0:04:03
0:03:51
0:04:05
0:03:04
0:05:52
0:02:04
0:06:05
0:00:49
0:03:05
0:01:04
0:02:04

Difference from
Ballots
10 4001 1 10/19/2020 100
10 4002 2 10/19/2020 42
10 4003 3 10/19/2020 100
10 4004 4 10/19/2020 100
10 4005 5 10/19/2020 100
10 4006 6 10/19/2020 100
10 4007 7 10/19/2020 100
10 4008 8 10/19/2020 99
10 4009 9 10/19/2020 100
10 4010 10 10/19/2020 100
4 2001 11 10/19/2020 98
4 2002 12 10/19/2020 100
4 2003 13 10/19/2020 100
4 2004 14 10/19/2020 100
4 2005 15 10/19/2020 100
4 2006 16 10/19/2020 100
4 2007 17 10/19/2020 100
4 2008 18 10/19/2020 100
4 2009 19 10/19/2020 100
4 2010 20 10/19/2020 100
4 2011 21 10/19/2020 99
4 2012 22 10/19/2020 100
4 2013 23 10/19/2020 100
4 2014 24 10/19/2020 100
4 2015 25 10/19/2020 100
4 2016 26 10/19/2020 100
4 2017 27 10/19/2020 100
4 2018 28 10/19/2020 33
4 2019 29 10/19/2020 100
4 2020 30 10/19/2020 100
4 2021 31 10/19/2020 99
4 2022 32 10/19/2020 100
4 2023 33 10/19/2020 99
4 2024 34 10/19/2020 100
10 4011 35 10/19/2020 100
4 2025 36 10/19/2020 100
10 4012 37 10/19/2020 100
4 2026 38 10/19/2020 99
10 4013 39 10/19/2020 100

Page 33 of 88
4 2027 40 10/19/2020 3:15:22 PM 0:02:49 100
10 4014 41 10/19/2020 3:16:26 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2028 42 10/19/2020 3:17:33 PM 0:01:07 100
4 2029 43 10/19/2020 3:19:22 PM 0:01:49 25
4 2030 44 10/19/2020 3:22:24 PM 0:03:02 100
10 4015 45 10/19/2020 3:24:29 PM 0:02:04 99
4 2031 46 10/19/2020 3:29:34 PM 0:05:05 100
10 4016 47 10/19/2020 3:30:23 PM 0:00:49 100
4 2032 48 10/19/2020 3:34:28 PM 0:04:05 99
10 4017 49 10/19/2020 3:34:32 PM 0:00:04 100
10 4018 50 10/19/2020 3:40:22 PM 0:05:50 100
10 4019 51 10/19/2020 3:44:26 PM 0:04:05 100
10 4020 52 10/19/2020 3:48:31 PM 0:04:05 99
4 2033 53 10/19/2020 4:00:24 PM 0:11:53 100
10 4021 54 10/19/2020 4:00:43 PM 0:00:19 99
4 2034 55 10/19/2020 4:03:33 PM 0:02:49 100
10 4022 56 10/19/2020 4:03:37 PM 0:00:04 100
10 4023 57 10/19/2020 4:05:26 PM 0:01:49 78
4 2035 58 10/19/2020 4:09:30 PM 0:04:04 100
10 4024 59 10/19/2020 4:09:34 PM 0:00:04 100
10 4025 60 10/19/2020 4:12:24 PM 0:02:50 99
4 2036 61 10/19/2020 4:13:28 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4026 62 10/19/2020 4:15:33 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2037 63 10/19/2020 4:16:22 PM 0:00:49 99
10 4027 64 10/19/2020 4:19:26 PM 0:03:04 100
10 4028 65 10/19/2020 4:22:31 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2038 66 10/19/2020 4:24:20 PM 0:01:50 100
4 2039 67 10/19/2020 4:28:25 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2040 68 10/19/2020 4:32:30 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2041 69 10/19/2020 4:35:22 PM 0:02:52 100
10 4029 70 10/19/2020 4:37:26 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2042 71 10/19/2020 4:41:31 PM 0:04:05 99
10 4030 72 10/19/2020 4:41:35 PM 0:00:04 99
4 2043 73 10/19/2020 4:46:25 PM 0:04:50 100
10 4031 74 10/19/2020 4:49:29 PM 0:03:05 97
10 4032 75 10/19/2020 4:53:34 PM 0:04:05 99
10 4033 76 10/19/2020 4:55:23 PM 0:01:49 100
4 2044 77 10/19/2020 4:57:27 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4034 78 10/19/2020 4:58:32 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2045 79 10/19/2020 5:00:22 PM 0:01:51 99
10 4035 80 10/19/2020 5:03:27 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4036 81 10/19/2020 5:06:31 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2046 82 10/19/2020 5:16:22 PM 0:09:51 99
4 2047 83 10/19/2020 5:18:28 PM 0:02:06 100
10 4037 84 10/19/2020 5:18:32 PM 0:00:04 100

Page 34 of 88
4 2048 85 10/19/2020 5:22:22 PM 0:03:51 99
4 2049 86 10/20/2020 10:05:36 AM 16:43:13 100
4 2050 87 10/20/2020 10:07:25 AM 0:01:49 100
4 2051 88 10/20/2020 10:10:30 AM 0:03:05 99
4 2052 89 10/20/2020 10:13:35 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2053 90 10/20/2020 10:17:26 AM 0:03:51 100
4 2054 91 10/20/2020 10:29:33 AM 0:12:06 100
4 2055 92 10/20/2020 10:32:37 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2056 93 10/20/2020 10:40:29 AM 0:07:51 100
4 2057 94 10/20/2020 10:43:33 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2058 95 10/20/2020 10:50:38 AM 0:07:05 99
4 2059 96 10/20/2020 10:53:28 AM 0:02:49 100
4 2060 97 10/20/2020 10:56:32 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2061 98 10/20/2020 10:59:37 AM 0:03:04 100
4 2062 99 10/20/2020 11:02:27 AM 0:02:50 98
4 2063 100 10/20/2020 11:05:31 AM 0:03:04 100
4 2064 101 10/20/2020 11:08:36 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2065 102 10/20/2020 11:11:26 AM 0:02:50 100
4 2066 103 10/20/2020 11:16:31 AM 0:05:05 100
4 2067 104 10/20/2020 11:19:35 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2068 105 10/20/2020 11:22:40 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2069 106 10/20/2020 11:26:29 AM 0:03:50 99
4 2070 107 10/20/2020 11:30:34 AM 0:04:05 94
4 2071 108 10/20/2020 11:33:38 AM 0:03:04 100
4 2072 109 10/20/2020 11:38:28 AM 0:04:50 100
4 2073 110 10/20/2020 11:43:33 AM 0:05:05 100
10 4038 111 10/20/2020 11:43:37 AM 0:00:04 99
10 4039 112 10/20/2020 11:48:28 AM 0:04:50 100
10 4040 113 10/20/2020 11:50:32 AM 0:02:04 99
4 2074 114 10/20/2020 11:52:36 AM 0:02:04 99
10 4041 115 10/20/2020 11:55:28 AM 0:02:51 100
4 2075 116 10/20/2020 11:56:32 AM 0:01:04 99
10 4042 117 10/20/2020 11:58:36 AM 0:02:04 100
10 4043 118 10/20/2020 12:02:26 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4044 119 10/20/2020 12:05:31 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2076 120 10/20/2020 12:07:35 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2077 121 10/20/2020 12:13:40 PM 0:06:05 100
10 4045 122 10/20/2020 12:13:44 PM 0:00:04 100
4 2078 123 10/20/2020 12:16:34 PM 0:02:50 99
10 4046 124 10/20/2020 12:16:38 PM 0:00:04 100
4 2079 125 10/20/2020 12:19:28 PM 0:02:50 99
10 4047 126 10/20/2020 12:19:46 PM 0:00:19 99
4 2080 127 10/20/2020 12:22:36 PM 0:02:49 99
10 4048 128 10/20/2020 12:22:40 PM 0:00:04 100
4 2081 129 10/20/2020 12:25:30 PM 0:02:50 100

Page 35 of 88
10 4049 130 10/20/2020 12:30:35 PM 0:05:05 100
4 2082 131 10/20/2020 1:08:32 PM 0:37:57 100
10 4050 132 10/20/2020 1:11:37 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2083 133 10/20/2020 1:14:29 PM 0:02:52 100
10 4051 134 10/20/2020 1:14:48 PM 0:00:19 100
4 2084 135 10/20/2020 1:16:37 PM 0:01:49 100
10 4052 136 10/20/2020 1:18:26 PM 0:01:49 100
4 2085 137 10/20/2020 1:20:30 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4053 138 10/20/2020 1:21:35 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2086 139 10/20/2020 1:22:39 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4054 140 10/20/2020 1:27:29 PM 0:04:50 100
10 4055 141 10/20/2020 1:31:34 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2087 142 10/20/2020 1:33:38 PM 0:02:04 98
4 2088 143 10/20/2020 1:37:28 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4056 144 10/20/2020 1:47:34 PM 0:10:06 97
4 2089 145 10/20/2020 1:53:39 PM 0:06:05 100
4 2090 146 10/20/2020 1:58:30 PM 0:04:51 99
10 4057 147 10/20/2020 2:02:35 PM 0:04:05 96
4 2091 148 10/20/2020 2:04:39 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2092 149 10/20/2020 2:07:29 PM 0:02:49 100
10 4058 150 10/20/2020 2:07:47 PM 0:00:18 97
4 2093 151 10/20/2020 2:10:37 PM 0:02:49 100
4 2094 152 10/20/2020 2:14:28 PM 0:03:52 100
4 2095 153 10/20/2020 2:19:33 PM 0:05:05 97
4 2096 154 10/20/2020 2:23:38 PM 0:04:05 99
7 3001 155 10/20/2020 2:26:28 PM 0:02:50 100
7 3002 156 10/20/2020 2:29:32 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2097 157 10/20/2020 2:31:37 PM 0:02:04 100
7 3003 158 10/20/2020 2:32:26 PM 0:00:49 100
7 3004 159 10/20/2020 2:36:31 PM 0:04:05 98
4 2098 160 10/20/2020 2:38:36 PM 0:02:05 100
7 3005 161 10/20/2020 2:39:40 PM 0:01:04 98
4 2099 162 10/20/2020 2:42:29 PM 0:02:49 99
7 3006 163 10/20/2020 2:43:33 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2100 164 10/20/2020 2:46:38 PM 0:03:05 100
7 3007 165 10/20/2020 2:47:27 PM 0:00:49 100
4 2101 166 10/20/2020 2:49:32 PM 0:02:05 100
7 3008 167 10/20/2020 2:51:36 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2102 168 10/20/2020 2:57:29 PM 0:05:53 97
7 3009 169 10/20/2020 2:57:47 PM 0:00:18 95
4 2103 170 10/20/2020 3:00:37 PM 0:02:49 99
7 3010 171 10/20/2020 3:01:41 PM 0:01:04 99
4 2104 172 10/20/2020 3:04:33 PM 0:02:53 99
7 3011 173 10/20/2020 3:04:37 PM 0:00:04 98
4 2105 174 10/20/2020 3:07:28 PM 0:02:51 100

Page 36 of 88
7 3012 175 10/20/2020 3:07:47 PM 0:00:19 100
7 3013 176 10/20/2020 3:10:36 PM 0:02:50 98
4 2106 177 10/20/2020 3:12:41 PM 0:02:04 95
7 3014 178 10/20/2020 3:13:30 PM 0:00:49 100
4 2107 179 10/20/2020 3:21:35 PM 0:08:06 95
7 3015 180 10/20/2020 3:23:39 PM 0:02:04 94
4 2108 181 10/20/2020 3:25:30 PM 0:01:50 100
7 3016 182 10/20/2020 3:25:50 PM 0:00:20 100
7 3017 183 10/20/2020 3:29:39 PM 0:03:50 100
4 2109 184 10/20/2020 3:30:29 PM 0:00:50 94
7 3018 185 10/20/2020 3:35:34 PM 0:05:05 97
7 3019 186 10/20/2020 3:59:43 PM 0:24:09 95
2 1001 187 10/20/2020 4:02:32 PM 0:02:49 75
7 3020 188 10/20/2020 4:03:36 PM 0:01:03 99
7 3021 189 10/20/2020 4:06:40 PM 0:03:04 99
7 3022 190 10/20/2020 4:10:30 PM 0:03:50 99
7 3023 191 10/20/2020 4:13:34 PM 0:03:05 100
7 3024 192 10/20/2020 4:22:40 PM 0:09:06 99
4 2110 193 10/20/2020 4:24:30 PM 0:01:50 98
7 3025 194 10/20/2020 4:26:34 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2111 195 10/20/2020 4:28:38 PM 0:02:04 100
7 3026 196 10/20/2020 4:29:30 PM 0:00:51 100
7 3027 197 10/20/2020 4:34:35 PM 0:05:05 100
7 3028 198 10/20/2020 4:38:39 PM 0:04:05 100
2 1002 199 10/20/2020 4:46:29 PM 0:07:50 21
2 1003 200 10/20/2020 4:56:34 PM 0:10:04 75
2 1004 201 10/20/2020 4:57:37 PM 0:01:03 80
4 2112 202 10/21/2020 9:05:41 AM 16:08:04 99
4 2113 203 10/21/2020 9:07:45 AM 0:02:04 95
4 2114 204 10/21/2020 9:10:35 AM 0:02:50 98
4 2115 205 10/21/2020 9:14:40 AM 0:04:05 96
4 2116 206 10/21/2020 9:18:45 AM 0:04:05 99
4 2117 207 10/21/2020 9:20:34 AM 0:01:49 100
4 2118 208 10/21/2020 9:22:38 AM 0:02:04 100
4 2119 209 10/21/2020 9:28:44 AM 0:06:05 100
4 2120 210 10/21/2020 9:33:35 AM 0:04:51 100
4 2121 211 10/21/2020 9:36:39 AM 0:03:04 100
4 2122 212 10/21/2020 9:39:44 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2123 213 10/21/2020 9:42:35 AM 0:02:51 100
2 1005 214 10/21/2020 9:50:40 AM 0:08:05 68
2 1006 215 10/21/2020 9:54:43 AM 0:04:03 37
2 1007 216 10/21/2020 9:56:45 AM 0:02:02 76
2 1008 217 10/21/2020 10:14:37 AM 0:17:51 14
10 4059 218 10/21/2020 10:16:39 AM 0:02:02 100
10 4060 219 10/21/2020 10:25:45 AM 0:09:06 100

Page 37 of 88
10 4061 220 10/21/2020

10:28:34 AM
10:32:39 AM
10:34:43 AM
10:37:35 AM
10:40:39 AM
10:43:44 AM
10:47:34 AM
10:51:39 AM
10:56:44 AM
10:59:33 AM
11:02:38 AM
11:05:42 AM
11:21:37 AM
11:27:42 AM
11:35:47 AM
11:38:37 AM
11:41:41 AM
11:46:46 AM
11:49:36 AM
11:53:41 AM
12:00:46 PM
12:02:36 PM
12:05:40 PM
12:08:45 PM
12:12:35 PM
12:15:40 PM
12:50:37 PM
12:53:41 PM
12:55:46 PM
12:58:35 PM
1:03:42 PM
1:08:46 PM
1:10:37 PM
1:13:41 PM
1:16:45 PM
1:19:35 PM
1:23:41 PM
1:28:46 PM
1:29:34 PM
1:34:38 PM
1:50:46 PM
1:53:37 PM
1:57:42 PM
2:00:50 PM
2:05:40 PM
0:02:50
0:04:05
0:02:04
0:02:51
0:03:05
0:03:05
0:03:51
0:04:05
0:05:05
0:02:49
0:03:05
0:03:05
0:15:54
0:06:05
0:08:06
0:02:49
0:03:05
0:05:05
0:02:50
0:04:05
0:07:05
0:01:49
0:03:05
0:03:05
0:03:50
0:03:05
0:34:57
0:03:04
0:02:04
0:02:50
0:05:06
0:05:05
0:01:50
0:03:04
0:03:04
0:02:50
0:04:05
0:05:05
0:00:49
0:05:04
0:16:07
0:02:51
0:04:05
0:03:09
0:04:50

100
10 4062 221 10/21/2020 98
10 4063 222 10/21/2020 100
10 4064 223 10/21/2020 100
10 4065 224 10/21/2020 100
10 4066 225 10/21/2020 100
10 4067 226 10/21/2020 99
10 4068 227 10/21/2020 100
10 4069 228 10/21/2020 100
10 4070 229 10/21/2020 100
10 4071 230 10/21/2020 99
10 4072 231 10/21/2020 100
10 4073 232 10/21/2020 100
10 4074 233 10/21/2020 100
10 4075 234 10/21/2020 97
10 4076 235 10/21/2020 100
10 4077 236 10/21/2020 100
10 4078 237 10/21/2020 100
10 4079 238 10/21/2020 100
10 4080 239 10/21/2020 100
10 4081 240 10/21/2020 101
10 4082 241 10/21/2020 100
10 4083 242 10/21/2020 100
10 4084 243 10/21/2020 100
10 4085 244 10/21/2020 100
10 4086 245 10/21/2020 98
10 4087 246 10/21/2020 98
10 4088 247 10/21/2020 95
10 4089 248 10/21/2020 97
10 4090 249 10/21/2020 98
10 4091 250 10/21/2020 95
10 4092 251 10/21/2020 98
10 4093 252 10/21/2020 98
10 4094 253 10/21/2020 95
10 4095 254 10/21/2020 97
10 4096 255 10/21/2020 96
10 4097 256 10/21/2020 95
10 4098 257 10/21/2020 100
10 4099 258 10/21/2020 63
10 4100 259 10/21/2020 100
7 3029 260 10/21/2020 100
7 3030 261 10/21/2020 100
7 3031 262 10/21/2020 100
7 3032 263 10/21/2020 100
7 3033 264 10/21/2020 100

Page 38 of 88
7 3034 265 10/21/2020 2:08:46 PM 0:03:05 100
7 3035 266 10/21/2020 2:11:35 PM 0:02:50 100
7 3036 267 10/21/2020 2:14:40 PM 0:03:05 99

Page 39 of 88
APPENDIX B – BATCHES – NEW ADJUDICATION DATABASE
(WITH TIME BETWEEN BATCHES) – NOVEMBER 2020 ELECTION
TabulatorId BatchId CvrBatchId LoadOrder Creation Date

Creation Time
2:20:07 PM
2:20:26 PM
2:20:30 PM
2:20:34 PM
2:20:39 PM
2:20:43 PM
2:20:47 PM
2:20:52 PM
2:20:56 PM
2:21:00 PM
2:21:04 PM
2:21:08 PM
2:21:13 PM
2:21:17 PM
2:21:21 PM
2:21:25 PM
2:21:29 PM
2:21:34 PM
2:21:40 PM
2:21:44 PM
2:21:48 PM
2:21:53 PM
2:21:57 PM
2:22:01 PM
2:22:05 PM
2:22:09 PM
2:22:13 PM
2:22:17 PM
2:22:21 PM
2:22:25 PM
2:22:30 PM
2:22:34 PM
2:22:38 PM
2:22:42 PM
2:22:46 PM
2:22:50 PM
2:22:54 PM
2:22:58 PM
2:23:02 PM
Prior
0:00:19
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:06
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04

Difference
from
Ballots
10 4001 1 1 10/21/2020 100
10 4025 60 60 10/21/2020 99
4 2036 61 61 10/21/2020 100
10 4026 62 62 10/21/2020 100
4 2037 63 63 10/21/2020 99
10 4027 64 64 10/21/2020 100
10 4028 65 65 10/21/2020 100
4 2038 66 66 10/21/2020 100
4 2039 67 67 10/21/2020 100
4 2040 68 68 10/21/2020 100
4 2041 69 69 10/21/2020 100
10 4029 70 70 10/21/2020 100
4 2042 71 71 10/21/2020 99
10 4030 72 72 10/21/2020 99
4 2043 73 73 10/21/2020 100
10 4031 74 74 10/21/2020 97
10 4032 75 75 10/21/2020 99
10 4033 76 76 10/21/2020 100
4 2044 77 77 10/21/2020 100
10 4034 78 78 10/21/2020 100
4 2045 79 79 10/21/2020 99
10 4035 80 80 10/21/2020 100
10 4036 81 81 10/21/2020 100
4 2046 82 82 10/21/2020 99
4 2047 83 83 10/21/2020 100
10 4037 84 84 10/21/2020 100
4 2048 85 85 10/21/2020 99
4 2049 86 86 10/21/2020 100
4 2050 87 87 10/21/2020 100
4 2051 88 88 10/21/2020 99
4 2052 89 89 10/21/2020 100
4 2053 90 90 10/21/2020 100
4 2054 91 91 10/21/2020 100
4 2055 92 92 10/21/2020 100
4 2056 93 93 10/21/2020 100
4 2057 94 94 10/21/2020 100
4 2058 95 95 10/21/2020 99
4 2059 96 96 10/21/2020 100
4 2060 97 97 10/21/2020 100

Page 40 of 88
4 2061 98 98 10/21/2020

2:23:06 PM
2:23:11 PM
2:23:15 PM
2:23:19 PM
2:23:23 PM
2:23:28 PM
2:23:34 PM
2:23:38 PM
2:23:42 PM
2:23:46 PM
2:23:50 PM
2:23:54 PM
2:23:58 PM
2:24:02 PM
2:24:06 PM
2:24:10 PM
2:24:14 PM
2:24:18 PM
2:24:22 PM
2:24:26 PM
2:24:31 PM
2:24:35 PM
2:24:39 PM
2:24:43 PM
2:24:48 PM
2:24:52 PM
2:24:56 PM
2:25:00 PM
2:25:05 PM
2:25:09 PM
2:25:13 PM
2:25:17 PM
2:25:22 PM
2:25:26 PM
2:25:30 PM
2:25:35 PM
2:25:39 PM
2:25:44 PM
2:25:49 PM
2:25:53 PM
2:25:57 PM
2:26:01 PM
2:26:05 PM
2:26:09 PM
2:26:13 PM
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:06
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04

100
4 2062 99 99 10/21/2020 98
4 2063 100 100 10/21/2020 100
4 2064 101 101 10/21/2020 100
4 2065 102 102 10/21/2020 100
4 2066 103 103 10/21/2020 100
4 2067 104 104 10/21/2020 100
4 2068 105 105 10/21/2020 100
4 2069 106 106 10/21/2020 99
4 2070 107 107 10/21/2020 94
4 2071 108 108 10/21/2020 100
4 2072 109 109 10/21/2020 100
4 2073 110 110 10/21/2020 100
10 4038 111 111 10/21/2020 99
10 4039 112 112 10/21/2020 100
10 4040 113 113 10/21/2020 99
4 2074 114 114 10/21/2020 99
10 4041 115 115 10/21/2020 100
4 2075 116 116 10/21/2020 99
10 4042 117 117 10/21/2020 100
10 4043 118 118 10/21/2020 100
10 4044 119 119 10/21/2020 100
4 2076 120 120 10/21/2020 100
4 2077 121 121 10/21/2020 100
10 4045 122 122 10/21/2020 100
4 2078 123 123 10/21/2020 99
10 4046 124 124 10/21/2020 100
4 2079 125 125 10/21/2020 99
10 4047 126 126 10/21/2020 99
4 2080 127 127 10/21/2020 99
10 4048 128 128 10/21/2020 100
4 2081 129 129 10/21/2020 100
10 4049 130 130 10/21/2020 100
4 2082 131 131 10/21/2020 100
10 4050 132 132 10/21/2020 100
4 2083 133 133 10/21/2020 100
10 4051 134 134 10/21/2020 100
4 2084 135 135 10/21/2020 100
10 4052 136 136 10/21/2020 100
4 2085 137 137 10/21/2020 100
10 4053 138 138 10/21/2020 100
4 2086 139 139 10/21/2020 100
10 4054 140 140 10/21/2020 100
10 4055 141 141 10/21/2020 100
4 2087 142 142 10/21/2020 98

Page 41 of 88
4 2088 143 143 10/21/2020

2:26:17 PM
2:26:21 PM
2:26:25 PM
2:26:29 PM
2:26:33 PM
2:26:37 PM
2:26:41 PM
2:26:45 PM
2:26:49 PM
2:26:53 PM
2:26:58 PM
2:27:02 PM
2:27:06 PM
2:27:10 PM
2:27:14 PM
2:27:18 PM
2:27:22 PM
2:27:26 PM
2:27:30 PM
2:27:35 PM
2:27:39 PM
2:27:43 PM
2:27:47 PM
2:27:53 PM
2:27:58 PM
2:28:02 PM
2:28:06 PM
2:28:10 PM
2:28:14 PM
2:28:18 PM
2:28:22 PM
2:28:26 PM
2:28:30 PM
2:28:34 PM
2:28:38 PM
2:28:42 PM
2:28:47 PM
2:28:50 PM
2:28:54 PM
2:28:58 PM
2:29:02 PM
2:29:06 PM
2:29:10 PM
2:29:15 PM
2:29:19 PM
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:06
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04

100
10 4056 144 144 10/21/2020 97
4 2089 145 145 10/21/2020 100
4 2090 146 146 10/21/2020 99
10 4057 147 147 10/21/2020 96
4 2091 148 148 10/21/2020 100
4 2092 149 149 10/21/2020 100
10 4058 150 150 10/21/2020 97
4 2093 151 151 10/21/2020 100
4 2094 152 152 10/21/2020 100
4 2095 153 153 10/21/2020 97
4 2096 154 154 10/21/2020 99
7 3001 155 155 10/21/2020 100
7 3002 156 156 10/21/2020 100
4 2097 157 157 10/21/2020 100
7 3003 158 158 10/21/2020 100
7 3004 159 159 10/21/2020 98
4 2098 160 160 10/21/2020 100
7 3005 161 161 10/21/2020 98
4 2099 162 162 10/21/2020 99
7 3006 163 163 10/21/2020 100
4 2100 164 164 10/21/2020 100
7 3007 165 165 10/21/2020 100
4 2101 166 166 10/21/2020 100
7 3008 167 167 10/21/2020 100
4 2102 168 168 10/21/2020 97
7 3009 169 169 10/21/2020 95
4 2103 170 170 10/21/2020 99
7 3010 171 171 10/21/2020 99
4 2104 172 172 10/21/2020 99
7 3011 173 173 10/21/2020 98
4 2105 174 174 10/21/2020 100
7 3012 175 175 10/21/2020 100
7 3013 176 176 10/21/2020 98
4 2106 177 177 10/21/2020 95
7 3014 178 178 10/21/2020 100
4 2107 179 179 10/21/2020 95
7 3015 180 180 10/21/2020 94
4 2108 181 181 10/21/2020 100
7 3016 182 182 10/21/2020 100
7 3017 183 183 10/21/2020 100
4 2109 184 184 10/21/2020 94
7 3018 185 185 10/21/2020 97
7 3019 186 186 10/21/2020 95
2 1001 187 187 10/21/2020 75

Page 42 of 88
7 3020 188 188 10/21/2020

2:29:22 PM
2:29:26 PM
2:29:31 PM
2:29:35 PM
2:29:40 PM
2:29:44 PM
2:29:48 PM
2:29:53 PM
2:29:57 PM
2:30:01 PM
2:30:05 PM
2:30:09 PM
2:30:10 PM
2:30:14 PM
2:30:17 PM
2:30:22 PM
2:30:25 PM
2:30:29 PM
2:30:34 PM
2:30:38 PM
2:30:42 PM
2:30:46 PM
2:30:50 PM
2:30:54 PM
2:30:59 PM
2:31:03 PM
2:31:06 PM
2:31:09 PM
2:31:11 PM
2:31:14 PM
2:31:15 PM
2:31:20 PM
2:31:24 PM
2:31:28 PM
2:31:32 PM
2:31:36 PM
2:31:40 PM
2:31:44 PM
2:31:49 PM
2:31:53 PM
2:31:57 PM
2:32:02 PM
2:32:06 PM
2:32:10 PM
2:32:15 PM
0:00:03
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:02
0:00:04
0:00:03
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:03
0:00:02
0:00:03
0:00:01
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05

99
7 3021 189 189 10/21/2020 99
7 3022 190 190 10/21/2020 99
7 3023 191 191 10/21/2020 100
7 3024 192 192 10/21/2020 99
4 2110 193 193 10/21/2020 98
7 3025 194 194 10/21/2020 100
4 2111 195 195 10/21/2020 100
7 3026 196 196 10/21/2020 100
7 3027 197 197 10/21/2020 100
7 3028 198 198 10/21/2020 100
2 1002 199 199 10/21/2020 21
2 1003 200 200 10/21/2020 75
2 1004 201 201 10/21/2020 80
4 2112 202 202 10/21/2020 99
4 2113 203 203 10/21/2020 95
4 2114 204 204 10/21/2020 98
4 2115 205 205 10/21/2020 96
4 2116 206 206 10/21/2020 99
4 2117 207 207 10/21/2020 100
4 2118 208 208 10/21/2020 100
4 2119 209 209 10/21/2020 100
4 2120 210 210 10/21/2020 100
4 2121 211 211 10/21/2020 100
4 2122 212 212 10/21/2020 100
4 2123 213 213 10/21/2020 100
2 1005 214 214 10/21/2020 68
2 1006 215 215 10/21/2020 37
2 1007 216 216 10/21/2020 76
2 1008 217 217 10/21/2020 14
10 4059 218 218 10/21/2020 100
10 4060 219 219 10/21/2020 100
10 4061 220 220 10/21/2020 100
10 4062 221 221 10/21/2020 98
10 4063 222 222 10/21/2020 100
10 4064 223 223 10/21/2020 100
10 4065 224 224 10/21/2020 100
10 4066 225 225 10/21/2020 100
10 4067 226 226 10/21/2020 99
10 4068 227 227 10/21/2020 100
10 4069 228 228 10/21/2020 100
10 4070 229 229 10/21/2020 100
10 4071 230 230 10/21/2020 99
10 4072 231 231 10/21/2020 100
10 4073 232 232 10/21/2020 100

Page 43 of 88
10 4074 233 233 10/21/2020

2:32:19 PM
2:32:23 PM
2:32:27 PM
2:32:32 PM
2:32:36 PM
2:32:40 PM
2:32:44 PM
2:32:49 PM
2:32:53 PM
2:32:57 PM
2:33:02 PM
2:33:06 PM
2:33:11 PM
2:33:15 PM
2:33:19 PM
2:33:23 PM
2:33:27 PM
2:33:31 PM
2:33:35 PM
2:33:39 PM
2:33:43 PM
2:33:47 PM
2:33:51 PM
2:33:55 PM
2:33:59 PM
2:34:03 PM
2:34:06 PM
2:34:10 PM
2:34:14 PM
2:34:18 PM
2:34:22 PM
2:34:26 PM
2:34:30 PM
2:34:34 PM
2:34:38 PM
2:34:42 PM
2:39:47 PM
2:45:38 PM
2:48:42 PM
2:51:47 PM
2:55:39 PM
3:03:44 PM
3:08:37 PM
3:15:42 PM
3:25:48 PM
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:05
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:03
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:00:04
0:05:05
0:05:50
0:03:05
0:03:05
0:03:52
0:08:06
0:04:52
0:07:05
0:10:06

100
10 4075 234 234 10/21/2020 97
10 4076 235 235 10/21/2020 100
10 4077 236 236 10/21/2020 100
10 4078 237 237 10/21/2020 100
10 4079 238 238 10/21/2020 100
10 4080 239 239 10/21/2020 100
10 4081 240 240 10/21/2020 101
10 4082 241 241 10/21/2020 100
10 4083 242 242 10/21/2020 100
10 4084 243 243 10/21/2020 100
10 4085 244 244 10/21/2020 100
10 4086 245 245 10/21/2020 98
10 4087 246 246 10/21/2020 98
10 4088 247 247 10/21/2020 95
10 4089 248 248 10/21/2020 97
10 4090 249 249 10/21/2020 98
10 4091 250 250 10/21/2020 95
10 4092 251 251 10/21/2020 98
10 4093 252 252 10/21/2020 98
10 4094 253 253 10/21/2020 95
10 4095 254 254 10/21/2020 97
10 4096 255 255 10/21/2020 96
10 4097 256 256 10/21/2020 95
10 4098 257 257 10/21/2020 100
10 4099 258 258 10/21/2020 63
10 4100 259 259 10/21/2020 100
7 3029 260 260 10/21/2020 100
7 3030 261 261 10/21/2020 100
7 3031 262 262 10/21/2020 100
7 3032 263 263 10/21/2020 100
7 3033 264 264 10/21/2020 100
7 3034 265 265 10/21/2020 100
7 3035 266 266 10/21/2020 100
7 3036 267 267 10/21/2020 99
7 3037 268 268 10/21/2020 100
7 3038 269 269 10/21/2020 100
7 3039 270 270 10/21/2020 100
7 3040 271 271 10/21/2020 99
7 3041 272 272 10/21/2020 100
7 3042 273 273 10/21/2020 100
7 3043 274 274 10/21/2020 99
7 3044 275 275 10/21/2020 100
7 3045 276 276 10/21/2020 100
7 3046 277 277 10/21/2020 99

Page 44 of 88
7 3047 278 278 10/21/2020 3:30:39 PM 0:04:51 100
7 3048 279 279 10/21/2020 3:33:43 PM 0:03:05 100
7 3049 280 280 10/21/2020 3:39:50 PM 0:06:06 99
7 3050 281 281 10/21/2020 3:42:39 PM 0:02:49 98
7 3051 282 282 10/21/2020 3:45:43 PM 0:03:04 99
7 3052 283 283 10/21/2020 3:49:48 PM 0:04:05 100
7 3053 284 284 10/21/2020 3:52:38 PM 0:02:49 99
7 3054 285 285 10/21/2020 3:56:43 PM 0:04:05 100
7 3055 286 286 10/21/2020 3:58:47 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2124 287 287 10/21/2020 4:06:38 PM 0:07:52 100
4 2125 288 288 10/21/2020 4:08:43 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2126 289 289 10/21/2020 4:11:48 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2127 290 290 10/21/2020 4:19:38 PM 0:07:51 98
4 2128 291 291 10/21/2020 4:23:43 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2129 292 292 10/21/2020 4:27:48 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2130 293 293 10/21/2020 4:30:37 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2131 294 294 10/21/2020 4:35:42 PM 0:05:05 99
4 2132 295 295 10/21/2020 4:39:47 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2133 296 296 10/21/2020 4:44:37 PM 0:04:50 99
4 2134 297 297 10/21/2020 4:47:42 PM 0:03:05 99
4 2135 298 298 10/21/2020 4:51:47 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2136 299 299 10/21/2020 4:55:38 PM 0:03:51 100
4 2137 300 300 10/21/2020 5:00:42 PM 0:05:05 100
4 2138 301 301 10/21/2020 5:03:47 PM 0:03:04 100
4 2139 302 302 10/21/2020 5:06:36 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2140 303 303 10/21/2020 5:09:41 PM 0:03:04 98
4 2141 304 304 10/21/2020 5:12:45 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2142 305 305 10/21/2020 5:17:36 PM 0:04:50 100
4 2143 306 306 10/21/2020 5:24:41 PM 0:07:05 99
10 4101 307 307 10/22/2020 8:33:49 AM 100
10 4102 308 308 10/22/2020 8:41:55 AM 0:08:06 96
10 4103 309 309 10/22/2020 8:49:45 AM 0:07:50 98
4 2144 310 310 10/22/2020 8:50:50 AM 0:01:05 100
4 2145 311 311 10/22/2020 8:53:41 AM 0:02:51 100
10 4104 312 312 10/22/2020 8:56:45 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2146 313 313 10/22/2020 9:01:50 AM 0:05:05 99
4 2147 314 314 10/22/2020 9:08:43 AM 0:06:53 96
4 2148 315 315 10/22/2020 9:13:48 AM 0:05:05 100
10 4105 316 316 10/22/2020 9:14:52 AM 0:01:04 100
10 4106 317 317 10/22/2020 9:20:43 AM 0:05:51 100
4 2149 318 318 10/22/2020 9:21:47 AM 0:01:04 96
10 4107 319 319 10/22/2020 9:24:52 AM 0:03:04 100
4 2150 320 320 10/22/2020 9:29:41 AM 0:04:50 99
10 4108 321 321 10/22/2020 9:30:46 AM 0:01:04 100
4 2151 322 322 10/22/2020 9:32:50 AM 0:02:04 100

Page 45 of 88
10 4109 323 323 10/22/2020 9:35:54 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2152 324 324 10/22/2020 9:39:44 AM 0:03:50 100
10 4110 325 325 10/22/2020 9:40:48 AM 0:01:04 100
4 2153 326 326 10/22/2020 9:43:53 AM 0:03:05 100
10 4111 327 327 10/22/2020 9:44:42 AM 0:00:50 100
4 2154 328 328 10/22/2020 9:46:47 AM 0:02:04 100
10 4112 329 329 10/22/2020 9:48:51 AM 0:02:04 100
4 2155 330 330 10/22/2020 9:52:41 AM 0:03:50 100
10 4113 331 331 10/22/2020 9:52:59 AM 0:00:18 100
4 2156 332 332 10/22/2020 9:55:48 AM 0:02:49 99
10 4114 333 333 10/22/2020 9:56:52 AM 0:01:04 100
4 2157 334 334 10/22/2020 9:58:41 AM 0:01:49 100
10 4115 335 335 10/22/2020 10:00:46 AM 0:02:04 100
4 2158 336 336 10/22/2020 10:01:50 AM 0:01:05 100
4 2159 337 337 10/22/2020 10:04:42 AM 0:02:52 100
4 2160 338 338 10/22/2020 10:09:47 AM 0:05:05 100
4 2161 339 339 10/22/2020 10:12:52 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2162 340 340 10/22/2020 10:15:42 AM 0:02:51 100
10 4116 341 341 10/22/2020 10:18:47 AM 0:03:05 99
4 2163 342 342 10/22/2020 10:20:51 AM 0:02:04 100
10 4117 343 343 10/22/2020 10:20:55 AM 0:00:04 100
10 4118 344 344 10/22/2020 10:24:45 AM 0:03:50 100
10 4119 345 345 10/22/2020 10:28:50 AM 0:04:05 100
4 2164 346 346 10/22/2020 10:31:54 AM 0:03:04 99
10 4120 347 347 10/22/2020 10:32:42 AM 0:00:48 100
10 4121 348 348 10/22/2020 10:36:46 AM 0:04:04 100
4 2165 349 349 10/22/2020 10:37:50 AM 0:01:04 92
10 4122 350 350 10/22/2020 10:41:42 AM 0:03:51 100
4 2166 351 351 10/22/2020 10:44:46 AM 0:03:05 95
10 4123 352 352 10/22/2020 10:46:51 AM 0:02:04 100
4 2167 353 353 10/22/2020 10:52:40 AM 0:05:50 46
4 2168 354 354 10/22/2020 10:57:44 AM 0:05:04 65
4 2169 355 355 10/22/2020 11:08:49 AM 0:11:05 85
4 2170 356 356 10/22/2020 11:09:53 AM 0:01:04 85
4 2171 357 357 10/22/2020 11:11:42 AM 0:01:49 78
2 1009 358 358 10/22/2020 11:21:47 AM 0:10:05 26
2 1010 359 359 10/22/2020 11:22:48 AM 0:01:02 66
2 1011 360 360 10/22/2020 11:26:52 AM 0:04:04 100
2 1012 361 361 10/22/2020 11:28:41 AM 0:01:49 31
4 2172 362 362 10/22/2020 12:22:41 PM 0:54:01 60
4 2173 363 363 10/22/2020 3:01:48 PM 2:39:07 100
4 2174 364 364 10/22/2020 3:07:53 PM 0:06:05 99
4 2175 365 365 10/22/2020 3:12:43 PM 0:04:50 100
4 2176 366 366 10/22/2020 3:16:48 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2177 367 367 10/22/2020 3:18:53 PM 0:02:04 100

Page 46 of 88
4 2178 368 368 10/22/2020 3:21:44 PM 0:02:51 100
4 2179 369 369 10/22/2020 3:26:49 PM 0:05:05 100
4 2180 370 370 10/22/2020 3:31:54 PM 0:05:05 100
4 2181 371 371 10/22/2020 3:37:44 PM 0:05:51 99
4 2182 372 372 10/22/2020 3:40:49 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2183 373 373 10/22/2020 3:43:54 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2184 374 374 10/22/2020 3:46:44 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4124 375 375 10/22/2020 4:19:55 PM 0:33:11 99
10 4125 376 376 10/22/2020 4:35:48 PM 0:15:53 85
10 4126 377 377 10/22/2020 4:37:52 PM 0:02:04 87
10 4127 378 378 10/22/2020 4:39:56 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4128 379 379 10/22/2020 4:42:45 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4129 380 380 10/22/2020 4:45:50 PM 0:03:04 100
10 4130 381 381 10/22/2020 4:48:54 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4131 382 382 10/22/2020 4:54:45 PM 0:05:51 100
10 4132 383 383 10/22/2020 4:57:49 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2185 384 384 10/22/2020 5:03:54 PM 0:06:05 98
4 2186 385 385 10/22/2020 5:06:44 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2187 386 386 10/22/2020 5:13:50 PM 0:07:05 100
4 2188 387 387 10/22/2020 5:18:55 PM 0:05:05 100
4 2189 388 388 10/22/2020 5:21:45 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2190 389 389 10/22/2020 5:24:50 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2191 390 390 10/22/2020 5:31:55 PM 0:07:05 99
4 2192 391 391 10/22/2020 5:36:45 PM 0:04:50 88
4 2193 392 392 10/22/2020 5:40:49 PM 0:04:04 100
4 2194 393 393 10/22/2020 5:43:54 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2195 394 394 10/22/2020 5:46:44 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2196 395 395 10/22/2020 5:49:48 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2197 396 396 10/22/2020 6:01:54 PM 0:12:06 24
4 2198 397 397 10/26/2020 10:25:50 AM 100
4 2199 398 398 10/26/2020 10:27:54 AM 0:02:04 100
4 2200 399 399 10/26/2020 10:30:45 AM 0:02:51 100
10 4133 400 400 10/26/2020 10:32:49 AM 0:02:04 99
4 2201 401 401 10/26/2020 10:33:54 AM 0:01:05 100
10 4134 402 402 10/26/2020 10:36:44 AM 0:02:49 99
4 2202 403 403 10/26/2020 10:37:48 AM 0:01:04 99
10 4135 404 404 10/26/2020 10:40:52 AM 0:03:05 100
4 2203 405 405 10/26/2020 10:43:42 AM 0:02:50 100
10 4136 406 406 10/26/2020 10:44:46 AM 0:01:04 100
4 2204 407 407 10/26/2020 10:46:51 AM 0:02:04 100
10 4137 408 408 10/26/2020 10:48:41 AM 0:01:50 100
4 2205 409 409 10/26/2020 10:49:45 AM 0:01:04 100
10 4138 410 410 10/26/2020 10:51:50 AM 0:02:04 100
2 1013 411 411 10/26/2020 10:53:40 AM 0:01:50 66
10 4139 412 412 10/26/2020 10:55:44 AM 0:02:04 100

Page 47 of 88
2 1014 413 413 10/26/2020 10:58:48 AM 0:03:04 59
10 4140 414 414 10/26/2020 10:58:51 AM 0:00:02 55
2 1015 415 415 10/26/2020 11:02:40 AM 0:03:49 57
2 1016 416 416 10/26/2020 11:04:44 AM 0:02:03 87
2 1017 417 417 10/26/2020 11:06:48 AM 0:02:04 95
2 1018 418 418 10/26/2020 11:09:52 AM 0:03:04 97
2 1019 419 419 10/26/2020 11:12:41 AM 0:02:49 43
10 4141 420 420 10/26/2020 1:13:55 PM 2:01:14 99
10 4142 421 421 10/26/2020 1:17:45 PM 0:03:50 99
10 4143 422 422 10/26/2020 1:24:50 PM 0:07:05 100
10 4144 423 423 10/26/2020 1:28:55 PM 0:04:05 100
10 4145 424 424 10/26/2020 1:31:44 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4146 425 425 10/26/2020 1:34:49 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4147 426 426 10/26/2020 1:41:54 PM 0:07:05 100
4 2206 427 427 10/26/2020 1:42:45 PM 0:00:51 98
10 4148 428 428 10/26/2020 1:45:50 PM 0:03:04 99
10 4149 429 429 10/26/2020 1:49:54 PM 0:04:05 100
10 4150 430 430 10/26/2020 1:53:44 PM 0:03:50 99
4 2207 431 431 10/26/2020 1:56:49 PM 0:03:05 99
4 2208 432 432 10/26/2020 1:59:53 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2209 433 433 10/26/2020 2:02:43 PM 0:02:50 99
4 2210 434 434 10/26/2020 2:05:49 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2211 435 435 10/26/2020 2:08:53 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4151 436 436 10/26/2020 2:27:47 PM 0:18:54 100
10 4152 437 437 10/26/2020 2:30:51 PM 0:03:05 99
10 4153 438 438 10/26/2020 2:34:44 PM 0:03:53 100
10 4154 439 439 10/26/2020 2:38:49 PM 0:04:05 99
10 4155 440 440 10/26/2020 2:41:53 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4156 441 441 10/26/2020 2:50:44 PM 0:08:51 96
10 4157 442 442 10/26/2020 2:53:49 PM 0:03:04 100
10 4158 443 443 10/26/2020 2:56:55 PM 0:03:07 100
10 4159 444 444 10/26/2020 3:00:46 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4160 445 445 10/26/2020 3:03:50 PM 0:03:05 100
7 3056 446 446 10/26/2020 3:12:56 PM 0:09:06 100
4 2212 447 447 10/26/2020 3:13:45 PM 0:00:49 99
7 3057 448 448 10/26/2020 3:15:50 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2213 449 449 10/26/2020 3:16:54 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2214 450 450 10/26/2020 3:19:43 PM 0:02:49 37
4 2215 451 451 10/26/2020 3:26:47 PM 0:07:04 99
4 2216 452 452 10/26/2020 4:40:52 PM 1:14:05 100
4 2217 453 453 10/26/2020 4:44:57 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2218 454 454 10/26/2020 4:48:46 PM 0:03:50 99
4 2219 455 455 10/26/2020 4:52:51 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2220 456 456 10/26/2020 4:54:56 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2221 457 457 10/26/2020 4:59:45 PM 0:04:50 100

Page 48 of 88
4 2222 458 458 10/26/2020 5:03:50 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2223 459 459 10/26/2020 5:06:55 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2224 460 460 10/26/2020 5:09:45 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2225 461 461 10/26/2020 5:12:49 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2226 462 462 10/26/2020 5:15:54 PM 0:03:04 98
4 2227 463 463 10/26/2020 5:21:44 PM 0:05:50 100
4 2228 464 464 10/26/2020 5:30:50 PM 0:09:06 100
4 2229 465 465 10/27/2020 12:58:54 PM 100
4 2230 466 466 10/27/2020 1:04:00 PM 0:05:05 98
10 4161 467 467 10/27/2020 1:06:04 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2231 468 468 10/27/2020 1:07:53 PM 0:01:49 100
10 4162 469 469 10/27/2020 1:08:58 PM 0:01:05 100
4 2232 470 470 10/27/2020 1:12:02 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4163 471 471 10/27/2020 1:12:52 PM 0:00:49 99
4 2233 472 472 10/27/2020 1:14:56 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4164 473 473 10/27/2020 1:16:00 PM 0:01:04 82
4 2234 474 474 10/27/2020 1:19:04 PM 0:03:04 100
10 4165 475 475 10/27/2020 1:19:53 PM 0:00:49 99
4 2235 476 476 10/27/2020 1:21:57 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4166 477 477 10/27/2020 1:23:02 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2236 478 478 10/27/2020 1:24:51 PM 0:01:49 99
2 1020 479 479 10/27/2020 1:30:56 PM 0:06:06 84
2 1021 480 480 10/27/2020 1:35:00 PM 0:04:04 34
2 1022 481 481 10/27/2020 1:38:03 PM 0:03:02 74
2 1023 482 482 10/27/2020 1:38:51 PM 0:00:49 71
4 2237 483 483 10/27/2020 1:49:57 PM 0:11:05 100
4 2238 484 484 10/27/2020 1:53:01 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2239 485 485 10/27/2020 1:55:52 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2240 486 486 10/27/2020 2:01:57 PM 0:06:06 98
4 2241 487 487 10/27/2020 2:06:02 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2242 488 488 10/27/2020 2:07:51 PM 0:01:49 100
4 2243 489 489 10/27/2020 2:14:57 PM 0:07:05 100
4 2244 490 490 10/27/2020 2:18:01 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2245 491 491 10/27/2020 2:20:51 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2246 492 492 10/27/2020 2:24:56 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2247 493 493 10/27/2020 2:29:01 PM 0:04:05 96
10 4167 494 494 10/27/2020 2:29:50 PM 0:00:49 68
4 2248 495 495 10/27/2020 2:30:53 PM 0:01:03 99
10 4168 496 496 10/27/2020 2:31:57 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2249 497 497 10/27/2020 2:35:02 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4169 498 498 10/27/2020 2:35:06 PM 0:00:04 100
4 2250 499 499 10/27/2020 2:38:56 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4170 500 500 10/27/2020 2:41:00 PM 0:02:04 99
4 2251 501 501 10/27/2020 2:42:04 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4171 502 502 10/27/2020 2:44:53 PM 0:02:50 100

Page 49 of 88
4 2252 503 503 10/27/2020 2:45:58 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4172 504 504 10/27/2020 2:48:02 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2253 505 505 10/27/2020 2:49:53 PM 0:01:51 100
4 2254 506 506 10/27/2020 2:54:58 PM 0:05:05 98
4 2255 507 507 10/27/2020 2:59:02 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2256 508 508 10/27/2020 3:01:52 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2257 509 509 10/27/2020 3:08:57 PM 0:07:05 100
4 2258 510 510 10/27/2020 3:16:03 PM 0:07:05 100
4 2259 511 511 10/27/2020 3:22:54 PM 0:06:51 100
4 2260 512 512 10/27/2020 3:25:58 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2261 513 513 10/27/2020 3:30:03 PM 0:04:05 100
10 4173 514 514 10/27/2020 3:31:52 PM 0:01:49 100
10 4174 515 515 10/27/2020 3:37:58 PM 0:06:05 99
4 2262 516 516 10/27/2020 3:39:02 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2263 517 517 10/27/2020 3:44:53 PM 0:05:51 100
10 4175 518 518 10/27/2020 3:45:11 PM 0:00:19 100
10 4176 519 519 10/27/2020 4:06:05 PM 0:20:53 98
10 4177 520 520 10/27/2020 4:09:54 PM 0:03:50 98
10 4178 521 521 10/27/2020 4:13:59 PM 0:04:05 100
10 4179 522 522 10/27/2020 4:18:04 PM 0:04:05 100
10 4180 523 523 10/27/2020 4:21:54 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4181 524 524 10/27/2020 4:25:59 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2264 525 525 10/27/2020 4:27:02 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4182 526 526 10/27/2020 4:28:52 PM 0:01:49 100
4 2265 527 527 10/27/2020 4:29:56 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4183 528 528 10/27/2020 4:32:00 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2266 529 529 10/27/2020 4:32:52 PM 0:00:52 100
10 4184 530 530 10/27/2020 4:35:57 PM 0:03:05 98
4 2267 531 531 10/27/2020 4:42:02 PM 0:06:05 99
4 2268 532 532 10/27/2020 4:49:53 PM 0:07:51 99
4 2269 533 533 10/27/2020 4:54:58 PM 0:05:05 90
2 1024 534 534 10/27/2020 6:54:58 PM 2:00:00 57
7 3058 535 535 10/27/2020 7:01:02 PM 0:06:04 99
4 2270 536 536 10/28/2020 2:03:04 PM 10
4 2271 537 537 10/29/2020 12:58:08 PM 100
4 2272 538 538 10/29/2020 1:01:13 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2273 539 539 10/29/2020 1:08:05 PM 0:06:52 100
4 2274 540 540 10/29/2020 1:12:10 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2275 541 541 10/29/2020 1:17:00 PM 0:04:50 98
4 2276 542 542 10/29/2020 1:21:05 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2277 543 543 10/29/2020 1:24:09 PM 0:03:04 100
4 2278 544 544 10/29/2020 1:30:01 PM 0:05:52 100
4 2279 545 545 10/29/2020 1:36:06 PM 0:06:05 100
4 2280 546 546 10/29/2020 1:40:11 PM 0:04:05 99
4 2281 547 547 10/29/2020 1:44:02 PM 0:03:51 100

Page 50 of 88
4 2282 548 548 10/29/2020 1:48:06 PM 0:04:05 99
4 2283 549 549 10/29/2020 1:54:11 PM 0:06:05 100
4 2284 550 550 10/29/2020 1:56:02 PM 0:01:51 100
4 2285 551 551 10/29/2020 1:59:07 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2286 552 552 10/29/2020 2:02:12 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2287 553 553 10/29/2020 2:09:03 PM 0:06:51 100
4 2288 554 554 10/29/2020 2:13:08 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2289 555 555 10/29/2020 2:19:12 PM 0:06:05 100
4 2290 556 556 10/29/2020 2:22:02 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2291 557 557 10/29/2020 2:25:07 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2292 558 558 10/29/2020 2:36:13 PM 0:11:06 100
4 2293 559 559 10/29/2020 2:38:04 PM 0:01:51 100
4 2294 560 560 10/29/2020 2:40:09 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2295 561 561 10/29/2020 2:45:13 PM 0:05:05 97
4 2296 562 562 10/29/2020 2:49:03 PM 0:03:50 99
4 2297 563 563 10/29/2020 2:51:07 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2298 564 564 10/29/2020 2:54:14 PM 0:03:06 100
4 2299 565 565 10/29/2020 2:57:03 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2300 566 566 10/29/2020 3:00:08 PM 0:03:05 100
2 1025 567 567 10/29/2020 3:16:15 PM 0:16:07 72
2 1026 568 568 10/29/2020 3:17:03 PM 0:00:48 61
2 1027 569 569 10/29/2020 3:23:07 PM 0:06:04 83
2 1028 570 570 10/29/2020 3:25:11 PM 0:02:04 82
2 1029 571 571 10/29/2020 3:27:14 PM 0:02:04 59
2 1030 572 572 10/29/2020 3:33:03 PM 0:05:49 82
2 1031 573 573 10/29/2020 3:34:07 PM 0:01:03 81
2 1032 574 574 10/29/2020 3:35:10 PM 0:01:03 76
2 1033 575 575 10/29/2020 3:37:13 PM 0:02:04 73
2 1034 576 576 10/29/2020 3:41:02 PM 0:03:49 52
4 2301 577 577 10/29/2020 3:45:05 PM 0:04:03 100
4 2302 578 578 10/29/2020 3:48:10 PM 0:03:04 99
4 2303 579 579 10/29/2020 3:52:14 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2304 580 580 10/29/2020 3:55:04 PM 0:02:49 100
4 2305 581 581 10/29/2020 3:59:09 PM 0:04:05 99
4 2306 582 582 10/29/2020 4:04:13 PM 0:05:05 99
4 2307 583 583 10/29/2020 4:07:03 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2308 584 584 10/29/2020 4:11:08 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2309 585 585 10/29/2020 4:13:12 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2310 586 586 10/29/2020 4:17:03 PM 0:03:50 98
4 2311 587 587 10/29/2020 4:20:07 PM 0:03:04 100
4 2312 588 588 10/29/2020 4:23:12 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2313 589 589 10/29/2020 4:26:04 PM 0:02:52 99
4 2314 590 590 10/29/2020 4:32:09 PM 0:06:05 98
4 2315 591 591 10/29/2020 4:38:14 PM 0:06:05 100
4 2316 592 592 10/29/2020 4:41:04 PM 0:02:50 100

Page 51 of 88
4 2317 593 593 10/29/2020 4:49:10 PM 0:08:06 100
4 2318 594 594 10/29/2020 4:52:14 PM 0:03:05 99
4 2319 595 595 10/29/2020 4:56:04 PM 0:03:50 100
4 2320 596 596 10/29/2020 4:59:09 PM 0:03:05 99
4 2321 597 597 10/29/2020 5:01:13 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2322 598 598 10/29/2020 5:07:05 PM 0:05:52 99
4 2323 599 599 10/29/2020 5:11:09 PM 0:04:05 99
4 2324 600 600 10/29/2020 5:14:14 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2325 601 601 10/29/2020 5:16:03 PM 0:01:49 100
4 2326 602 602 10/29/2020 5:20:08 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2327 603 603 10/29/2020 5:22:13 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2328 604 604 10/29/2020 5:25:04 PM 0:02:51 100
4 2329 605 605 10/29/2020 5:30:09 PM 0:05:05 100
7 3059 606 606 10/30/2020 12:37:26 PM 97
7 3060 607 607 10/30/2020 12:41:16 PM 0:03:50 100
7 3061 608 608 10/30/2020 12:45:20 PM 0:04:05 100
7 3062 609 609 10/30/2020 12:50:11 PM 0:04:51 100
7 3063 610 610 10/30/2020 12:55:16 PM 0:05:05 99
10 4185 611 611 10/30/2020 1:16:25 PM 0:21:08 100
10 4186 612 612 10/30/2020 1:20:14 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4187 613 613 10/30/2020 1:23:19 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4188 614 614 10/30/2020 1:27:24 PM 0:04:05 99
10 4189 615 615 10/30/2020 1:30:13 PM 0:02:49 100
10 4190 616 616 10/30/2020 1:37:19 PM 0:07:05 100
10 4191 617 617 10/30/2020 1:40:23 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4192 618 618 10/30/2020 1:43:13 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4193 619 619 10/30/2020 1:48:18 PM 0:05:05 100
10 4194 620 620 10/30/2020 1:51:23 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4195 621 621 10/30/2020 1:54:12 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4196 622 622 10/30/2020 2:04:18 PM 0:10:06 99
10 4197 623 623 10/30/2020 2:07:23 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4198 624 624 10/30/2020 2:13:13 PM 0:05:50 100
10 4199 625 625 10/30/2020 2:22:19 PM 0:09:06 96
10 4200 626 626 10/30/2020 2:25:23 PM 0:03:04 100
10 4201 627 627 10/30/2020 2:28:13 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4202 628 628 10/30/2020 2:31:17 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4203 629 629 10/30/2020 2:34:22 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4204 630 630 10/30/2020 2:41:13 PM 0:06:51 98
10 4205 631 631 10/30/2020 2:44:17 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4206 632 632 10/30/2020 2:47:22 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4207 633 633 10/30/2020 2:51:11 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4208 634 634 10/30/2020 2:54:16 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4209 635 635 10/30/2020 2:57:21 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4210 636 636 10/30/2020 3:00:12 PM 0:02:51 100
10 4211 637 637 10/30/2020 3:03:17 PM 0:03:04 100

Page 52 of 88
10 4212 638 638 10/30/2020 3:06:21 PM 0:03:05 100
2 1035 639 639 10/30/2020 3:09:11 PM 0:02:50 96
10 4213 640 640 10/30/2020 3:09:30 PM 0:00:18 100
2 1036 641 641 10/30/2020 3:11:19 PM 0:01:49 79
10 4214 642 642 10/30/2020 3:12:22 PM 0:01:04 100
2 1037 643 643 10/30/2020 3:14:12 PM 0:01:49 82
2 1038 644 644 10/30/2020 3:16:15 PM 0:02:03 69
2 1039 645 645 10/30/2020 3:18:18 PM 0:02:03 34
4 2330 646 646 10/30/2020 3:25:22 PM 0:07:03 100
10 4215 647 647 10/30/2020 3:27:12 PM 0:01:50 93
4 2331 648 648 10/30/2020 3:30:16 PM 0:03:04 98
10 4216 649 649 10/30/2020 3:35:23 PM 0:05:07 100
4 2332 650 650 10/30/2020 3:38:13 PM 0:02:49 100
10 4217 651 651 10/30/2020 3:38:31 PM 0:00:18 100
4 2333 652 652 10/30/2020 3:47:22 PM 0:08:51 100
10 4218 653 653 10/30/2020 3:48:11 PM 0:00:49 100
4 2334 654 654 10/30/2020 3:51:16 PM 0:03:04 100
10 4219 655 655 10/30/2020 3:53:20 PM 0:02:05 70
4 2335 656 656 10/30/2020 3:55:24 PM 0:02:03 100
10 4220 657 657 10/30/2020 3:57:13 PM 0:01:49 100
4 2336 658 658 10/30/2020 3:59:17 PM 0:02:04 99
10 4221 659 659 10/30/2020 4:00:21 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4222 660 660 10/30/2020 4:03:11 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2337 661 661 10/30/2020 4:04:15 PM 0:01:04 99
10 4223 662 662 10/30/2020 4:07:20 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4224 663 663 10/30/2020 4:10:25 PM 0:03:05 100
4 2338 664 664 10/30/2020 4:11:14 PM 0:00:49 100
4 2339 665 665 10/30/2020 4:17:19 PM 0:06:05 99
4 2340 666 666 10/30/2020 4:22:24 PM 0:05:05 100
4 2341 667 667 10/30/2020 4:27:14 PM 0:04:50 84
4 2342 668 668 10/30/2020 4:32:18 PM 0:05:04 75
4 2343 669 669 10/30/2020 4:37:22 PM 0:05:04 68
10 4225 670 670 11/1/2020 1:56:35 PM 100
10 4226 671 671 11/1/2020 1:59:40 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4227 672 672 11/1/2020 2:01:29 PM 0:01:49 100
10 4228 673 673 11/1/2020 2:04:34 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4229 674 674 11/1/2020 2:09:39 PM 0:05:05 100
10 4230 675 675 11/1/2020 2:12:43 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4231 676 676 11/1/2020 2:17:33 PM 0:04:50 100
10 4232 677 677 11/1/2020 2:22:38 PM 0:05:05 99
10 4233 678 678 11/1/2020 2:26:43 PM 0:04:05 99
10 4234 679 679 11/1/2020 2:29:32 PM 0:02:49 100
10 4235 680 680 11/1/2020 2:32:37 PM 0:03:05 99
10 4236 681 681 11/1/2020 2:35:41 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4237 682 682 11/1/2020 2:38:31 PM 0:02:49 100

Page 53 of 88
10 4238 683 683 11/1/2020 2:44:36 PM 0:06:05 100
10 4239 684 684 11/1/2020 2:51:42 PM 0:07:05 97
10 4240 685 685 11/1/2020 2:54:31 PM 0:02:49 100
10 4241 686 686 11/1/2020 2:57:36 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4242 687 687 11/1/2020 3:00:40 PM 0:03:05 99
10 4243 688 688 11/1/2020 3:05:31 PM 0:04:51 100
10 4244 689 689 11/1/2020 3:07:35 PM 0:02:04 100
7 3064 690 690 11/1/2020 3:14:42 PM 0:07:07 100
7 3065 691 691 11/1/2020 3:17:32 PM 0:02:50 100
7 3066 692 692 11/1/2020 3:20:36 PM 0:03:05 100
7 3067 693 693 11/1/2020 3:24:41 PM 0:04:05 100
10 4245 694 694 11/1/2020 3:35:32 PM 0:10:51 100
10 4246 695 695 11/1/2020 3:38:37 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4247 696 696 11/1/2020 3:41:41 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4248 697 697 11/1/2020 3:45:31 PM 0:03:50 99
10 4249 698 698 11/1/2020 3:49:36 PM 0:04:05 99
10 4250 699 699 11/1/2020 3:51:40 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4251 700 700 11/1/2020 3:54:30 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4252 701 701 11/1/2020 3:57:35 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4253 702 702 11/1/2020 4:00:39 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4254 703 703 11/1/2020 4:02:44 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4255 704 704 11/1/2020 4:05:33 PM 0:02:49 100
10 4256 705 705 11/1/2020 4:12:39 PM 0:07:05 100
10 4257 706 706 11/1/2020 4:15:43 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4258 707 707 11/1/2020 4:19:33 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4259 708 708 11/1/2020 4:24:38 PM 0:05:05 100
4 2344 709 709 11/1/2020 4:27:42 PM 0:03:04 70
10 4260 710 710 11/1/2020 4:27:45 PM 0:00:03 100
10 4261 711 711 11/1/2020 4:30:35 PM 0:02:50 100
4 2345 712 712 11/1/2020 4:32:39 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4262 713 713 11/1/2020 4:33:43 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4263 714 714 11/1/2020 4:36:33 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4264 715 715 11/1/2020 4:38:37 PM 0:02:04 99
10 4265 716 716 11/1/2020 4:42:42 PM 0:04:05 100
4 2346 717 717 11/1/2020 4:45:31 PM 0:02:49 99
10 4266 718 718 11/1/2020 4:46:36 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2347 719 719 11/1/2020 4:48:39 PM 0:02:04 22
10 4267 720 720 11/1/2020 4:51:42 PM 0:03:02 100
10 4268 721 721 11/1/2020 4:54:31 PM 0:02:50 100
2 1040 722 722 11/2/2020 3:06:33 PM 94
2 1041 723 723 11/2/2020 3:06:36 PM 0:00:03 91
2 1042 724 724 11/2/2020 3:06:39 PM 0:00:03 77
2 1043 725 725 11/2/2020 3:06:58 PM 0:00:19 75
2 1044 726 726 11/2/2020 3:07:01 PM 0:00:03 83
2 1045 727 727 11/2/2020 3:07:04 PM 0:00:03 80

Page 54 of 88
2 1046 728 728 11/2/2020 3:07:07 PM 0:00:03 72
2 1047 729 729 11/2/2020 3:07:10 PM 0:00:03 75
2 1048 730 730 11/2/2020 3:07:13 PM 0:00:03 36
2 1049 731 731 11/2/2020 3:07:14 PM 0:00:02 51
2 1050 732 732 11/2/2020 3:07:17 PM 0:00:02 55
2 1051 733 733 11/2/2020 3:07:19 PM 0:00:02 35
2 1052 734 734 11/2/2020 3:07:21 PM 0:00:02 61
2 1053 735 735 11/2/2020 3:07:23 PM 0:00:03 64
2 1054 736 736 11/2/2020 3:07:26 PM 0:00:03 53
2 1055 737 737 11/2/2020 3:07:29 PM 0:00:03 55
2 1056 738 738 11/2/2020 3:07:47 PM 0:00:18 98
10 4269 739 739 11/2/2020 3:07:51 PM 0:00:04 99
2 1057 740 740 11/2/2020 3:08:26 PM 0:00:35 97
10 4270 741 741 11/2/2020 3:08:45 PM 0:00:19 100
2 1058 742 742 11/2/2020 3:10:34 PM 0:01:49 97
2 1059 743 743 11/2/2020 3:12:23 PM 0:01:49 32
10 4271 744 744 11/2/2020 3:13:26 PM 0:01:03 100
2 1060 745 745 11/2/2020 3:17:30 PM 0:04:05 61
2 1061 746 746 11/2/2020 3:19:33 PM 0:02:03 62
2 1062 747 747 11/2/2020 3:20:36 PM 0:01:03 30
10 4272 748 748 11/2/2020 3:22:38 PM 0:02:02 98
10 4273 749 749 11/2/2020 3:26:28 PM 0:03:50 100
4 2348 750 750 11/2/2020 3:28:32 PM 0:02:04 99
10 4274 751 751 11/2/2020 3:29:36 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2349 752 752 11/2/2020 3:31:26 PM 0:01:50 100
10 4275 753 753 11/2/2020 3:32:31 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2350 754 754 11/2/2020 3:34:35 PM 0:02:04 100
4 2351 755 755 11/2/2020 3:36:26 PM 0:01:51 100
10 4276 756 756 11/2/2020 3:37:31 PM 0:01:04 99
4 2352 757 757 11/2/2020 3:40:35 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4277 758 758 11/2/2020 3:40:39 PM 0:00:04 100
4 2353 759 759 11/2/2020 3:44:29 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4278 760 760 11/2/2020 3:45:33 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2354 761 761 11/2/2020 3:50:25 PM 0:04:51 100
10 4279 762 762 11/2/2020 3:50:45 PM 0:00:20 99
10 4280 763 763 11/2/2020 3:54:34 PM 0:03:50 100
4 2355 764 764 11/2/2020 3:55:39 PM 0:01:04 100
4 2356 765 765 11/2/2020 3:58:28 PM 0:02:49 100
10 4281 766 766 11/2/2020 3:59:32 PM 0:01:04 99
4 2357 767 767 11/2/2020 4:02:37 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4282 768 768 11/2/2020 4:02:41 PM 0:00:04 100
10 4283 769 769 11/2/2020 4:05:30 PM 0:02:50 98
4 2358 770 770 11/2/2020 4:06:34 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4284 771 771 11/2/2020 4:12:27 PM 0:05:52 100
10 4285 772 772 11/2/2020 4:14:31 PM 0:02:04 100

Page 55 of 88
10 4286 773 773 11/2/2020 4:19:37 PM 0:05:06 100
7 3068 774 774 11/2/2020 4:21:26 PM 0:01:49 98
10 4287 775 775 11/2/2020 4:22:30 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4288 776 776 11/2/2020 4:25:35 PM 0:03:05 100
7 3069 777 777 11/2/2020 4:27:25 PM 0:01:50 99
7 3070 778 778 11/2/2020 4:32:30 PM 0:05:05 100
7 3071 779 779 11/2/2020 4:42:36 PM 0:10:06 86
7 3072 780 780 11/2/2020 5:06:30 PM 0:23:54 60
2 1063 781 781 11/3/2020 1:58:38 PM 100
2 1064 782 782 11/3/2020 2:01:42 PM 0:03:05 100
2 1065 783 783 11/3/2020 2:07:33 PM 0:05:50 63
2 1066 784 784 11/3/2020 2:08:35 PM 0:01:03 61
2 1067 785 785 11/3/2020 2:12:39 PM 0:04:03 62
2 1068 786 786 11/3/2020 2:14:42 PM 0:02:03 69
2 1069 787 787 11/3/2020 2:19:45 PM 0:05:04 62
10 4289 788 788 11/3/2020 2:24:49 PM 0:05:04 86
2 1070 789 789 11/3/2020 2:26:38 PM 0:01:49 73
10 4290 790 790 11/3/2020 2:26:41 PM 0:00:03 100
2 1071 791 791 11/3/2020 2:28:45 PM 0:02:04 74
2 1072 792 792 11/3/2020 2:29:34 PM 0:00:49 78
10 4291 793 793 11/3/2020 2:29:52 PM 0:00:18 99
2 1073 794 794 11/3/2020 2:31:42 PM 0:01:49 79
10 4292 795 795 11/3/2020 2:32:45 PM 0:01:03 100
2 1074 796 796 11/3/2020 2:34:34 PM 0:01:49 40
10 4293 797 797 11/3/2020 2:35:36 PM 0:01:02 100
10 4294 798 798 11/3/2020 2:37:41 PM 0:02:04 100
2 1075 799 799 11/3/2020 2:40:45 PM 0:03:04 45
10 4295 800 800 11/3/2020 2:42:48 PM 0:02:03 97
10 4296 801 801 11/3/2020 2:44:37 PM 0:01:49 100
2 1076 802 802 11/3/2020 2:46:41 PM 0:02:04 86
2 1077 803 803 11/3/2020 2:48:45 PM 0:02:04 76
2 1078 804 804 11/3/2020 2:54:34 PM 0:05:49 61
10 4297 805 805 11/3/2020 2:57:38 PM 0:03:03 99
2 1079 806 806 11/3/2020 2:58:42 PM 0:01:04 72
2 1080 807 807 11/3/2020 3:00:45 PM 0:02:03 81
10 4298 808 808 11/3/2020 3:01:36 PM 0:00:51 100
2 1081 809 809 11/3/2020 3:02:40 PM 0:01:04 59
10 4299 810 810 11/3/2020 3:04:43 PM 0:02:03 100
10 4300 811 811 11/3/2020 3:07:48 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4301 812 812 11/3/2020 3:10:37 PM 0:02:49 100
7 3073 813 813 11/3/2020 3:11:41 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4302 814 814 11/3/2020 3:13:46 PM 0:02:04 99
7 3074 815 815 11/3/2020 3:14:35 PM 0:00:49 99
10 4303 816 816 11/3/2020 3:16:39 PM 0:02:04 100
7 3075 817 817 11/3/2020 3:17:43 PM 0:01:04 100

Page 56 of 88
10 4304 818 818 11/3/2020 3:18:48 PM 0:01:04 100
7 3076 819 819 11/3/2020 3:20:37 PM 0:01:49 100
10 4305 820 820 11/3/2020 3:21:42 PM 0:01:05 100
7 3077 821 821 11/3/2020 3:23:47 PM 0:02:05 100
10 4306 822 822 11/3/2020 3:24:36 PM 0:00:49 100
10 4307 823 823 11/3/2020 3:26:40 PM 0:02:04 100
7 3078 824 824 11/3/2020 3:27:45 PM 0:01:04 99
10 4308 825 825 11/3/2020 3:30:36 PM 0:02:51 99
7 3079 826 826 11/3/2020 3:32:40 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4309 827 827 11/3/2020 3:33:44 PM 0:01:04 100
7 3080 828 828 11/3/2020 3:35:48 PM 0:02:04 100
7 3081 829 829 11/3/2020 3:41:38 PM 0:05:50 98
10 4310 830 830 11/3/2020 3:41:42 PM 0:00:04 100
7 3082 831 831 11/3/2020 3:45:47 PM 0:04:05 100
10 4311 832 832 11/3/2020 3:47:37 PM 0:01:50 98
7 3083 833 833 11/3/2020 3:49:41 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4312 834 834 11/3/2020 3:50:45 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4313 835 835 11/3/2020 3:54:35 PM 0:03:50 100
7 3084 836 836 11/3/2020 3:55:39 PM 0:01:04 100
7 3085 837 837 11/3/2020 3:58:44 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4314 838 838 11/3/2020 3:58:48 PM 0:00:04 99
7 3086 839 839 11/3/2020 4:03:38 PM 0:04:50 99
10 4315 840 840 11/3/2020 4:03:57 PM 0:00:19 99
10 4316 841 841 11/3/2020 4:07:46 PM 0:03:50 100
7 3087 842 842 11/3/2020 4:08:36 PM 0:00:49 99
10 4317 843 843 11/3/2020 4:10:40 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4318 844 844 11/3/2020 4:12:45 PM 0:02:05 100
7 3088 845 845 11/3/2020 4:16:35 PM 0:03:50 100
10 4319 846 846 11/3/2020 4:16:53 PM 0:00:18 100
10 4320 847 847 11/3/2020 4:19:43 PM 0:02:49 100
7 3089 848 848 11/3/2020 4:21:49 PM 0:02:06 100
10 4321 849 849 11/3/2020 4:22:40 PM 0:00:52 100
7 3090 850 850 11/3/2020 4:25:45 PM 0:03:05 97
7 3091 851 851 11/3/2020 4:28:37 PM 0:02:52 100
7 3092 852 852 11/3/2020 4:34:43 PM 0:06:05 95
10 4322 853 853 11/3/2020 4:37:47 PM 0:03:04 99
7 3093 854 854 11/3/2020 4:38:36 PM 0:00:49 100
7 3094 855 855 11/3/2020 5:11:47 PM 0:33:11 100
7 3095 856 856 11/3/2020 5:14:37 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4323 857 857 11/3/2020 5:44:47 PM 0:30:10 100
10 4324 858 858 11/3/2020 5:47:37 PM 0:02:50 100
10 4325 859 859 11/3/2020 5:55:43 PM 0:08:06 100
10 4326 860 860 11/3/2020 6:01:49 PM 0:06:06 100
7 3096 861 861 11/3/2020 6:11:40 PM 0:09:51 20
10 4327 862 862 11/3/2020 6:11:41 PM 0:00:01 86

Page 57 of 88
7 3097 863 863 11/3/2020 6:48:53 PM 0:37:12 100
7 3098 864 864 11/3/2020 6:51:42 PM 0:02:50 100
7 3099 865 865 11/3/2020 7:19:52 PM 0:28:10 100
10 4328 866 866 11/3/2020 7:20:41 PM 0:00:49 100
7 3100 867 867 11/3/2020 7:24:46 PM 0:04:05 100
10 4329 868 868 11/3/2020 7:25:37 PM 0:00:51 100
7 3101 869 869 11/3/2020 7:27:42 PM 0:02:05 98
10 4330 870 870 11/3/2020 7:34:48 PM 0:07:05 100
7 3102 871 871 11/3/2020 7:35:37 PM 0:00:49 100
10 4331 872 872 11/3/2020 7:49:44 PM 0:14:07 99
7 3103 873 873 11/3/2020 7:50:48 PM 0:01:05 98
10 4332 874 874 11/3/2020 8:05:41 PM 0:14:52 100
10 4333 875 875 11/3/2020 8:09:46 PM 0:04:05 99
2 1082 876 876 11/3/2020 8:16:36 PM 0:06:51 100
2 1083 877 877 11/3/2020 8:17:41 PM 0:01:04 81
2 1084 878 878 11/3/2020 8:19:44 PM 0:02:04 81
10 4334 879 879 11/3/2020 8:23:35 PM 0:03:51 100
10 4335 880 880 11/3/2020 8:27:39 PM 0:04:04 99
2 1085 881 881 11/3/2020 8:29:43 PM 0:02:04 71
10 4336 882 882 11/3/2020 8:30:47 PM 0:01:03 100
2 1086 883 883 11/3/2020 8:31:36 PM 0:00:49 78
10 4337 884 884 11/3/2020 8:37:42 PM 0:06:06 100
2 1087 885 885 11/3/2020 8:38:46 PM 0:01:04 52
2 1088 886 886 11/3/2020 8:40:48 PM 0:02:03 57
10 4338 887 887 11/3/2020 8:40:51 PM 0:00:03 99
2 1089 888 888 11/3/2020 8:41:40 PM 0:00:49 35
2 1090 889 889 11/3/2020 8:44:42 PM 0:03:03 85
10 4339 890 890 11/3/2020 8:44:46 PM 0:00:03 100
2 1091 891 891 11/3/2020 8:46:36 PM 0:01:50 84
10 4340 892 892 11/3/2020 8:47:40 PM 0:01:04 100
2 1092 893 893 11/3/2020 8:48:44 PM 0:01:04 82
2 1093 894 894 11/3/2020 8:50:47 PM 0:02:04 82
10 4341 895 895 11/3/2020 8:50:51 PM 0:00:03 100
2 1094 896 896 11/3/2020 8:51:40 PM 0:00:49 74
10 4342 897 897 11/3/2020 8:53:43 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4343 898 898 11/3/2020 8:56:48 PM 0:03:04 99
2 1095 899 899 11/3/2020 8:58:37 PM 0:01:49 83
10 4344 900 900 11/3/2020 8:59:41 PM 0:01:04 100
2 1096 901 901 11/3/2020 9:01:45 PM 0:02:04 89
10 4345 902 902 11/3/2020 9:02:49 PM 0:01:04 100
10 4346 903 903 11/3/2020 9:08:39 PM 0:05:50 97
10 4347 904 904 11/3/2020 9:13:44 PM 0:05:05 99
10 4348 905 905 11/3/2020 9:17:48 PM 0:04:05 99
10 4349 906 906 11/3/2020 9:20:38 PM 0:02:50 99
7 3104 907 907 11/3/2020 9:24:43 PM 0:04:05 99

Page 58 of 88
10 4350 908 908 11/3/2020 9:27:47 PM 0:03:05 100
7 3105 909 909 11/3/2020 9:28:37 PM 0:00:49 99
7 3106 910 910 11/3/2020 9:32:41 PM 0:04:05 68
10 4351 911 911 11/3/2020 10:13:38 PM 0:40:57 55
10 4352 912 912 11/3/2020 10:16:42 PM 0:03:03 98
10 4353 913 913 11/3/2020 10:22:47 PM 0:06:05 99
10 4354 914 914 11/3/2020 10:25:38 PM 0:02:51 100
10 4355 915 915 11/3/2020 10:28:43 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4356 916 916 11/3/2020 10:31:47 PM 0:03:05 99
10 4357 917 917 11/3/2020 10:34:38 PM 0:02:51 100
10 4358 918 918 11/3/2020 10:37:43 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4359 919 919 11/3/2020 10:40:47 PM 0:03:05 100
10 4360 920 920 11/3/2020 10:43:39 PM 0:02:52 100
10 4361 921 921 11/3/2020 10:45:44 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4362 922 922 11/3/2020 10:48:48 PM 0:03:05 100
2 1097 923 923 11/3/2020 10:50:37 PM 0:01:49 99
2 1098 924 924 11/3/2020 10:53:42 PM 0:03:04 94
10 4363 925 925 11/3/2020 10:55:46 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4364 926 926 11/3/2020 11:00:38 PM 0:04:52 98
10 4365 927 927 11/3/2020 11:03:43 PM 0:03:04 100
2 1099 928 928 11/3/2020 11:04:47 PM 0:01:04 68
10 4366 929 929 11/3/2020 11:06:51 PM 0:02:04 100
10 4367 930 930 11/3/2020 11:09:40 PM 0:02:50 100
2 1100 931 931 11/3/2020 11:10:44 PM 0:01:04 77
10 4368 932 932 11/3/2020 11:11:48 PM 0:01:03 100
2 1101 933 933 11/3/2020 11:15:37 PM 0:03:50 88
10 4369 934 934 11/3/2020 11:15:56 PM 0:00:19 100
10 4370 935 935 11/3/2020 11:18:45 PM 0:02:50 100
2 1102 936 936 11/3/2020 11:19:50 PM 0:01:04 99
10 4371 937 937 11/3/2020 11:20:39 PM 0:00:49 100
2 1103 938 938 11/3/2020 11:21:43 PM 0:01:04 65
2 1104 939 939 11/3/2020 11:22:45 PM 0:01:03 37
2 1105 940 940 11/3/2020 11:27:48 PM 0:05:03 95
2 1106 941 941 11/3/2020 11:28:37 PM 0:00:49 95
7 3107 942 942 11/3/2020 11:37:42 PM 0:09:05 66
2 1107 943 943 11/10/2020 12:58:43 PM 87
2 1108 944 944 11/10/2020 1:01:32 PM 0:02:49 81
2 1109 945 945 11/10/2020 1:03:36 PM 0:02:04 69
2 1110 946 946 11/10/2020 1:08:40 PM 0:05:04 98
2 1111 947 947 11/10/2020 1:15:45 PM 0:07:05 97
2 1112 948 948 11/10/2020 1:27:36 PM 0:11:51 95
2 1113 949 949 11/10/2020 1:28:40 PM 0:01:04 68
2 1114 950 950 11/10/2020 1:30:43 PM 0:02:03 81
2 1115 951 951 11/10/2020 1:37:33 PM 0:06:50 85
2 1116 952 952 11/10/2020 1:40:37 PM 0:03:04 81

Page 59 of 88
2 1117 953 953 11/10/2020 1:42:41 PM 0:02:04 95
2 1118 954 954 11/10/2020 1:44:31 PM 0:01:50 94
2 1119 955 955 11/10/2020 1:54:37 PM 0:10:06 98
2 1120 956 956 11/10/2020 1:56:41 PM 0:02:04 87
2 1121 957 957 11/10/2020 1:58:31 PM 0:01:50 83
2 1122 958 958 11/10/2020 2:01:35 PM 0:03:04 85
2 1123 959 959 11/10/2020 2:02:39 PM 0:01:03 68
7 3108 960 960 11/10/2020 2:13:44 PM 0:11:05 97
7 3109 961 961 11/10/2020 2:21:34 PM 0:07:51 99
7 3110 962 962 11/10/2020 2:24:39 PM 0:03:04 100
7 3111 963 963 11/10/2020 2:33:45 PM 0:09:06 99
7 3112 964 964 11/10/2020 2:39:35 PM 0:05:50 90
7 3113 965 965 11/10/2020 2:45:40 PM 0:06:05 92
7 3114 966 966 11/10/2020 3:43:41 PM 0:58:01 82
2 1124 967 969 11/13/2020 11:38:15 AM 59
7 3115 968 970 11/13/2020 11:38:17 AM 0:00:02 21
7 3116 969 971 11/13/2020 11:38:18 AM 0:00:01 2
7 3117 970 972 11/13/2020 11:38:18 AM 0:00:00 23
7 3118 971 973 11/13/2020 12:59:07 PM 1:20:49 40
2 1125 972 976 11/20/2020 11:47:01 AM 12
7 3119 973 977 11/20/2020 11:53:03 AM 0:06:02 21

Page 60 of 88
APPENDIX C – LOG ENTRIES FROM EMS USER LOG – OCTOBER 2020

Date and Time Commands / Comments in red
10/21/2020
14:18:01
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 1250ms): Batch 227 – Successfully synchronized results.
10/21/2020
14:18:02
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 1156ms): Batch 226 – Successfully synchronized results.
10/21/2020
14:18:03
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 1297ms): Batch 228 – Successfully synchronized results.
10/21/2020
14:18:05
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 906ms): Batch 229 – Successfully synchronized results.
The above four commands are the last 4 batches adjudicated and written back to the database before the database
copy.
10/21/2020
14:18:14
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 267).
10/21/2020
14:18:33
LoadResultsCommand (execution duration: 2688ms): Result file ‘1_1_7_3037_DETAIL.DVD’ was loaded successfully.
The above two statements are the Adjudication Module checking for new Batches, and then loading the DVD file
from the NAS for the new one it encountered.
Note that this batch never made it to the old Adjudication database, it eventually made it to the new one. We are at
this point 18 seconds from the database copy.
10/21/2020
14:18:39
GetAdjudicationSupportStatusCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Adjudication status retrieved (Adjudication is
enabled)
10/21/2020
14:18:52
GetAdjudicationSupportStatusCommand (execution duration: 0ms): Adjudication status retrieved (Adjudication is
enabled)
This is the only time that this command is seen in the log during the election period, and they happened 12 seconds
BEFORE the copy and then again 1 second after.
10/21/2020
14:18:57
GetRelevantOutstackConditionsCommand (execution duration: 31ms): Successfully retrieved relevant outstack
conditions
10/21/2020
14:19:26
GetRelevantOutstackConditionsCommand (execution duration: 0ms): Successfully retrieved relevant outstack
conditions
Again, the only time this command is seen, and to me it seems that it involves the new database trying to figure out
the current adjudication status
10/21/2020
14:20:06
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 1156ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 0). Values of CvrSortOrder field for delivered batches are: 1
This is the Adjudication Module looking for new batches on the NAS drive. As there are currently no batches (the
new database was created with no records), it is looking for anything >0
10/21/2020
14:20:07
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 219ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘1’ successfully retrieved.
1 Batch was found and retrieved
10/21/2020
14:20:25
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 47ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 1). Values of CvrSortOrder field for delivered batches are: 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67,
68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98,
99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121,
122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144,
145, 146, 147, 148, 149, 150, 151, 152, 153, 154, 155, 156, 157, 158, 159, 160, 161, 162, 163, 164, 165, 166, 167,
168, 169, 170, 171, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178, 179, 180, 181, 182, 183, 184, 185, 186, 187, 188, 189, 190,
191, 192, 193, 194, 195, 196, 197, 198, 199, 200, 201, 202, 203, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208, 209, 210, 211, 212, 213,
214, 215, 216, 217, 218, 219, 220, 221, 222, 223, 224, 225, 226, 227, 228, 229, 230, 231, 232, 233, 234, 235, 236,
237, 238, 239, 240, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 246, 247, 248, 249, 250, 251, 252, 253, 254, 255, 256, 257, 258, 259,
260, 261, 262, 263, 264, 265, 266, 267, 268
Now the Adjudication module checks for new batches again. Note that the 1st time it found only one, now it finds
ALL the rest from 60 – 267 (no sign of 2-59)
10/21/2020
14:20:26
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 219ms): Cast vote records for batch ’60’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:20:30
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 312ms): Cast vote records for batch ’61’ successfully retrieved.

Page 61 of 88

10/21/2020
14:20:34
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ’62’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:20:38
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’63’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:20:43
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’64’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:20:47
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ’65’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:20:51
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 406ms): Cast vote records for batch ’66’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:20:55
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’67’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:20:59
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’68’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:04
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’69’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:08
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 359ms): Cast vote records for batch ’70’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:12
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’71’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:16
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ’72’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:20
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ’73’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:24
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ’74’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:28
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ’75’ successfully retrieved.
The above log entries are the reloading of the batches 60 – 75
10/21/2020
14:21:29
GetCastVoteRecordImageCommand (execution duration: 0ms): Image for tabulator ’10, batch ‘4001’ and session
’18’ successfully retrieved.
The Adjudication Module begins processing ballots needing adjudication (4001 = batch 1)
10/21/2020
14:21:33
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 312ms): Cast vote records for batch ’76’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:37
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ’77’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:44
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’78’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:48
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’79’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:52
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 375ms): Cast vote records for batch ’80’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:21:56
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’81’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:00
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ’82’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:04
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ’83’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:09
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’84’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:13
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ’85’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:17
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 281ms): Cast vote records for batch ’86’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:21
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’87’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:25
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ’88’ successfully retrieved.

Page 62 of 88

10/21/2020
14:22:29
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 328ms): Cast vote records for batch ’89’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:33
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’90’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:37
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ’91’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:41
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’92’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:46
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ’93’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:50
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ’94’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:54
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ’95’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:22:58
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ’96’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:02
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 359ms): Cast vote records for batch ’97’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:06
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’98’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:10
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ’99’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:14
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘100’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:18
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘101’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:23
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘102’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:27
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘103’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:31
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘104’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:37
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘105’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:41
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘106’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:45
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 312ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘107’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:49
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘108’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:53
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘109’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:23:57
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘110’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:01
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘111’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:06
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 328ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘112’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:10
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘113’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:13
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 281ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘114’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:18
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘115’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:22
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘116’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:26
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 281ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘117’ successfully retrieved.

Page 63 of 88

10/21/2020
14:24:30
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘118’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:35
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘119’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:39
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘120’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:43
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘121’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:47
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 328ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘122’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:51
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘123’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:24:55
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘124’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:00
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘125’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:04
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘126’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:08
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘127’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:12
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘128’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:16
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘129’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:20
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘130’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:25
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 328ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘131’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:30
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘132’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:34
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘133’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:38
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘134’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:42
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘135’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:47
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘136’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:52
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘137’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:25:57
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘138’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:01
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘139’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:05
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘140’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:09
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘141’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:13
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘142’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:17
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘143’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:21
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘144’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:25
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘145’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:29
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘146’ successfully retrieved.

Page 64 of 88

10/21/2020
14:26:33
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 219ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘147’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:37
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘148’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:41
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘149’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:45
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘150’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:49
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘151’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:52
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘152’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:26:57
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘153’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:01
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘154’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:05
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘155’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:10
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘156’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:14
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘157’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:18
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 359ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘158’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:21
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘159’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:26
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘160’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:30
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘161’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:34
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘162’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:38
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘163’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:42
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘164’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:46
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘165’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:50
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘166’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:27:56
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 312ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘167’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:01
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘168’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:05
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘169’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:10
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘170’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:13
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘171’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:18
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘172’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:22
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘173’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:25
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘174’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:30
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘175’ successfully retrieved.

Page 65 of 88

10/21/2020
14:28:34
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘176’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:38
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘177’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:42
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘178’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:46
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘179’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:50
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 313ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘180’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:54
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘181’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:28:58
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘182’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:02
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘183’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:06
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘184’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:10
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 312ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘185’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:14
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘186’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:18
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 172ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘187’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:22
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 438ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘188’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:26
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘189’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:30
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 328ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘190’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:34
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘191’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:38
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘192’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:43
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘193’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:47
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 281ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘194’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:52
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘195’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:29:56
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘196’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:00
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘197’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:04
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 281ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘198’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:08
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 62ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘199’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:09
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 203ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘200’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:13
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 203ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘201’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:17
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘202’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:21
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 281ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘203’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:25
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘204’ successfully retrieved.

Page 66 of 88

10/21/2020
14:30:29
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘205’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:33
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘206’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:37
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘207’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:41
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 313ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘208’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:45
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 313ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘209’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:50
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘210’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:54
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘211’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:30:58
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘212’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:02
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘213’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:06
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 187ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘214’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:09
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘215’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:11
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘216’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:14
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 47ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘217’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:15
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘218’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:19
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘219’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:23
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘220’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:27
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘221’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:31
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘222’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:35
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘223’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:40
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘224’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:44
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 328ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘225’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:48
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘226’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:52
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘227’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:31:56
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘228’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:01
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 328ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘229’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:05
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘230’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:09
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 219ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘231’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:14
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘232’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:18
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘233’ successfully retrieved.

Page 67 of 88

10/21/2020
14:32:23
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘234’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:27
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘235’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:31
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘236’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:36
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘237’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:40
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 250ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘238’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:44
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘239’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:48
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 266ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘240’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:52
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 219ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘241’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:32:57
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 313ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘242’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:01
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘243’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:06
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘244’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:10
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 297ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘245’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:14
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘246’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:18
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 219ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘247’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:22
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘248’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:26
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘249’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:31
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘250’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:34
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 219ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘251’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:38
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘252’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:43
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘253’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:47
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘254’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:51
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 281ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘255’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:55
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘256’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:33:59
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘257’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:34:03
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 141ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘258’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:34:05
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘259’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:34:10
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 344ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘260’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:34:13
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘261’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:34:17
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘262’ successfully retrieved.

Page 68 of 88

10/21/2020
14:34:21
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘263’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:34:25
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘264’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:34:30
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘265’ successfully retrieved.
The reload is almost complete
10/21/2020
14:34:33
GetCastVoteRecordImageCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Image for tabulator ’10, batch ‘4001’ and session
’25’ successfully retrieved.
A second ballot from batch 1 goes to adjudication
10/21/2020
14:34:34
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘266’ successfully retrieved.
10/21/2020
14:34:38
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘267’ successfully retrieved.
At this point we have reloaded all of the batches from the original database. Time elapsed since copy event: 11
minutes, 47 seconds
This is 3 seconds (on average) per copied batch, .03 seconds (on average) per ballot.
10/21/2020
14:34:42
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 234ms): Cast vote records for batch ‘268’ successfully retrieved.
This is the system actually loading up batch 3037, the last one that was saved before the database copy. (See line
7 above)
At this point all but 58 batches and their ballots from the original Adjudication database are now copied to the new
database

Page 69 of 88
APPENDIX D – LOG ENTRIES FROM EMS USER LOG – MARCH 2021

Date and Time Command / Comment
03/30/2021
14:57:16
GetCastVoteRecordImageCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Image for tabulator ’30, batch ‘3044’
and session ’72’ successfully retrieved.
Adjudication Module requesting an image so that it can be adjudicated
03/30/2021
14:57:17
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 0ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
03/30/2021
14:57:32
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
03/30/2021
14:57:47
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
03/30/2021
14:58:02
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 0ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
Normal checks for new batches. We are 54 seconds from database copy event
03/30/2021
14:58:41
GetAdjudicationSupportStatusCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Adjudication status retrieved
(Adjudication is enabled)
03/30/2021
14:58:57
GetAdjudicationSupportStatusCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Adjudication status retrieved
(Adjudication is enabled)
Like in the November 2020 election these two commands appear right before and right after the copy
event.
03/30/2021
14:58:59
GetRelevantOutstackConditionsCommand (execution duration: 47ms): Successfully retrieved relevant
outstack conditions
03/30/2021
14:59:15
GetRelevantOutstackConditionsCommand (execution duration: 0ms): Successfully retrieved relevant
outstack conditions
These two commands also were found just after the database copy event
03/30/2021
14:59:52
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 156ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 0). Values of CvrSortOrder field for delivered batches are: 45, 46
03/30/2021
14:59:52
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 406ms): Cast vote records for batch ’46’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
14:59:56
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Cast vote records for batch ’47’ successfully
retrieved.
The select batches from the original Adjudication database begin being encountered, although like
November 2020, not all at once.
03/30/2021
15:00:14
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 46). Values of CvrSortOrder field for delivered batches are: 48, 49
03/30/2021
15:00:14
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’49’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:00:18
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Cast vote records for batch ’50’ successfully
retrieved.

Page 70 of 88

03/30/2021
15:00:36
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 31ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 49). Values of CvrSortOrder field for delivered batches are: 51, 52, 53, 54, 55,
56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83,
84, 85, 86, 87, 88
03/30/2021
15:00:36
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’52’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:00:40
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’53’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:00:43
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’54’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:00:47
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’55’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:00:51
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’56’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:00:54
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’57’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:00:58
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’58’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:01
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 125ms): Cast vote records for batch ’59’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:05
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’60’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:08
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’61’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:11
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’62’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:15
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’63’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:19
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 125ms): Cast vote records for batch ’64’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:22
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’65’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:25
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’66’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:29
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’67’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:33
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’68’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:36
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’69’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:40
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’70’ successfully
retrieved.

Page 71 of 88

03/30/2021
15:01:44
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Cast vote records for batch ’71’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:48
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’72’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:51
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’73’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:55
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’74’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:01:59
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Cast vote records for batch ’75’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:02
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Cast vote records for batch ’76’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:06
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’77’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:09
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’78’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:12
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’79’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:16
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 63ms): Cast vote records for batch ’80’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:19
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Cast vote records for batch ’81’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:22
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’82’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:26
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’83’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:29
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’84’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:33
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Cast vote records for batch ’85’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:37
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Cast vote records for batch ’86’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:40
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’87’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:44
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Cast vote records for batch ’88’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:02:47
GetCastVoteRecordsCommand (execution duration: 47ms): Cast vote records for batch ’89’ successfully
retrieved.
03/30/2021
15:03:04
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).

Page 72 of 88

03/30/2021
15:03:19
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 203ms): Batch 63 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:19
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
03/30/2021
15:03:19
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 141ms): Batch 59 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:20
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 125ms): Batch 61 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:20
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Batch 62 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:20
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Batch 64 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:20
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 62ms): Batch 65 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:21
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Batch 67 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:21
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Batch 68 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:21
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 62ms): Batch 69 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:21
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 94ms): Batch 70 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:21
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 62ms): Batch 71 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:22
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 63ms): Batch 72 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:22
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 62ms): Batch 74 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:22
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 78ms): Batch 56 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:34
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 0ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
03/30/2021
15:03:40
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 188ms): Batch 75 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:48
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 172ms): Batch 79 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:48
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 125ms): Batch 77 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:03:48
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Batch 78 – Successfully synchronized results.

Page 73 of 88

03/30/2021
15:03:49
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 0ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
03/30/2021
15:03:51
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 125ms): Batch 80 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:04:04
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
03/30/2021
15:04:14
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 203ms): Batch 82 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:04:18
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 156ms): Batch 84 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:04:19
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 125ms): Batch 83 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:04:19
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 0ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
03/30/2021
15:04:21
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 156ms): Batch 85 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:04:34
GetBatchesCommand (execution duration: 16ms): Cast vote record batch list was successfully retrieved
(CvrSortOrder greater then 88).
03/30/2021
15:04:48
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 109ms): Batch 89 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:04:49
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 141ms): Batch 87 – Successfully synchronized results.
03/30/2021
15:04:49
SubmitBatchCommand (execution duration: 156ms): Batch 88 – Successfully synchronized results.
Like November 2020, the rest of the batches from the original Adjudication database are copied and
reprocessed.
The order, however, is not the same, and there is a referenced to a batch 89 which does not have a
record in either Adjudication database.

Page 74 of 88
REFERENCE A – DATABASES AND TABLES
In order to assist other researchers, who may wish to examine these findings or
perform additional analysis, here are the most important databases and tables
which were used in this analysis.
Main election databases:
November 2020 General Election:
[2020 Mesa County General-2020-09-05-00-10-20]
MD5 File Hash:
a0d14c37dc7a596e0687351314e0c363
April 2021 Municipal Election:
[City of Grand Junction Municipal Election 2021-2021-02-05-16-01-32]
MD5 File Hash:
6a11b07b6c03e45aa66da599d76a37e1
Primary Tables (specifically related to vote totals):
ResultContainer: (Batch level raw vote data)
ResultSplitter: (Vote Data by Polling Location
ChoiceResult: (Raw aggregated vote data)
CastVoteRecord: (Raw per-ballot list)
Choice: (All Candidates/Choices)
Contest: (All contests in Election)
Tabulator: (All defined tabulators)
Stored Procedures (useful for checking final results):
GetContestResults: Displays current results of any or all contests
GetContestStatistics: Displays stats for any or all contests, including undervotes and
overvotes
Adjudication databases:
November 2020 General Election:
[AdjudicableBallotStore_2020_Mesa_County_General_2020-10-01_12:18:50] (before
copy)
MD5 File Hash:
56c292e893c1ea2782718b7c56d90bd9
[AdjudicableBallotStore_2020_Mesa_County_General_2020-10-21_14:18:51] (after
copy)

Page 75 of 88
MD5 Hash: 9c46e48519c88cc4becf519cc3fa9649
April 2021 Municipal Election:
[AdjudicableBallotStore_City_Of_Grand_Junction_Municipal_Election_2021_2021-03-
18_10:48:14] (before copy)
MD5 Hash:
901c5945f2abde8101716175a7827000
[AdjudicableBallotStore_City_Of_Grand_Junction_Municipal_Election_2021_2021-03-
30_14:58:56] (after copy)
MD5 Hash:
7937423c28f0741d7a9540810783b0c4a2629dc4
Primary Tables:
Batches: Raw batch information
SerializedAdjudicableBallots: Contains one data record for each ballot received.
BallotStatusEvents: Every ballot with Adjudication status. New records for same ballot
whenever any change occurs in the status of the ballot.

Page 76 of 88
REFERENCE B – SCANNER SPEED
https://www.sos.state.co.us/pubs/elections/VotingSystems/DVS-DemocracySuite511/documentation/2-03-ICC-FunctionalityDescription-5-
11-CO.pdf

Page 77 of 88
REFERENCE C – SCANNERS USED BY MESA COUNTY
https://onbase.mesacounty.us/OnBaseAgendaOnline/Documents/Downloadfile/Special_Meeting_1018_Agenda_Packet_8_24_2021_1_00_0
0_PM.pdf?documentType=5&meetingId=1018&isAttachment=True

Page 78 of 88
REFERENCE D – DATA MOVEMENT FROM BATCHES TO VOTES
Below please find an example of how the data moves through the system from
the batch to its votes, and how the ballot level vote data is obfuscated in the
process. Blank and irrelevant fields are omitted.
When batch 4025 was received in the Mesa County November 2020 election, the
following record was created in the
batches table of the Adjudication database.

Field Value
TabulatorId 10
BatchId 4025
Name Tabulator 10 – Batch 4025
LoadOrder 60
CreationTime 10/21/20 2:20 PM
ModificationTime 10/22/20 10:33 AM
BallotCount 99
HasAdjudicatedBallots 1

After all adjudication tasks were complete, a record exists in the Main election
database
ResultContainer table.

Field Value
Id 60
containerType CVR
resultState Published
batchId 4025
fileName 1_1_10_4025_DETAIL.DVD
tabulatorId 10
CvrSortOrder 60
TimeStamp 10/19/20 4:12 PM

This table serves as a record of each individual batch received, and the batchId
field (4025 in this case) references the BatchId of the Adjudication database’s
Batches table, as shown above. This is the first evidence of a break in referential
integrity, as there is no database-level relationship between these two tables. In

Page 79 of 88
other words, the Batches record in the Adjudication database can be removed or
altered without any warning or error being generated by the database.
Of note also is that the number of ballots which exists in each batch is not a part
of the
ResultContainer table. This makes reconciling the data in the Main election
database tables much more difficult.
From here, the information goes to three other tables of interest in the Main
election database. The first is
CastVoteRecord, which contains the ballot-level
vote data.

Id ResultContainerId RecordId PrecinctPortionId IsCurrent OriginalCvrId OutstackConditions BallotTypeId tabulatorId batchId
5892 60 1 124 1 NULL 1088 5 10 4025
5893 60 2 103 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5894 60 3 66 0 NULL 256 8 10 4025
5895 60 4 44 1 NULL 1088 3 10 4025
5896 60 5 111 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5897 60 6 63 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5898 60 7 79 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5899 60 8 98 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5900 60 9 22 1 NULL 1088 3 10 4025
5901 60 10 22 0 NULL 256 3 10 4025
5902 60 11 111 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5903 60 12 134 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5904 60 13 134 0 NULL 256 7 10 4025
5905 60 14 4 1 NULL 1088 1 10 4025
5906 60 15 100 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5907 60 16 98 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5908 60 17 40 1 NULL 0 1 10 4025
5909 60 18 129 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5910 60 19 124 1 NULL 1088 5 10 4025
5911 60 20 108 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5912 60 21 131 0 NULL 5 7 10 4025
5913 60 22 41 0 NULL 1344 1 10 4025
5914 60 23 42 0 NULL 256 1 10 4025
5915 60 24 13 1 NULL 1088 2 10 4025
5916 60 25 42 1 NULL 1088 1 10 4025
5917 60 26 2 1 NULL 0 1 10 4025
5918 60 27 42 1 NULL 0 1 10 4025
5919 60 28 60 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5920 60 29 95 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5921 60 30 100 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025

Page 80 of 88

5922 60 31 10 1 NULL 1088 1 10 4025
5923 60 32 117 1 NULL 1088 5 10 4025
5924 60 33 101 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5925 60 34 10 0 NULL 256 1 10 4025
5926 60 35 102 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5927 60 36 60 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5928 60 37 101 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5929 60 38 7 1 NULL 1088 1 10 4025
5930 60 39 41 1 NULL 0 1 10 4025
5931 60 40 101 0 NULL 1344 7 10 4025
5932 60 41 62 1 NULL 1088 8 10 4025
5933 60 42 46 1 NULL 1088 1 10 4025
5934 60 43 70 1 NULL 0 8 10 4025
5935 60 44 63 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5936 60 45 100 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5937 60 46 94 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5938 60 47 101 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5939 60 48 79 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5940 60 49 131 0 NULL 1 7 10 4025
5941 60 50 3 1 NULL 0 1 10 4025
5942 60 51 108 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5943 60 52 63 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5944 60 53 105 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5945 60 54 100 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5946 60 55 17 1 NULL 0 3 10 4025
5947 60 56 40 1 NULL 0 1 10 4025
5948 60 57 101 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5949 60 58 60 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5950 60 59 22 0 NULL 1 3 10 4025
5951 60 60 134 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5952 60 61 103 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5953 60 62 60 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5954 60 63 7 1 NULL 1088 1 10 4025
5955 60 64 52 1 NULL 0 3 10 4025
5956 60 65 100 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5957 60 66 100 0 NULL 256 7 10 4025
5958 60 67 101 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5959 60 68 79 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5960 60 69 100 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5961 60 70 129 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5962 60 71 98 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5963 60 72 138 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5964 60 73 119 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025

Page 81 of 88

5965 60 74 50 1 NULL 1088 1 10 4025
5966 60 75 102 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5967 60 76 100 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5968 60 77 22 1 NULL 1088 3 10 4025
5969 60 78 60 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5970 60 79 44 0 NULL 1344 3 10 4025
5971 60 80 101 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5972 60 81 111 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5973 60 82 129 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5974 60 83 98 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5975 60 84 111 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5976 60 85 34 1 NULL 0 1 10 4025
5977 60 86 35 1 NULL 1088 1 10 4025
5978 60 87 17 1 NULL 0 3 10 4025
5979 60 88 50 1 NULL 1088 1 10 4025
5980 60 89 104 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5981 60 90 104 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5982 60 91 30 1 NULL 0 1 10 4025
5983 60 92 134 1 NULL 0 7 10 4025
5984 60 93 134 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5985 60 94 101 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5986 60 95 105 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5987 60 96 52 1 NULL 1088 3 10 4025
5988 60 97 105 0 NULL 256 7 10 4025
5989 60 98 100 1 NULL 1088 7 10 4025
5990 60 99 98 0 NULL 1344 7 10 4025
9514 60 3 66 1 5894 0 8 10 4025
9515 60 10 22 1 5901 0 3 10 4025
9516 60 13 134 1 5904 0 7 10 4025
9517 60 22 41 1 5913 1088 1 10 4025
9518 60 23 42 1 5914 0 1 10 4025
9519 60 21 131 1 5912 1092 7 10 4025
9620 60 34 10 1 5925 0 1 10 4025
9621 60 49 131 1 5940 1088 7 10 4025
9622 60 40 101 1 5931 1088 7 10 4025
9623 60 59 22 1 5950 1 3 10 4025
9624 60 66 100 1 5957 256 7 10 4025
9625 60 79 44 1 5970 1088 3 10 4025
9626 60 99 98 1 5990 1088 7 10 4025
9728 60 97 105 1 5988 0 7 10 4025

Page 82 of 88
There is one record for each ballot in batch 4025, and then an additional record
for each ballot which went through the manual adjudication process. The
IsCurrent field indicates which of the two ballot records is the latest one. No
timestamp exists in this table to be able to determine the time the ballot data
was entered or modified.
Unlike a “Cast Vote Record” file, this table contains no vote information.
Next is
ResultSplitter. Batch 4025 was separated into 42 rows in this table:

Id numberOfValid pollingDistrictId resultContainerId numberOfWriteIns tabulatorId ballotId
2008 1 30 60 0 10 1
2007 2 104 60 0 10 7
2006 1 35 60 0 10 1
2005 1 34 60 0 10 1
2004 2 50 60 0 10 1
2003 1 119 60 0 10 7
2002 1 138 60 0 10 7
2001 2 52 60 0 10 3
2000 2 17 60 0 10 3
1999 3 105 60 0 10 7
1998 1 3 60 0 10 1
1997 1 94 60 0 10 7
1996 1 70 60 0 10 8
1995 1 46 60 0 10 1
1994 1 62 60 0 10 8
1993 2 7 60 0 10 1
1992 2 102 60 0 10 7
1991 8 101 60 0 10 7
1990 1 117 60 0 10 5
1989 2 10 60 0 10 1
1988 1 95 60 0 10 7
1987 5 60 60 0 10 7
1986 1 2 60 0 10 1
1985 1 13 60 0 10 2
1984 3 42 60 0 10 1
1983 2 41 60 0 10 1
1982 2 131 60 0 10 7
1981 2 108 60 0 10 7
1980 3 129 60 0 10 7
1979 2 40 60 0 10 1
1978 9 100 60 0 10 7

Page 83 of 88

1977 1 4 60 0 10 1
1976 5 134 60 0 10 7
1975 4 22 60 1 10 3
1974 5 98 60 0 10 7
1973 3 79 60 0 10 7
1972 3 63 60 0 10 7
1971 4 111 60 0 10 7
1970 2 44 60 0 10 3
1969 1 66 60 0 10 8
1968 2 103 60 0 10 7
1967 2 124 60 0 10 5

The 99 ballots in batch 4025 are segregated here by polling district number. No
vote information appears in this table, and this table links back to its
corresponding record in the
ResultContainer table through the resultContainerId
field. Again, this table contains no specific vote information for the ballots.
Next is the table
ChoiceResult. Because of how the records are aggregated, there
are over 1,600 records for batch 4025. For brevity, only the first 49 records are
displayed.

Id numberOfVotes isValid contestResultId pollingDistrictId tabulatorId resultContainerId choiceId partyId
72135 2 1 56749 63 10 60 82 0
72136 1 1 56749 63 10 60 83 0
72137 2 1 56750 63 10 60 88 0
72138 1 1 56750 63 10 60 89 0
72139 2 1 56751 79 10 60 2 0
72140 1 1 56751 79 10 60 1 0
72141 2 1 56752 79 10 60 23 5
72142 1 1 56752 79 10 60 22 2
72143 2 1 56753 79 10 60 27 5
72144 1 1 56753 79 10 60 28 2
72145 2 1 56754 79 10 60 32 5
72146 1 1 56754 79 10 60 31 2
72147 2 1 56755 79 10 60 35 5
72148 1 1 56755 79 10 60 36 2
72149 2 1 56756 79 10 60 38 5
72150 2 1 56757 79 10 60 39 5
72151 1 1 56757 79 10 60 40 2
72152 2 1 56758 79 10 60 42 5
72153 1 1 56758 79 10 60 41 2

Page 84 of 88

72154 3 1 56759 79 10 60 44 0
72155 3 1 56760 79 10 60 46 0
72156 3 1 56761 79 10 60 48 0
72157 3 1 56762 79 10 60 50 0
72158 2 1 56763 79 10 60 74 0
72159 1 1 56763 79 10 60 75 0
72160 3 1 56764 79 10 60 76 0
72161 3 1 56765 79 10 60 78 0
72162 3 1 56766 79 10 60 80 0
72163 2 1 56767 79 10 60 53 0
72164 1 1 56767 79 10 60 52 0
72165 3 1 56768 79 10 60 55 0
72166 2 1 56769 79 10 60 56 0
72167 1 1 56769 79 10 60 57 0
72134 3 1 56748 63 10 60 73 0
72133 1 1 56747 63 10 60 71 0
72132 2 1 56747 63 10 60 70 0
72131 3 1 56746 63 10 60 68 0
72130 2 1 56745 63 10 60 66 0
72129 1 1 56745 63 10 60 67 0
72128 2 1 56744 63 10 60 65 0
72127 1 1 56744 63 10 60 64 0
72126 1 1 56743 63 10 60 63 0
72125 2 1 56743 63 10 60 62 0
72124 1 1 56742 63 10 60 60 0
72123 2 1 56742 63 10 60 61 0
72122 2 1 56741 63 10 60 59 0
72121 1 1 56741 63 10 60 58 0
72120 1 1 56740 63 10 60 57 0
72119 2 1 56740 63 10 60 56 0

This table, the only table which actually has a record of the vote totals used to
produce reports, aggregates the votes by polling district and candidate or issue
choice. As an example, the fifth line of data specifies that there are two votes for
Donald Trump (
choiceId 2, which references the internalMachineId field of the
table
Choice) from polling district 3075539035 – GJ (pollingDistrictId 79, which
references the
internalMachineId field of the table PollingDistrict).
From this table, and the associated tables it links to, all reports are generated.
As this is the only table which records vote choices, this is a single point of attack

Page 85 of 88
or failure for the entire vote counting process of the Dominion system. Changes
can be made to this table by any process, for instance changing the number of
votes or the candidate, would be undetectable as such changes do not affect any
other records in any other tables. Nor would such changes require alterations of
any other records in any other tables.
Additionally, there is no way to consistently link a particular vote shown in the
ChoiceResult table to its original ballot within the batch.
Page 86 of 88
The foregoing Forensic Examination and Report was prepared by us, and we
are responsible for its content.
The 19
th day of March 2022.
Jeffrey O’Donnell
Chief Information Officer
Ordros Analytics
Walter C. Daugherity
Senior Lecturer Emeritus
Department of Computer Science and Engineering
Texas A&M University

Page 87 of 88
BIOGRAPHY
Jeffrey O’Donnell is a Full Stack software and database developer and analyst.
He holds Bachelor’s degrees in Computer Science and Mathematics from the
University of Pittsburgh.
Over the last 40 years, Mr. O’Donnell has worked and consulted for numerous
private sector corporations, including Rockwell International, Westinghouse
Electric Nuclear, General Defense, U.S. Steel, Mellon Bank, IOTA 360, and the
Penn State Applied Research Laboratory. For several years he also delivered
and created computer science curriculum for the Community College of
Allegheny County.
For the last two decades, Mr. O’Donnell has developed numerous “big data”
analysis systems, including systems to provide short-term stock market
investors with new types of research and predictive analytics.
He currently is President of Qest Development, a full-service software
consulting and publishing company, and is Chief Information Officer of Ordros
Analytics, which specializes in election analytics of all types.
Dr. Walter C. Daugherity is a computer consultant and also Senior Lecturer
Emeritus in the Department of Computer Science and Engineering at Texas
A&M University. He graduated from Oklahoma Christian University with a
degree in mathematics, and then earned master’s and doctor’s degrees from
Harvard University, which he attended on a Prize Fellowship from the National
Science Foundation.
As a computer expert he has consulted for major national and international
firms, and for government agencies. He helped develop the national computer
keyboard standard and invented integrated user training within computer
applications as well as various electronic computer interfaces.

Page 88 of 88
As a computer science and engineering teacher and researcher, he has
published 26 research articles from over $2.8 million in funded research
projects, plus conference papers and other publications. He taught many areas
of computer science and engineering for 37 years (32 years at Texas A&M
University), including artificial intelligence, quantum computing, programming
and software design, and cyber-ethics.
At Harvard he received the Bowdoin Prize and medal for writing, and in 2015
was named a Distinguished Alumnus of Oklahoma Christian University. He is a
life member of the Association for Computing Machinery and American MENSA.

Source: https://frankspeech.com/article/bombshell-proof-election-machine-manipulation

Click here to download the supporting documentation for this report (Please note this file is .zip file and the size is 750MB)

Click here to download this report in PDF Format

 

 

Posted by Publisher in Red Pill Reports, US News
Breaking — Why John Burroughs’s Medical Records Are “Classified”

Breaking — Why John Burroughs’s Medical Records Are “Classified”

Breaking — Why John Burroughs’s Medical Records Are “Classified”

By Linda Moulton Howe | Earthfiles

Emmy Award-winning Reporter Linda Moulton Howe Investigates: This Is Why John Burroughs’s Medical Records from RAF Bentwaters/Woodbridge 1979-1982 Are “Classified,” According to Christopher C. Green M.D., Ph.D., FAAFS, Wayne State School of Medicine. © 2015 by Linda Moulton Howe

 

Breaking — Why John Burroughs's Medical Records Are "Classified"

John Burroughs receiving 2015 Researcher of the Year Award for FOIA breakthroughs with the U. K. Ministry of Defence about the MoD’s withholding UAP/UFO files, on February 21, 2015, Open Minds Conference, Fountain Hills, Arizona.

March 13, 2015 Albuquerque, New Mexico – The following statement was posted on March 13, 2015, at the Above Top Secret (ATS) website URL by Christopher “Kit” Green, M.D., Ph.D., FAAFS. See Websites below. Dr. Green was also listed in “The Aviary”of bird names given by UFO investigators William Moore and Jaime Shandera in 1982 of whistleblowers leaking information to them about extraterrestrial biological entities interacting with Earth past and present. Christopher “Kit” Green, M. D., was listed as “Bluejay,” who worked for the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) on remote viewing research and later became Chief of Biomedical Sciences at General Motors. More recently, Dr. Green has worked as Assistant Dean Asia Pacific in the Wayne State School of Medicine and as Professor of Diagnostic Radiology & Psychiatry in the Detroit Medical Center.


Kit Green ATS why Burroughs VA records Classified 031315

March 13, 2015, 07:46 PM, Kit Green reply in ATS thread under “US DoD have confirmed the UFO phenomenon is real,” Page 12. See Websites below.

Christopher “Kit” Green, M. D., Ph.D., FAAFS: This is a reply to the entire thread… and will only address two issues that are common throughout many comments on this thread.

They are: Q # 1 … How can it be true that medical records such as John Burroughs’ could have been classified…Is this true? Is it sensible? What are the reasons? And, Q # 2 … What caused his injuries (and several others present over the encounter) with the odd Air Form that emitted the Broad Band NIEMR?

It is true, his records…about a thousand pages, and to this day, still many hundreds, were in fact legally classified. In my 46 year career as a Medical Officer and physician with CIA [including as Staff Officer, Chief of Medical Intelligence/ Life Sciences Division, and Assistant National Intelligence Officer for Science and Technology]…I had, until a year or so ago…only seen a handful of truly ‘classified’ medical records: those of Adolph Hitler, John Kennedy’s Autopsy, and recently … John Burroughs.

The reasons were different. When I was denied these records after many requests (even though I have continuously held TS/SCI clearances for almost 50 years), I was able to quickly determine that the reasons were quite simple…medical records are not usually digital and are easily sequestered in multiple location…and almost impossible to find (these were and remain except for recent years in hard copy, scanned, and separated from FOIA access…and even mine.) The reasons are (I was told by current DoD and VA Records staffs) that “inside the doctors notes, the nursing notes, the specialist’s note are a myriad of references to Special Access Projects and the names of OTHER “adjacent and ancillary Programs and projects that can not be disentangled, and which could uncover active and recent projects unrelated to Rendlesham. The reasons are not necessarily related to Rendlesham…and not all the connections relate to Rendlesham.”

This makes some sense operationally, but no sense ethically…John was hurt. He needed care, then, often, and now. He had injuries we now understand are related to narrow RF bandwidths that only in some cases in the past five years have become linked to the specific etiology of cardiac and other injury he suffered. There are likely other persons and other injuries.

So: Q # 1 … Yes, his records were classified. Some remain classified. The reasons are not entirely ethical. Thank god that a couple of Senators had the guts to push, and push to ‘Disentangle’ that which was legitimately classified from those records that were needed to make the right decision about injury sustained while on Active Duty. Period. It is/was true. It is sensible. It is not entirely the stuff to make us physicians very proud.

Q # 2 Broad-band Non Ionizing Electromagnetic Radiation caused the injuries. The RF is identified in a dozen classified and a half-dozen unclassified studies on cardiological and neurological injuries … not thousands of reports. Very, very few physicians even care about this arcane area of research…and fewer know about the injuries sustained by near-field (< 100 M) to humans. The data is sparse, it is not properly Peer-reviewed, it is not understood, it is not the subject of current research. And that is the truth.

The decision that was made to grant medical disability to John was just. Some of his records will remain classified. Those of us in Military and Intelligence Medicine can be proud the right decision was finally, if belatedly made; we should remain both vigilant and ashamed that our profession remains improperly darkened, and we should bring it to the light when we can.

{Disclosure Statements: 1) I did not clear this short statement with John Burroughs, his Attorney, anyone in my government including my Contracting Officers’ Technical Representatives. 2) I am a Chief Medical Advisor to ATS. 3. I own a fraction of a fraction of a % of Stock in The Above Network, LLC. I receive no compensation. }

Christopher C. Green MD, PhD, FAAFS


I called John Burroughs for his comment on Dr. Green’s “reply to the entire thread” of ATS “US DoD have confirmed the UFO phenomenon is real,” Page 12.

John Burroughs, Normal, Illinois, evening of March 13, 2015:

“I am stunned. I didn’t know this was coming. I want to thank Dr. Green for being open now about what has been going on behind the scenes. When I met with Dr. Green in July 2013, he saw how ill I was, he went out of his way to get the proper treatment and surgery I needed and I will always be grateful to him for his help.”

See also: https://redpillreports.com/red-pill-reports/injury-caused-by-unidentified-aerial-phenomena-radiation/

Broad-band Non Ionizing Electromagnetic
Radiation Caused the Injuries

U. K. Project Condign – Originally SECRET UK RESTRICTED

Page F-4 and 14 other pages,Vol. 2 ANNEX F – “Non-Ionising EM Effects On Humans” and “Potential Mental Effects On Humans”

May 15, 2006, declassified and released: U. K. The National Archives, for hot links to UAP Executive Summary; Volume 1; Volume 2; and Volume 3.

February 27, 2015 Earthfiles: Part 1: Implications of John Burroughs’s Full V. A. Medical Coverage from Injury Caused by Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAP) Radiation at RAF Bentwaters/Woodbridge, Dec. 1980:
https://www.earthfiles.com/news.php?ID=2285&category=Science

February 27, 2015 Earthfiles: Part 2: Implications of John Burroughs’s Full V. A. Medical Coverage from Injury Caused by Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAP) Radiation at RAF Bentwaters/Woodbridge, Dec. 1980:
https://www.earthfiles.com/news.php?ID=2286&category=Science

Other Related Earthfiles Reports

March 8, 2015 Earthfiles News YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FAs8Imq–eE&feature=youtu.be

October 30, 2014 Earthfiles: “Updated – USAF Tech Sgt. (Ret.) John Burroughs Has Forced U. K. Ministry of Defence to Admit It Withheld At Least 18 Classified UFO Files”: https://www.earthfiles.com/news.php?ID=2243&category=Environment

Also see: May 4, 2011, Earthfiles: “8,500 More UFO Pages Released by U. K. Ministry of Defence – But RAF Bentwaters Files Are Missing”:
http://www.earthfiles.com/news.php?ID=1822&category=Environment

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
Injury Caused by Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Radiation?

Injury Caused by Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Radiation?

Injury Caused by Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Radiation?

By Linda Moulton Howe | Earthfiles

Emmy Award-winning Reporter Linda Moulton Howe Investigates: Implications of John Burroughs’s Full V. A. Medical Coverage from Injury Caused by Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAP) Radiation at RAF Bentwaters / Woodbridge, Dec. 1980. © 2015 by Linda Moulton Howe

 

Injury Caused by Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Radiation?

Computer illustration of sketch by John Burroughs of unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP or UFO) in Rendlesham Forest, 3 AM, December 26, 1980. Artwork by John Rackham.

“What makes this incredible and groundbreaking is that in January of 2015, the Veterans Administration has finally implied — after many years of attempting to get them to acknowledge that John Burroughs was injured while in the Rendlesham Forest, tying it together with the Condign document from the U. K. — it was an unidentified aerial phenomenon or vehicle that caused the injury (to John Burroughs).

– Pat Frascogna, Atty., for USAF Tech Sgt. (Ret.) John Burroughs

“By settling this case in full, the U. S. Dept. of Defense — because the V. A. is part of DoD — they confirmed that the UFO phenomenon is real.”

– John Burroughs, USAF Tech Sgt. (Ret.)

February 27, 2015 Albuquerque, New Mexico – On Saturday night, February 21, 2015, retired USAF Tech Sgt. John Burroughs received the Researcher of the Year Award at the Open Minds International UFO Congress in Fountain Hills, Arizona. The award honored John’s breakthrough by using Freedom of Information requests to the U. K.’s Ministry of Defence that finally provoked MoD admission that it was withholding 18 classified files, including 6 policy files, about the RAF Bentwaters/Woodbridge Rendlesham Forest events December 26-28, 1980, that involved Unidentified Aerial Phenomena (UAP) that interacted with John Burroughs, then USAF Airman 1st Class.

John Burroughs receiving Researcher of the Year Award 2015

John Burroughs receiving Researcher of the Year Award 2015, from Alejandro Rojas, Director of Operations, 2015 Open Minds International UFO Congress, on Saturday, February 21, 2015, Fountain Hills, Arizona. Image © 2015 by Open Minds. See Open Minds video about John Burroughs below in More Information.

In 2011, John began suffering periodic life-threatening atrial fibrillation, also known as AFib, a quivering or irregular heartbeat that can lead to blood clots, stroke, heart failure and other heart-related complications. He filed for Veterans Administration medical benefits but was denied when V. A. staff said there was no record of his serving at RAF Bentwaters/Woodbridge. John sought legal help in Jackson, Mississippi, attorney Pat Frascogna and then-Arizona U. S. Senator Jon Kyl before his retirement. John’s V. A. case then went to the office of Arizona’s U. S. Senator John McCain.

Eventurally the V. A. admitted knowledge of John’s service at RAF Bentwaters-Woodbridge in the 1979-1982 time period, but found those medical records were “classified.” By 2013, needing open heart surgery to repair seriously damaged mitral valve leaflets, John was angry and frustrated at not being able to get V. A. medical disability coverage when he was learning that a Top Secret U. K. Restricted Project Condign — that had been quietly de-classified in 2006 — contained information that directly linked exposure to UAP radiation in the December 1980 Rendlesham Forest “unexplained lights” phenomenon to bodily injury and mental manipulation.

Finally under pressure from Senator John McCain’s office, the V. A. arranged John’s urgent open heart surgery for mid-December 2013. He began to recover to more normal health, but without V. A. medical benefits or his RAF Bentwaters/Woodbridge medical records.

By January 23, 2014, John began filing Freedom of Information requests with the MoD and by the spring and fall of 2014, the U. K. Ministry of Defence finally admitted it withheld at least 18 classified UAP/UFO files. That is the FOIA breakthrough for which John Burroughs received the Researcher of the Year Award at the 2015 Open Minds Conference in Fountain Hills, Arizona.

January 2015: V. A. Finally Awards
John Burroughs Full Medical Disability Benefits

“U. S. Government’s De Facto Acknowledgement of the Existence of UFOs.”

– February 22, 2015, Press Release by John Burroughs and attorney Pat Frascogna

The day after his research award, on Sunday, February 22, 2015, John and his attorney, Pat Frascogna, announced in a press release the “U. S. Government’s De Facto Acknowledgement of the Existence of UFOs.” This breakthrough came with the Veterans Administration finally granting John Burroughs in January 2015 full medical disability for bodily injury in the line of duty December 26 to 28, 1980, when John twice encountered mysterious aerial lights in the U. K.’s Rendlesham Forest growing along RAF Bentwaters/Woodbridge.

Attorney Frascogna said in his February 22nd press release, “The December 1980 Rendlesham Forest incident in the United Kingdom is arguably the most well documented and important UFO encounter in history. A UFO was seen over three consecutive nights by United States Air Force personnel stationed at the twin bases of Bentwaters and Woodbridge, near Ipswich, England — then the largest NATO air force base at the height of the Cold War.

Project Condign

“Airman First Class John Burroughs encountered the UFO at close proximity on the first night. While for many years the U.S. Government denied that this incident had even occurred, in 2006 the UK Government declassified an intelligence study on UFOs (codenamed Project Condign and classified as Secret UK Eyes Only) in which the following statement is found:

“The well-reported Rendlesham Forest/Bentwaters event is an example where it might be postulated that several observers were probably exposed to UAP [Unidentified Aerial Phenomenon] radiation for longer than normal UAP sighting periods.”

Page F-4, ANNEX F, Vol. 2, Pages 16-30, Project Condign's “Unidentified Aerial Phenomena in the UK Air Defence Region: Executive Summary

Page F-4, ANNEX F, Vol. 2, Pages 16-30, Project Condign’s “Unidentified Aerial Phenomena in the UK Air Defence Region: Executive Summary, Scientific & Technical Memorandum – No. 55/2/00,” DI55, Defence Intelligence Service, Ministry of Defence, December 2000. The red underline section begins, “The well-reported Rendlesham Forest/Bentwaters event is an example where it might be postulated that several observers were probably exposed to UAP radiation for longer than normal UAP sighting periods.”


Interviews with Pat Frascogna and John Burroughs:

Joseph Patrick Frascogna, Atty., Madison, Mississippi:

“After many years of trying to get the Veterans Administration to recognize that John Burroughs was injured in the line of duty in December 1980 in responding to what initially was thought to be a downed aircraft in the Rendlesham Forest near the twin bases of Bentwaters and Woodbridge, the injury that he received was immediate to his heart — something that he did not have when he went into the Air Force just a year or so before that eventually would require open heart surgery.

THE ESSENCE OF THAT DAMAGE IS WHAT?

The damage was described as a shredded anterior mitral valve component of his heart. I was there in Tucson with John at the V. A. in late 2013 (December 18) when he had his surgery. And I spoke to the cardiac surgeon, who performed that surgery and he said that he did not know what could have caused that damage.

WE NOW KNOW THERE IS A CLASSIFIED U. K. DOCUMENT KNOWN AS PROJECT CONDIGN THAT SPECIFICALLY TIES PEOPLE WHO WERE IN RENDLESHAM FOREST IN THE DECEMBER 26TH TO 28TH TIME PERIOD TO EXPOSURE TO UAP RADIATION, WHICH IS UNIDENTIFIED AERIAL PHENOMENA RADIATION. CAN YOU NOW EXPLAIN TO A GENERAL AUDIENCE YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT THIS UAP RADIATION IS THAT CAN DAMAGE HUMAN BODIES AND MINDS?

Yes, in reference to the document that was formerly U. K. Restricted and I am just going to quote from it: ‘The well-reported Rendlesham Forest/Bentwaters event is an example where it might be postulated that several observers were probably exposed to UAP radiation for longer than normal UAP sighting periods. The unidentified aerial phenomenon” — or referred to in the United States as Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) or “anomalous vehicles” and when these craft are operating, they emit a certain electromagnetic field. That field is known to cause injury. That is what was referenced in the U. K. document.

Groundbreaking Implication of V. A. Granting Full Medical Benefits to John Burroughs — UAPs Are Real and UAP Radiation Injured John During Military Duty

What makes this incredible and groundbreaking is that in January of 2015, the Veterans Administration has finally implied — after many years of attempting to get them to acknowledge that John Burroughs was injured while in the Rendlesham Forest, tying it together with the Condign document from the U. K. — it was an unidentified aerial phenomenon or vehicle that caused the injury (in John Burroughs).

WITH YOUR PRESS RELEASE (February 22, 2015) ANNOUNCING THAT JOHN BURR0UGHS HAS OFFICIALLY RECEIVED HIS DISABILITY COVERAGE FROM THE UNITED STATES VETERANS ADMINISTRATION AND THAT IT LINKED DIRECTLY WITH HIS INQUIRY TO GET HIS MEDICAL RECORDS BECAUSE OF HIS HEART PROBLEMS AND THAT, AS YOU SAY, THE U. S. GOVERNMENT’S ‘DE FACTO ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF THE EXISTENCE OF UFOS THROUGH THIS MEDICAL COVERAGE, LEADS TO THE ISSUE: WHY ARE HIS MEDICAL RECORDS STILL CLASSIFIED?

I think the reason we believe they are still classified is because there is too much information in them. We don’t know to what detail things may have been recorded in them. We don’t know who all may have been involved in the construction of those records that might be linked to them. So I think keeping the records classified is still serving a purpose for whatever that may be. But obviously, the door has been finally opened when it never has been before. There has always been denial after denial after denial. This time it’s different. This time there is an actual ability to link up things that have happened, things that have been said from officialdom.

V. A.’s Action Is De Facto
Confirmation of UAP/UFO Reality

IN YOUR MIND AS AN ATTORNEY, WHAT DO YOU THINK NOW IN FEBRUARY OF 2015 IS THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN DISCLOSURE VERSUS THE VETERANS ADMINISTRATION SEEMS TO BE A CONFIRMATION THAT BYPASSES DISCLOSURE?

Yes, confirmation. It does seem to be that and I think the community has always known, the researchers and so forth, that just a straight out disclosure at a press conference in the White House, that sort of thing, was probably never going to happen because there were just too many bad things that would have to be dealt with if you did it that way. Number One, why have you lied to the people of the world for so long? Why have you done that?

Now, there are many, many, many questions to both countries (U. S. and U. K.) and to find out what this means going forward?”

John Burroughs

Interview:
John Burroughs, USAF Tech Sergeant (Ret.), Normal, Illinois:

“By settling this case in full, the U. S. Department of Defense — because the V. A. is part of the Department of Defense as far as they have to go through the DoD to get this information and confirm it — it is confirmation. They confirmed that the UFO phenomenon is real.

They confirmed that I and others encountered it (UAP radiation). And they have confirmed it (UAP radiation) has harmful effects on me and more than likely other people, you know that were out there. To me, confirmation trumps disclosure because Project Condign confirms that this is what’s going on in the world and that the governments of the world are aware of it. This report, Project Condign, was highly classified — some of it has been declassified, but a lot of it remains classified. The majority of governments of the world are aware of it and working on it. And what are they working on — the biggest part of it? Project Condign did not say they were looking at it from a help-the-world-standpoint as far as medical and all that other stuff. What they are looking at it for and what they are classifying, the parts that are being classified, is the weaponization part of it.

It’s taken over three decades. There has been denial. There has been disinformation. But finally, there has been a real breakthrough and I think this is a victory for everybody, not just me, but something that a lot of people fought hard for and continue to fight for and I think it’s something that just confirms that this is really going on.

More Pressure Needs to Be Put On
MoD to Release All Bentwaters Files

Obviously, it’s not THE smoking gun that everyone is looking for where you have some kind of bodies and some kind of craft. But you do have confirmation that the governments of the world are: a) are aware of it and b) they are working on it. I think more people need to push the MoD a lot harder on Project Condign itself and what they are still holding back and the documents they denied having in the first place.

MOD DI55 Document About Radiation
At UAP Site in Rendlesham Forest

Now, before Condign, there was already through FOIA through the release of the British government, there was a document in there that British MoD DI55 talked about where they were looking over whatever documents could possibly be the ones that have never been released that the MoD claimed they lost ( 030411 Earthfiles).

But it was clearly in that DI55 document that they said we were exposed to above background radiation.

JOHN, I HAVE THAT DI55 DOCUMENT IN MY HAND AND IT WAS DATED FEBRUARY 23, 1981, ONLY ABOUT ONE MONTH AFTER YOUR RENDLESHAM FOREST ENCOUNTERS NEAR RAF BENTWATERS. THIS IS COMING FROM THE U.K.’S DI55. THE SENTENCE WAS THAT THEY ARE ADDRESSING THE ISSUE OF BACKGROUND RADIOACTIVITY AT THE SITE IN RENDLESHAM FOREST AND THEY, THE DI55, ARE SAYING, ‘It seems significantly higher than the average background of about 0.015 milliroentgens.’ [ A unit of exposure to ionizing radiation and is 1/1000th of a roentgen.]

Bentwaters DI55 radiation

February 23, 1981, “Loose Minute” memo to DI55a about the subject of “Unexplained Lights” phenomena in Rendlesham Forest near RAF Bentwaters/Woodbridge December 26-28, 1980, that emitted “significantly higher than the average background (radiation) of about 0.015 milliroentgens.”

Right, they actually call it the ‘phenomena’ right away. They (MoD’s DI55) had already reviewed whatever they had reviewed as far as whatever has been sent to them. And right away, they were calling it a ‘phenomena’!

THAT IS IN THE BEGINNING OF THIS DI55 DOCUMENT.

Right.

IT SAYS, ‘UNEXPLAINED LIGHTS. REFERENCE DI55/108/15/1 FIRST PARAGRAPH: LIKE DI55, DI52 (they) DO NOT KNOW OF ANY SERIOUS EXPLANATION FOR THE PHENOMENA DESCRIBED AT REFERENCE.’ THAT RELATES TO UNEXPLAINED LIGHTS IN RENDLESHAM FOREST DECEMBER 26-28, 1980.

Now, that was one of the documents that was submitted to the V. A. The fact that there was an MoD document saying that we were exposed to above background radiation. Then, when you get into Project Condign, which is a huge report that has a lot in it, but it’s one of the few things in the report when you go through the report — and it’s over 400 pages long (460 pages) — there’s a spot in there where it goes: ‘The well-reported Rendlesham/Forest Bentwaters event is an example where it might be postulated that several observers were probably exposed to UAP (Unidentified Aerial Phenomenon) radiation for longer than normal UAP sighting periods.’

WHAT IS YOUR UNDERSTANDING TODAY IN FEBRUARY 2015 ABOUT WHAT EXACTLY UNIDENTIFIED AERIAL PHENOMENA RADIATION IS?

I’m not a scientist, but it’s the type of radiation that if you go into the documents itself, they are actually working on it — a lot of it is redacted in these documents. If you look at the Project Condign report — and a lot of it was classified Secret or above. So, if none of it is of defense significance, if none of it matters, why is some of it still redacted? A lot of it is still redacted. Why was it all classified first as Secret?

The phenomenon itself, they talk about it on and off within Condign, but there is no definitive answer of exactly what the phenomenon is other than it exists. It is clear. And then they go into what it is capable of doing and that there is high interest in it, even from a defense standpoint.”


“I wish to make it perfectly clear that the UFOs that I saw were structured machines moving under intelligent control and operating beyond the realm of anything I have ever seen before or since. I believe the objects that I saw at close quarter were extraterrestrial in origin and that the security services of both the United States  and England were and have been complicit in trying to subvert the significance  of what occurred at Rendlesham by use of well-practiced methods of disinformation.”

– Col. Charles Halt (Ret.), June 25, 2009 Press Release

Lt. Col. Charles I. Halt described a mysterious aerial light above Rendlesham Forest

Lt. Col. Charles I. Halt described a mysterious aerial light above Rendlesham Forest that emitted several thin, white beams down to the ground, including one right in front of his own feet as he stood next to Staff Sergeant Monroe Nevels in the early morning hours of December 28, 1980. Illustration [by Jan Roth at www.rendlesham-incident.co.uk used with permission.]

February 27, 2015 Albuquerque, New Mexico – Continuing interview with John Burroughs. See video of 2015 Researcher of the Year Award to John in More Information below.

Interview with John Burroughs:

John Burroughs, retired USAF Tech Sgt., Normal, Illinois:

“IT IS SIGNIFICANT THAT PROJECT CONDIGN THAT WAS HIGHLY CLASSIFIED AND THEN RELEASED WITHIN THIS DECADE SORT OF QUIETLY SAYS THAT THIS UAP PHENOMENA — THAT IN THE UNITED STATES WE WOULD CALL ‘UFO’ AND THE BRITISH ARE CALLING ‘UNIDENTIFIED AERIAL PHENOMENON’ — EMITS SOME KIND OF RADIATION THAT CAN EFFECT MINDS AND BODIES. THAT IS A DISSCUSSION IN PROJECT CONDIGN.

Right, it’s a high spectrum radiation in the terahertz range and that this type of radiation is highly classified within the Dept. of Defense and even in the MoD. What I mean by classified is terahertz is out there. It’s being used in the white world (airport security scanners). But it (UAP frequencies) is also being worked on in the black world. This type of radiation is being looked at for weaponization in a lot of different ways, which is classified.”

Spectrum of Ionizing to Non-Ionizing
Electromagnetic Radiation

Bentwaters Terahertz UAP electromag Band

Terahertz waves (where thin black lines above point) lie at the far end of the infrared band (red), just before the start of the microwave band (grey and pink). Left to right in the graphic above are .01 nanometer (1 billionth of a meter) ionizing radiation; 1 nm ionizing x-rays and 100 nm ionizing ultraviolet. Then non-ionizing frequencies are visible light in which human eyes see; non-ionizing infrared; 1 millimeter (1 thousandth of a meter) non-ionizing terahertz radiation; 1m non-ionizing microwaves; and 1 km non-ionizing radiowaves and extremely low frequencies. Graphic by Spectre.sfg.

Ionizing alpha, beta and gamma rays, x-rays and ultraviolet rays have enough energy to strip off tightly bound electrons from atoms, which are ions. Thus, ionizing radiation can do serious damage to human and other Earth life tissues.

Non-ionizing radiation that has enough energy to move atoms in a molecule around or cause them to vibrate, but not enough to remove electrons, is referred to as “non-ionizing radiation.” Examples of these frequencies are the visible light spectrum, infrared, terahertz, microwaves, radio and extremely low frequencies. Current civilian world uses of non-ionizing radiation include terahertz airport body scanners, microwaves for telecommunications and heating food and liquids; infrared lamps to keep food warm in restaurants; and radio waves broadcasting.

UAP Radiation –
How Does It Damage Human Tissues?

“JOHN, TERAHERTZ LIES BETWEEN MICROWAVE AND INFRA RED ON THE ELECTROMAGNETIC SPECTRUM. HAS ANYBODY SO FAR TALKED TO YOU ABOUT WHAT IT IS THAT THE TERAHERTZ MIGHT BE ABLE TO DO TO YOUR HEART VALVE, GIVEN THE FACT THAT TERAHERTZ IS SUPPOSED TO BE NON-IONIZING AND THEREFORE NOT DAMAGING TO TISSUE?

The best I can tell you on this is that it was clear once this information was made available, all of a sudden the doctors knew what to look for and they did some more testing (on me). Prior to that (classified information provided about UAP radiation exposure at RAF Bentwaters in Dec. 1980), my civilian doctors could not understand a guy of my health overall — my heart was healthy other than the fact that it was being damaged because it kept going into A fib (atrial fibrillation) and congestive heart failure. They (civilian doctors) could not understand why it was doing that because there was no reason for it. They could not get to the bottom of it. That’s when they requested my military records in the first place and were denied.

Basically once this (UAP radiation exposure) information became available, everything expedited and within a short period of time — you know, within a 3-month period — I was completely treated and they figured out what was wrong. They went in and did this surgery and my life was saved. I credit that to Senator John McCain’s office and to a doctor that was behind the scenes that gave information to the doctors in the V. A., who then knew what to look for and were able to do life saving surgery.

THE DAMAGE TO THE SHREDDED LEAFLET IN YOUR HEART HAS BEEN LINKED DIRECTLY BACK TO YOUR EXPOSURE TO UNIDENTIFIED AERIAL PHENOMENA RADIATION.

Yes. That was the basis of the whole claim. I mean, originally it was, ‘I need my medical records for the civilian doctors.’ It was denied. Then along the way, it became clear to the people involved trying to get my records that they were most likely classified. They (V. A. workers) were the ones that stated that.

To this day, my medical records were not released to me in this (V. A.) settlement. I am not allowed to see them. I am not allowed to have access to them, nor was my FOIA answered. My FOIA was, ‘I want a confirmation from the Department of Defense and the V. A. Are my records classified? Do they lie within the classified section? Where are my medical records being held?’

That (FOIA) has also been ignored, which is a violation of federal law. They (gov’t) have to acknowledge a FOIA and they didn’t!

But the bottom line is that my medical claim was based on the facts that:

— I was injured in the line of duty.

— That I became sick right after the incident.

— Which was the reason why I had my heart issues.

— Here’s the Condign proof that this incident happened.

— And not only that, but the Condign proof shows that my heart was damaged by whatever I was exposed to in the Rendlesham Forest in December 1980.

Physical Illness Symptoms Soon
After Rendlesham Forest Encounters

JOHN, HOW SOON AFTER DECEMBER 28, 1980, DID YOU HAVE A MEDICAL EXAM WHEN YOU WERE AT RAF BENTWATERS-WOODBRIDGE?

The interesting thing is that I never had a medical exam per se where they found the issue at Bentwaters. But I did not feel good right after the incident and I struggled with different things — vision, throat and some other problems, but they never found the heart issue.

It was after I returned to the United States four or five months later that again I got sick, just out of the blue, completely got sick and I went into the civilian hospital. My heart was not acting properly. They found a heart murmur and there was an abnormal anomaly in the heart. And the interesting thing about that, which I didn’t know at the time, but I’ve learned over the years, is a lot of times when they find this heart murmur anomaly in the heart and do an EKG and stuff like that, that leads to you have some kind of heart blockage.

But I never had that. As a matter of fact, prior to my surgery (Dec. 2013), the doctors checked for that, in case they were going to have to clean out my arteries, and they were clean. I have no heart disease, no heart problems, no nothing. The only heart problem I have was that both of my leaflets were shredded. But the one that normally doesn’t even have any damage in the mitral valve was completely shredded, which was on the inside of my mitral valve. And that was causing all my heart issues.

IT IS DESCRIBED IN PROJECT CONDIGN THAT EXPOSURE TO UAP RADIATION — HOWEVER IT IS DEFINED AT WHAT FREQUENCY — CAN CAUSE DAMAGE TO THE BODY AND CAN MANIPULATE THE MIND.

Yeah, it can, it states that in the report. People need to read that report.
[See hot links below to Condign Report ANNEX F.]

The Project Condign report is the closest thing to a smoking gun that’s out there right now, next to the fact of recovering a craft. And what I mean by that is to have proof of a craft. I mean there are implications that the crafts have been recovered and I’m not saying they haven’t been. But no one in the public has got that proof, as far as I know. But this is a report and it was a highly classified intelligence study on UFOs.

“UAP” Acronym Used by MoD
to Avoid FOIA Requests About UFOs

What is interesting, too, within some other work that I’ve done where I’ve got the MoD to admit they are still holding back 18 files — these are some of the policy files that they are holding back — six of them (policy files) and in fact, 18 files overall withheld.

Originally the MoD used ‘UFOs.’ And then later on, all of a sudden they (MoD) changed it to UAPs.

THAT UNIDENTIFIED AERIAL PHENOMENA ACRONYM MEANS THAT EVERYBODY FILING FOIA FOR ‘UFO’ CAN HONESTLY BE DISMISSED OR IGNORED BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT TECHNICALLY FILING FOR ‘UAP.’

Right. I was able to get them to admit that they (MoD) still withheld these 18 files and some other stuff that I’m still holding on to. But they’ve gotten to the point now because of my follow up questions, they will not even answer anymore of my questions. They (MoD) used this reasoning — they said, ‘We are no longer going to discuss which files we are holding, what interdepartmental memos, emails or anything else involved in this case until after these 18 files are released.’

Well, after the V. A. reviewed all my documents and everything that was presented to them, it appears that they have had some type of access to my medical records (because) they agreed that I was injured in the line of duty; that I deserved compensation and to be taken care of for my injuries in the line of duty in the forest of Rendlesham in 1980. Which all goes back to Project Condign, the UAP radiation and that other MoD DI55 report acknowledging that we were exposed to above background radiation.

Now, when I first got them (MoD) to admit to these (withheld) files, they were supposed to release them last Fall or early Winter 2014. But then when a British citizen — that’s how they magically released all of this where they didn’t acknowledge the fact that they had admitted that to me. They had a British citizen who had read some of my work that was put out — or some of the work that’s been done with my colleagues, too, that’s been put out — that he made another request supposedly, and then they (MoD) admitted, ‘Yeah, well, we’re holding on to 18 files and we’re going to release them eventually. The tentative release date will be sometime at the end of this year (2015). But there have been follow up FOIAs since then. Mine were not acknowledged, as usual, but somebody else did not get a response back either on when they (MoD) plan on releasing these (18) files, which I think are important and one of the things I think they are going to have a problem with this time is there’s going to be more people wanting to know what’s redacted and why it’s redacted.

Before, they just kind of seemed to get away with it. They just kind of said, ‘Well, here you go, guys, this is it. We don’t have anymore. And this is what we know and it’s no big deal. Well, now, if they claim they claim they released everything — that’s not true. That’s one of those: ‘I’m never going to tell you a total lie, but I’m never going to tell you the whole truth’ type of scenario.

What they are doing is saying, ‘Here’s what we can release. Here’s what’s redacted. Here’s what’s de-classified now, but there’s still a lot still classified within this that we’re not going to release.’

Why would they do that? Why would they still hold it (some files) back? Because it’s still of defense significance.

Is UAP Radiation in the Black World
Being Used in Weapon Systems?

WHY DO YOU THINK THAT IT IS NOT PUBLICLY ANNOUNCED THAT WE’RE NOT ALONE IN THE UNIVERSE AND THAT OTHER INTELLIGENCES HAVE BEEN INTERACTING WITH THIS PLANET FOR A LONG TIME?

My gut feeling is that it’s written within Project Condign itself. It’s the fact that everybody’s in a race to weaponize this technology. What I mean is the major world powers. That particular technology — this would be the next game changer.

Not only is it a game changer for whoever would hold the technology and be able to utilize it the best — but then also, is there a real threat from outside? In my case, it is unknown. When I was hurt, was it intentional or not? I can’t answer that. I mean, it could be just as simple as what happened when the Europeans came over to America and the North American Indians were exposed to them for the first time and there was stuff (germs) within what they had and carried that caused disease and sickness. It could just be as simple as that was what happened to me.

But then, there could be more implications to it. There are definitely reports of things that have happened where there has been some kind of exchange (with UAPs). So not only would it benefit the countries of the world to understand this technology if there is a threat from above. But it would also benefit whoever had the best ability to use this technology to rule the world itself.”


“I wish to make it perfectly clear that the UFOs that I saw were structured machines moving under intelligent control and operating beyond the realm of anything I have ever seen before or since. I believe the objects that I saw at close quarter were extraterrestrial in origin and that the security services of both the United States and England were and have been complicit in trying to subvert the significance of what occurred at Rendlesham by use of well-practiced methods of disinformation.”

– Col. Charles Halt (Ret.), June 25, 2009 press release


Project Condign Hot Links

Page F-4 and 14 other pages, Vol. 2 ANNEX F – “Non-Ionising EM Effects On Humans” and “Potential Mental Effects On Humans”

May 15, 2006, declassified and released:
U. K. The National Archives, for hot links to UAP Executive Summary; Volume 1; Volume 2; and Volume 3.

October 30, 2014 Earthfiles: “Updated – USAF Tech Sgt. (Ret.) John Burroughs Has Forced U. K. Ministry of Defence to Admit It Withheld At Least 18 Classified UFO Files”: https://www.earthfiles.com/news.php?ID=2243&category=Environment

May 4, 2011 Earthfiles: “8,500 More UFO Pages Released by U. K. Ministry of Defence – But RAF Bentwaters Files Are Missing”:
http://www.earthfiles.com/news.php?ID=1822&category=Environment

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
Sky Cults and UFO Encounters in Ancient Egypt

Sky Cults and UFO Encounters in Ancient Egypt

Sky Cults and UFO Encounters in Ancient Egypt

By Xaviant Haze | Red Pill Reports

Sky Cults and UFO Encounters in Ancient Egypt

We do not need to look back five thousand years or more to find evidence of humanity’s perplexity concerning metallic vehicles roaming the sky. A phenomenon anthropologists call “cargo cults” began to appear in remote South Pacific islands after the end of World War II. Aboriginal Indians formed these sky cults after being showered with material gifts by American and Japanese pilots. These islanders had never seen airplanes before. So imagine the shock and joy at seeing a loud bomber fly by and drop boxes full of food and other goods. Then imagine their confusion once the planes vanished and the goods stopped falling from heaven. In 1871 the Russian baron Nikolai Miklouho-Maclay and his fellow explorers became the first white settlers in Madang, New Guinea. When they arrived in their mammoth steamships, the native black Indian population somehow believed the Russians were their long-dead ancestors, now returning as gods. The baron impressed the natives with “magical” inventions like dynamite, chewing gum, and lanterns. After the Russians left, the natives prayed for their return, and finally, in 1884 more white men came ashore. The smiling faces of the natives didn’t last long as the Indians quickly learned that these strangers didn’t bring any goods. The German settlers rounded up the natives and put them to work on their newly formed plantations. The Indians would eventually rebel against their taskmasters but found that they were no match for another “magical” invention the white man had developed—the Winchester fast-reloading rifle.

Over a period of decades, progress between the black native islanders and white missionaries and industrialists from various countries began to sour race relations in the remote South Pacific islands. Most native islanders believed that white men inside a volcano somewhere in Australia were holding their gods hostage. These beliefs continued until World War II, when the Japanese began occupying most of the Pacific islands. Showered with goods, the islanders now believed that the Japanese were going to rescue their gods and drive away the whites from the islands.

The Japanese were happy to go along with these beliefs, considering that they were fighting for their lives against the Allied forces. After being given weapons, the native population was ready to attack any foreign troops not wearing Japanese uniforms. Their enemies were now wearing GI camouflage, and they were preferably white. Imagine how awestruck and disoriented they must have been after watching John Frum’s American fighter plane skid recklessly across the ground, smashing through palms and low-lying brush until safely halting after sliding across miles of jungle grass. With smoke billowing from the plane’s engines, Frum emerged from the cockpit. The natives ran up to the smoldering plane and stared curiously at Frum. After climbing out of the plane, John Frum pulled off his helmet, revealing African features similar to those of the local Indians. John Frum was an African-American fighter pilot; to the black native islanders, this was a huge revelation.

Once the islanders saw Frum as a hero and his plane as a symbol of a sky cult, it didn’t take long for a cult to grow up around him. Frum initially gave out candy bars and socialized with the natives until he was rescued. After he promised to return and then never appeared again, the islanders turned John Frum into a deity. The cult of Frum began to take hold right after the war ended. The natives constructed bamboo radio shacks, complete with wooden antennas and vines to represent electric cables. In these shacks they repeated phrases they must have heard during the war, including popular military jargon like, “Roger, Foxtrot, Bravo, Over and out.”

They even made a landing strip and built replica airplanes out of palms and straw and have yearly celebrations dedicated to John Frum’s return, where they paint USA on their chests and hoist a stick representing the American flag opposite the bamboo rifles slung over their shoulders.

The modern sky cult sheds light on the many psychological elements underlying how we have always viewed unfamiliar technological devices. If primitive natives had trouble understanding World War II bomber planes in the 1940s, then how can we expect ancient humans not to have had the same problems? When the South Pacific natives failed to understand how airplanes worked, it prompted them to worship the airplane. This is tied to our ancient belief in magic, and a desire to relegate something that we don’t understand to the supernatural realms. The sky cult seen in modern times makes it easier for us to understand what the ancients were describing thousands of years ago.

2What is known today as The Egyptian Book of the Dead was called by the ancient Egyptians Reu nu pert em hru, commonly translated as, “The Chapters of Coming Forth by Day.” This book was an important guide, full of funerary rites and instructions in preparing ancient Egyptians for life after death. But it was only made available during a later period of history, when the priesthood began selling this “How to Survive the Underworld” manual. Once the priests discovered how much money people were willing to pay for access to the afterlife, a cycle of mass control through religion was started that continues to the present day. The Egyptian Book of the Dead contains some of the world’s oldest written knowledge and goes far deeper than just simple spells and old time remedies. Collections of funerary chapters first appeared in Egyptian tombs around 1600 BCE. The most famous example of this, the Papyrus of Ani, is now kept in excellent condition at the British Museum in London. This famous papyrus represents a small portion of the museum’s massive archives of Egyptian texts. Many sections of The Book of the Dead have never been seen publicly and are up to 3,500 years old. Yet we do not have scholars poring madly over these documents round-the-clock in an attempt to decipher them. Considering that over 70 percent of ancient Egypt still sleeps under the hot desert sands, and that the indigenous teachings of Egypt are different from those found in the European translations of the past few hundred years, most scholars acknowledge that we only know 30 percent of its contents, at best. There is certainly plenty of room for growth. Despite the different translations, the overall core of the Egyptian texts can still be properly decoded.

Our search for clues that lead to the ancient astronaut theory in Egypt begins with the translations made by respected Egyptian linguist E. A. Wallis Budge in the book Egyptian Literature Comprising Egyptian Tales, Hymns, Litanies, Invocations, the Book of the Dead and Cuneiform Writings, published in 1901.5 Below are varied descriptions of spaceships that can be found in Egyptian writing. The mainstream view is that these are merely different kinds of boats that are meant to float on water. But if the ancient Egyptians saw the Nile as the Milky Way, then why not assume that they’re talking about celestial boats, rather than boats traversing the water? Obviously, Egyptians had boats to sail on, but given the extreme antiquity and importance of their writing, it seems more logical that they are describing scenes involving ancient space platoons, possibly older than those that visited during the days of Rama and Ezekiel.

Reading with our twenty-first-century minds, we will find the quotes below (from Budge’s book, cited above) both poetic and clear. These early Egyptian writings, especially the ones concerned with the gods hiding in their space stations or ports, are also, without a doubt, describing fast-moving jets and space vehicles able to travel to the stars:

May the soul of Osiris Ani, the triumphant one, come forth with thee into heaven, may he go forth in the Motet boat. May he come into port in the Sektet boat, and may he cleave his path among the never-resting stars in the heavens.

(Hymn to Ra: Papyrus of Ani No.10,470, sheet 20)

Thou passest over the sky, and every face watcheth thee and thy course, for thou hast been hidden from their gaze. Thou dost shew thyself at dawn and at eventide day by day. The Sektet boat, wherein is thy Majesty, goeth forth with might; thy beams [shine] upon [all] faces; [the number] of thy red and yellow rays cannot be known, nor can thy bright beams be told. The lands of the gods, and the eastern lands of Punt must be seen, ere that which is hidden [in thee] may be measured. Alone and by thyself thou dost manifest thyself [when] thou comest into being above Nu [i.e., the sky].”

(Hymn to Ra: Papyrus of Ani No. 10,470, sheet 20)

The hidden places adore thee, the aged ones make offerings unto thee, and they create for thee protecting powers. The divine beings who dwell in the eastern and western horizons transport thee, and those who are in the Sektet boat convey thee round and about.”

(Hymn to the Setting Sun: Papyrus of Mut-hetep No. 10,010, sheet 5)

Here’s a verse that describes our “divine” alien ancestors lifting off and creating a billow of smoke and fire, in a scene similar to a NASA rocket launch:

I am the oar made ready for rowing, wherewith Ra transported the boat containing the divine ancestors, and lifted up the moist emanations of Osiris from the Lake of Fire, and he was not burned.

(Preservation from Scalding: Papyrus of Nu No. 10,477, sheet 12)

There’s an astonishing verse about the God Osiris dwelling in what appears to be a scientific chamber for the purpose of cloning. Our knowledge of stem cells and DNA cloning has reached the point where we can read the verse below with a whole new understanding. Whether or not this hypothesis is too far-out to believe still doesn’t take away the staggering and unmatched quality of the poetry:

I have sat in the birth-chamber of Osiris, and I was born with him, and I renew my youth along with him . . . I fill the office of priest in the regions above, and I write down there [the things] which make strong the heart . . . I snuff the wind of the East by his head, and I lay hold upon the breezes of the West thereby . . . I go round about heaven in the four quarters thereof.

(Beating Back the Crocodile: Papyrus of Nu No. 10,477, sheet 5)

Here is one of the most profound and mysterious descriptions of alien visitation ever written. Excerpted from Budge’s Egyptian Literature, it is visually and mentally stimulating, alluding to cloning as well as offering an understanding of the time lapses that occur during long celestial voyages:

I am he who cometh forth, advancing, whose name is unknown. I am Yesterday, and Seer of millions of years is my name. I pass along the paths of the divine celestial judges. I am the lord of eternity, and I decree and I judge like the god Khepera. I am the lord of the Ureret crown. I am he who dwelleth in the Utchat [and in the Egg, in the Utchat and in the Egg, and it is given unto me to live [with] them. I am he that dwelleth in the Utchat when it closeth, and I exist by the strength thereof. I come forth and I shine; I enter in and I come to life. I am in the Utchat], my seat is upon my throne, and I sit in the abode of splendor (?) before it. I am Horus and [I] traverse millions of years . . . I open the door in heaven, I govern my throne, and I open up [the way] for the births [which take place] on this day. I am (?) the child who marcheth along the road of Yesterday. [I am] To-day for untold nations and peoples. I am he who protecteth you

for millions of years, and whether ye be denizens of the heavens, or of the Earth, or of the south, or of the north, or of the east, or of the west, the fear of me is in your bodies. I am he whose being has been moulded in his eye, and I shall not die again. My moment is in your bodies, but my forms are in my place of habitation. I am he who cannot be known, but the Red Ones have their faces directed toward me. I am the unveiled one.”

(Abolishing the Slaughterings: Papyrus of No. 10,477, sheet 6)

4 5

Here, again from Budge’s book, are more descriptions of space fleets and their divine commanders, who not only have mastered the art of cloning and space travel but also know how to keep themselves hidden from humanity:

I am Yesterday, To-day, and To-morrow, [and I have] the power to be born a second time; [I am] the divine hidden Soul who createth the gods, and who giveth sepulchral meals unto the denizens of the Tuat (underworld), Amentet, and heaven. [I am] the rudder of the east, the possessor of two divine faces wherein his beams are seen. I am the lord of the men who are raised up; [the lord] who cometh forth from out of the darkness, and whose forms of existence are of

the house wherein are the dead. Hail, ye two hawks who are perched upon your resting-places, who hearken unto the things which are said by him, who guide the bier to the hidden place, who lead along Ra, and who follow [him] into the uppermost place of the shrine which is in the celestial heights! I am the divine envoy [?] of the house of him that dwelleth in his possessions, and I have come from Sekhem to Annu to make known to the Bennu bird therein concerning

the events of the Tuat [underworld]. Let me journey on in peace; let me pass over the sky; let me adore the radiance of the splendor [which is in] my sight; let me soar like a bird to see the companies [?] of the Khus in the presence of Ra day by day, who vivifieth every human being that walketh upon the regions which are upon the earth.

(Coming Forth by Day: Papyrus of Nebseni No.9,900, sheets 23 and 24) (See plate 10.)

This verse contains astounding technical descriptions and is packed with words that can only be referring to space-age vehicles. Note also the references to cloning:

I have risen, I have risen like the mighty hawk [of gold] that cometh forth from his egg; I fly and I alight like the hawk which hath a back four cubits wide, and the wings of which are like unto the mother-of-emerald of the south. I have come forth from the interior of the Sektet boat, and my heart hath been brought unto me from the mountain of the east. I have alighted upon the Atet boat, and those who were dwelling in their companies have been brought unto me, and they bowed low in paying homage unto me and in saluting me with cries of joy. I have risen, and I have gathered myself together like the beautiful hawk of gold, which hath the head of a Bennu bird, and Ra entereth in day by day to hearken unto my words; I have taken my seat among those firstborn gods of Nut.

(Of Performing Transformations: Papyrus of Nu No.10,477, sheet 10)

6Behold me now, for I make this mighty boat to travel over the Lake of Hetep, and I brought it away with might from the palace of Shu; the domain of his stars groweth young and reneweth its former strength. I have brought the boat into the lakes thereof so that I may come forth into the cities thereof, and I have sailed into their divine city Hetep. The god Horus maketh himself to be strong like unto the Hawk which is one thousand cubits in length and two thousand [cubits in width] in life; he hath equipments with him, and he journeyeth on and cometh where the seat of his heart wisheth in the Pools thereof and in the cities thereof. He was begotten in the birth-chamber of the god of the city, he hath offerings [made unto him] of the food of the god of the city, he performeth that which it is meet to do therein, and the union thereof, in the matter of everything of the birth-chamber of the divine city. When [he] setteth in life like crystal he performeth everything therein, and these things are like unto the things which are done in the Lake of double fire, wherein there is none that rejoiceth, and wherein are all manner of evil things. The god Hetep goeth in, and cometh out, and goeth backward [in] that Field which gathereth together all manner of things for the birth-chamber of the god of the city.

(Of Sekhet-Hetepet: Papyrus of Nebseni No. 9,900, sheet 17)

There’s a curious verse that appears to describe a first-person narrative of witnessing a spaceship and implies that this individual was taken on a space flight, or was allowed to fly along with a fleet. A peculiarly stated word in the last line suggests that ancient apes’ DNA and ours might have been experimented with at some point in the past. It’s no secret that our DNA has much in common with primates’. For the ancient Egyptians to refer to apes as being divine reflects their knowledge of humankind’s genome:

[Hail], ye bright and shining flames that keep your place behind Ra, and which slay behind him, the boat of Ra is in fear of the whirlwind and the storm; shine ye forth, then, and make [ye yourselves] visible. I have come [daily] along with the god Sek-hra from the bight of his holy lake, and I have seen the Maat [goddesses] pass along, and the lion-gods who belong unto them. I have made a way in front of the boat of Ra, I have lifted myself up into his divine Disk. I am he who dwelleth among the gods, come, let [me] pass onward in the boat, the boat of the lord Sa. Behold, O Heru-ur, there is a flame, but the fire hath been extinguished. I have made [my] road, O ye divine fathers and your divine apes!

(Sailing in the Great Boat: Papyrus of Nu No. 10,477, sheet 28)

7The Litany of Ra is the most esoteric of all the ancient Egyptian writings. The rite specified in this text originated in Thebes from the walls adorning the tombs of the pharaohs and maybe one-quarter has been discovered. Edouard Naville translated these passages from texts published in France in 1875 and today housed in the British Museum:

Homage to thee, Ra! Supreme power, the only one, the courageous one, who fashions his body, he who calls his gods [to life], when he arrives in his hidden sphere . . . Supreme power, he who shines when he is in his sphere, who sends his darkness into his sphere, and who hides what it contains . . . he who lights the bodies which are on the horizon, he who enters his sphere . . . he who descends into the spheres of Ament, his form is that of Turn . . . the urn of the creatures, the only one, that unites the generative substances, its form is that of Horus . . . the brilliant one who shines in the waters of the inundation, his form is that of Nun and comes forth continually from his highly mysterious cavern . . .The royal Osiris is like one of those who speak in their hidden spheres. God of the disk with the brilliant rays, the brilliant triangle which appears in the shining place . . . he enters into the interior of his white disk, he lights the empyrean with his rays, he creates it, he makes the souls remain in their bodies, they praise him from the height of their pedestal. He receives the acclamations of all the gods who open the doors, the hidden essences who prepare the way for Ra’s soul, and who allow the King of souls access to the fields. He traverses his disk himself.

The lines of this litany contain a wide array of mysterious topics far beyond what we can imagine, let alone what primitive humans could. If we apply what we know about technology today, some of the descriptions in this document appear to be of multiple spaceships working in conjunction with one another to express profound metaphysical poetry, philosophies, scientific equations, and most significant of all an understanding of gene manipulation and cloning techniques. The roots of these pre-dynastic alien mysteries can be traced all the way to the beginning of Egyptian mythology, where a celestial goddess known as Hathor claimed that she was indeed an alien from a distant galaxy.

8

 

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
Linda Moulton Howe: Creatures from Outer Space; Aliens, Hybrids and Droids

Linda Moulton Howe: Creatures from Outer Space; Aliens, Hybrids and Droids

Linda Moulton Howe: Creatures from Outer Space; Aliens, Hybrids and Droids

By Red Pill Reports

Emmy Award-winning Reporter Linda Moulton Howe Investigates the E.T., Hybrids and Drone Phenomena

 

Zeta Reticuli Betty Hill Star Map

The Betty Hill Star Map as Interpreted by Ms. Marjorie Fish

(RedPillReports) Linda Moulton Howe joins JD, for this edition of Red Pill Reports. It should not be a surprise that the conversation lead quickly into the topic of animal mutilation and creatures from outer space; aliens, hybrids and droids.

As the interview opens, Linda talks about how her career began at Stanford. The Stanford linear accelerators, working with early computers and the bombardment images.

From there to a local Boston TV station to work in science and medicine, and then to Director of Special Projects at a local Denver TV Station. In the summer of 1979, Mark O’Kane, an audio  man, said he had just come off of a shoot with 20/20. He took Linda to a location where animals, mostly cattle, had ears, eyes, tongue, jaws, genitals and rectum cored out with no blood and no tracks. If that wasn’t strange enough, there was something else odd that was happening on location. They couldn’t keep the battery packs operating when near the animals. Why?

Linda and the crew went from one location to another investigating this strange phenomenon. Sheriff Tex Graves from Logon County, who was about to retire, told her off camera that the animal mutilation perpetrators were “creatures from outer space”.

This began Linda’s “trip down the rabbit hole”.

The subject of A Strange Harvest was my 9-months-long investigation of the animal mutilation mystery in Colorado and the surrounding region, North America and beyond to both hemispheres of this planet. Cattle, horses, goats, sheep, pigs, rabbits, dogs, cats and even wild game such as deer and marmots were found dead with bloodless excisions and no tracks around their bodies, not even their own tracks.

My documentary crew and I traveled to many mutilation sites and interviewed sheriffs and deputies in law enforcement. Retired former Logan County Sheriff Tex Graves showed us photographs of strange aerial lights he and others had seen over pastures where mutilated animals were found with the same bloodless pattern of excisions. But even though Sheriff Graves had told me off camera that he and others in law enforcement believed the animal mutilation perpetrators were “creatures from outer space,” he would not talk about that on camera.

Then on the evening of October 18, 1979, in an interview with Lou Girodo, Chief Investigator for the District Attorney’s Office in Trinidad, Colorado, he said those words on the record. Lou had been assigned to investigate the several cattle mutilations around Trinidad and with our TV camera rolling, I asked him, “Who? or what? do you think is killing and mutilating these animals?” Lou Girodo looked right at me and said, “Who is doing this now is very possibly creatures not of this planet.” He and a deputy had even watched an orange glowing sphere split in two over a farm region where there had been cattle mutilations. One orange sphere went north and the other orange sphere went south. A few minutes later, Lou said with amazement in his voice, the two orange spheres merged back together “and went straight down into the ground!” – Linda Moulton Howe

Linda Moulton Howe  with Camera Richard Lerner and Audio Man Mark O'Kane

KMGH-TV Director of Special Projects Linda Moulton Howe with TV cameraman Richard Lerner and audio man Mark O’Kane in cattle corral south of Denver, Colorado in spring of 1980 during production of Howe’s investigation of the animal mutilation mystery, A Strange Harvest, that originally broadcast on May 25, 1980.

Science, environment and medicine

Skip forward many years, takes her face to face with the US government, when working on an HBO Special in which she would explore the idea that the perpetrators were from outer space. A one hour special they planned on calling ‘The ET Factor’. The government tried to block her every step of the way.

The CIA came into being on September 18, 1947, when Truman signed the National Security Act two and a half months after the recovery of at least three wedge-shaped craft and non-human bodies from three different sites in the region of Roswell, New Mexico. The majority of the provisions of the Act took effect on September 18, 1947, the day after the Senate confirmed James Forrestal as the first Secretary of Defense. A year and a half later on May 22, 1949, Forrestal was found dead at Bethesda Naval Medical Center where he had been treated for severe mental depression. Were the stresses of trying to cope with an extraterrestrial presence while carrying out strict policies of denial about the ETs the true cause of Forrestal’s mental deterioration and suicide or murder? – LMH

Now the public has become disenchanted with a government and mainstream media, that they know has been lying since WW2.

One of the documents that was leaked in the early 1990’s, called the SOM1-01 Training Manual. A Special Operations Manual used to train very special forces for retrieval of extraterrestrial technology and extraterrestrial biological entities.

Linda is now convinced that the SOM1-01 TOP SECRET Majestic-12, April 1954, called ‘Extraterrestrial Entities and Technology, Recovery and Disposal’, showing diagrams of entities and craft, how bodies should be handled, and much more .. is authentic.

How could this possibly be kept secret from the world?

Counter-intelligence that got us through WW2, some of the brightest minds on the planet, working in England and the US, are exactly the same minds that took over, under the orders of the US President and the Prime Minister in England. This was to be kept from the public and the media for at least 50 years. They would do all they could to learn what and who these entities are.

Linda was told by a source in 1983, that Gene Roddenberry was collaborating with intel agencies, on the script for Star Trek, to get out into the public, information that our government knew was based on fact. It was a way to keep testing the public. What is Star Trek based on? That there are extraterrestrial civilizations, some are friendly to humans and some are not. That we are in a universe in which there are conflicts. There are political arguments. That this planet, and other planets can be harvested.

The evidence concerning UFO crashes that are extraterrestrial in origin, and their covert retrieval by highly specialized teams involving joint military and government personnel, is extensive and persuasive. Evidence has been accumulated by pioneers of UFO crash research such as Leonard Stringfield, and more recently by Dr Robert Wood and Ryan Wood. Understanding the highly classified procedures established to manage the retrieval of crashed UFOs received a significant boost with the public emergence of the Special Operations Manual – SOM1-01 in 1994. SOM1-01 provides an important analytical framework for understanding, and answering questions about, classified procedures used for locating, isolating and recovering crashed UFOs that are extraterrestrial in origin. Significantly, SOM1-01 described the classified government entity created for the managing crash retrieval operations. Known as the Majestic-12 Group, it evolved out of the “Majestic 12 Operation” created by President Truman on September 24, 1947. – Michael E. Salla, PhD

According to Michio Kaku, they (extraterrestrials) have known how to harvest energy from the vacuum of space, how to terraform planets, and go to the moons around planets to place base operations.

Wikipedia – The Kardashev scale is a method of measuring a civilization’s level of technological advancement, based on the amount of energy a civilization is able to utilize. The scale has three designated categories called Type I, II, and III. A Type I civilization uses all available resources impinging on its home planet, Type II harnesses all the energy of its star, and Type III of its galaxy. The scale is only hypothetical, but it puts energy consumption in a cosmic perspective. It was first proposed in 1964 by the Soviet astronomer Nikolai Kardashev (Kardashyov). Various extensions of the scale have been proposed since, from a wider range of power levels (types 0, IV and V) to the use of metrics other than pure power.

If the whistleblowers are correct, in the last 60 years since the end of WW2, the retrievals have led scientists to back-engineer this technology. Who or what pilots the disk, cylinder, spheres, triangle or boomerang shaped craft? Could it be androids? Linda thinks it could be. Androids on a mission that have been programmed into the ‘machine’, using software referred to as ‘self activating technology’, to mutilate animals, abduct humans and find gold.

Truman-Forrestal Memo (TFM) of Sept. 24, 1947 (page 8 of the EBD)

Truman-Forrestal Memo (TFM) of Sept. 24, 1947 (page 8 of the EBD)

Linda was introduced to the Truman Treaty, giving permission to extraterrestrials to do limited numbers of mutilations of animals and abductions of humans, going back to 1947.

Linda Moulton Howe: Creatures from Outer Space; Aliens, Hybrids and Droids

The Helen Littrell Sketch of the ET human hybrid Raechel

Bringing us forward to more recent times, and the account of Helen Littrell in a book called Raechel’s Eyes by Helen Littrell and Jean Bilodeaux. Helen was the mother of a young, blind college student named Marisa. Marisa briefly had a college roommate, Raechel, who always wore sunglasses and layers of clothing, even on hot days. Helen Littrell told what happened one day when Raechel tripped on a rug and she caught Raechel’s wrist to keep her from falling. It felt spongy as though there was no bone in her wrist, and her glasses fell off, revealing eyes which were a solid green, with no pupils, and a vertical black slit. Helen also spoke of her interactions with Raechel’s father, Colonel Nadien, who claimed that Raechel was part of a “humanization program” to see how beings from another planet (in this case the Zeta Reticuli star system) could be integrated into Earth society. [More at http://www.earthfiles.com/]

That brings us to a book titled UFO Highway by Anthony Sanchez. Anthony was recording an interview with an Air Force Colonel, at the same time Helen Littrell was writing her book. The interview was about the question “Why are there biological entities on this planet and where do they come from? What has our government been doing in collaboration?”

Zeta Reticuli Betty Hill Star Map

The Betty Hill Star Map as Interpreted by Ms. Marjorie Fish

Both Air Force Colonels made reference to Zeta Reticuli. They weren’t the only cases of ET disclosure that had a reltationship to Zeta Reticuli. Betty Hill drew a diagram under hypnosis.

Back to 1976, when Robert K.G. Temple released a book titled “The Sirius Mystery”.

The book presents the hypothesis that the Dogon people of Mali, in west Africa, preserve a tradition of contact with intelligent extraterrestrial beings from the Sirius star-system.

Linda considers the aforementioned books to be some of the most important books written on the topic.

So why would extraterrestrials from Zeta Reticuli 1 and 2 or Sirius A and B, or any other solar system, be on this planet producing hybrids by combining genetic material from earth to theirs?

The story line in the book UFO Highways comes down to this. Multiple species from ‘Tall Pales’ to reptilians to grays, involved in human abduction, are also involved in a political conflict or war.

Is this true and if so, why? Does it have to do with genetic survival? Problems in their replicating DNA?

Listen to the entire interview for more of Linda’s research and her perspective.

What is the real history of our planet and our universe? It’s time for more of the individuals inside the secretive agencies who are privy to information on the topics of other species, high technology and factual history, to stop hiding and manipulating the facts.

Linda’s Website: https://www.earthfiles.com/

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
Ron Paul; Inner City Turmoil and Other Crises: My Predictions for 2015

Ron Paul; Inner City Turmoil and Other Crises: My Predictions for 2015

Ron Paul; Inner City Turmoil and Other Crises: My Predictions for 2015

By Ron Paul | Ron Paul Institute

If Americans were honest with themselves they would acknowledge that the Republic is no more. We now live in a police state. If we do not recognize and resist this development, freedom and prosperity for all Americans will continue to deteriorate. All liberties in America today are under siege.

It didn’t happen overnight. It took many years of neglect for our liberties to be given away so casually for a promise of security from the politicians. The tragic part is that the more security was promised — physical and economic — the less liberty was protected.

With cradle-to-grave welfare protecting all citizens from any mistakes and a perpetual global war on terrorism, which a majority of Americans were convinced was absolutely necessary for our survival, our security and prosperity has been sacrificed.

It was all based on lies and ignorance. Many came to believe that their best interests were served by giving up a little freedom now and then to gain a better life.

The trap was set. At the beginning of a cycle that systematically undermines liberty with delusions of easy prosperity, the change may actually seem to be beneficial to a few. But to me that’s like excusing embezzlement as a road to leisure and wealth — eventually payment and punishment always come due. One cannot escape the fact that a society’s wealth cannot be sustained or increased without work and productive effort. Yes, some criminal elements can benefit for a while, but reality always sets in.

Reality is now setting in for America and for that matter for most of the world. The piper will get his due even if “the children” have to suffer. The deception of promising “success” has lasted for quite a while. It was accomplished by ever-increasing taxes, deficits, borrowing, and printing press money. In the meantime the policing powers of the federal government were systematically and significantly expanded. No one cared much, as there seemed to be enough “gravy” for the rich, the poor, the politicians, and the bureaucrats.

Warfare/Welfare State Requires Police Control

As the size of government grew and cracks in the system became readily apparent, a federal police force was needed to regulate our lives and the economy, as well as to protect us from ourselves and make sure the redistribution of a shrinking economic pie was “fair” to all. Central economic planning requires an economic police force to monitor every transaction of all Americans. Special interests were quick to get governments to regulate everything we put in our bodies: food, medications, and even politically correct ideas. IRS employees soon needed to carry guns to maximize revenue collections.

The global commitment to perpetual war, though present for decades, exploded in size and scope after 9/11. If there weren’t enough economic reasons to monitor everything we did, fanatics used the excuse of national security to condition the American people to accept total surveillance of all by the NSA, the TSA, FISA courts, the CIA, and the FBI. The people even became sympathetic to our government’s policy of torture.

To keep the people obedient to statism that originated at the federal level of government, control of education was required. It is now recognized that central control of education has actually ruined education, while costs have skyrocketed. National control of medical care has brought a similar result. This has meant more money for bureaucrats, as well as drug, insurance, and health management companies, and less money for medical care. Constantly more police are required to run our lives at greater costs while providing less benefit. “Nationalizing” both medical care and education has provided a great incentive to increase the policing powers of the federal government.

The predictable poverty that results from such a terrible system is now upon us and is a strong motivation for the militarization of local police as part of the expansion of the national police state. Temporary and perceived benefits of government overreach and expanded policing powers end up becoming the real problem. By the time it is understood that these “benefits” are artificial, government power and special interests have gained control of a system designed to serve them and not the people the programs were purported to help. The victims are left hanging and taught that too much freedom is the source of the problem, prompting even more support for the policing power of the state.

Today the failure of central economic planning and of the US as world policeman is everywhere to be found. This is especially noticeable in the police war on the lawbreakers — real and unreal — in America. The failures of social and economic policy of the past 50 years have led to a mounting friction between the local police and the rights of the people. Local police have been militarized and have become an integral part of the national police state. A police culture that accepts the principle of initiating unjustified violence against citizens has become a serious problem.

The news is constant. If it’s not Ferguson, it’s New York City. If not New York City, it’s Chicago or Detroit or Cleveland. And I believe the violence in our cities is only in its early stages. We had a taste of the conflict in the 1960s, but the fundamental values of equal justice and economic opportunity have receded further from reality. Failing to understand why the past 50 years of government expansion to eradicate poverty has only worsened the conditions of our cities will guarantee that the violent conflicts we see erupting today will only get worse.

Fight for Equal Protection Distorted by ‘War on Poverty’

Fifty years ago, as a result of Martin Luther King Jr.’s leadership in a plea for equal justice, LBJ declared war on poverty. Poverty was seen at that time as the major contributing factor in the plight of those living in the inner city. King’s dream was to make sure all people will be judged by the “content of their character” and not by “the color of their skin.” Good advice, but it was never followed. Residual racism remains, but the excuse for every shortcoming in the failed cities is said to be due to the color of one’s skin.

The very expensive war on poverty has after 50 years only made matters worse, compounding the problems of poverty and inflation while hurting most of the people the “war” was supposed to help. Currently our government spends over $1 trillion per year on anti-poverty programs. Over the past 50 years, over $16 trillion was spent, i.e., wasted. And yet poverty and dire economic conditions remain the major factor in the violence that persists, which incites or gives the police the excuse to overreact to maintain order. The plans and expectations for the war on poverty must have been seriously flawed.

Although the degree of poverty is different for the various races in the United States, all categories — Asian, white, Hispanic, and black — have had a steady increase in real median income from 1964 until the year 2000, when the first of many bubbles started bursting. In all four race categories incomes are lower since then. With the economy moving into the next stage of liquidation of bad investment and debt, we should expect this trend to continue. Economic setbacks and a decrease in real income are not limited to blacks in the inner city. The setback for the young has been dramatically worse than for the older generations, aggravating the problem of violent crime in our cities.

The “progress” of the early years of the war on poverty is understandable because the payment that always must be paid was delayed. The deficits and the borrowing and printing of money were unsustainable. It should not be difficult to understand that the welfare benefits, the bloated government, the excessive salaries, and the promised pensions for thousands of nonproductive bureaucrats in Detroit would lead to bankruptcy. The benefits had to be reduced. If policies don’t change and the politicians continue to be elected by wild promises, the disaster will continue. How can the provocateurs blame racism for the plight of the middle class in Detroit?

We must get people to reject flawed economic policy if we want a real war on poverty. LBJ’s war on poverty was no more successful than his Vietnam War — or any war since, for that matter. A national government that can print money as needed to finance extraordinary extravagance can function longer than a city, state, or private entity, but it too must eventually “file for bankruptcy” albeit in a different fashion. As we are now seeing, the bankruptcy of a nation also involves poverty for many. This situation will continue to worsen. Since poverty is a major contributing factor to the violence of excessive police militarization, some fundamentals must be understood. The economic theories of Paul Samuelson, Paul Krugman, John Maynard Keynes, and all those who claim to know how to “regulate” the economy to benefit the poor, must be challenged and abandoned.

So far reality has not yet set in. The poor grow in numbers as the middle class shrinks and the privileged class that benefits from government spending and government control of the monetary system thrives. The political demagogues and the authoritarians feed the flames of resentment that develop between the rich and the poor as class warfare and racial strife take over. They care little and understand less what liberty is all about — the more chaos there is, the more laws they seek to pass.

The Victimized Inner Cities

This social disruption has motivated the enthusiastic growth and militarization of our local police departments. The law and order crowd thrives on excessive laws and regulations that no US citizen can escape. The out-of-control war on drugs is the worst part, and it generates the greatest danger in poverty-ridden areas via out-of-control police. It is estimated that these conditions have generated up to 80,000 SWAT raids per year in the United States. Most are in poor neighborhoods and involve black homes and businesses being hit disproportionately. This involves a high percentage of no-knock attacks. As can be expected many totally innocent people are killed in the process. Property damage is routine and compensation is rare. The routine use of civil forfeiture of property has become an abomination, totally out of control, which significantly contributes to the chaos. It should not be a surprise to see resentment building up against the police under these conditions. The violent reaction against local merchants in retaliation for police actions further aggravates the situation —hardly a recipe for a safe neighborhood.

Though poverty and excessive laws associated with the war on drugs are significant factors in the conflicts that are routine in the inner-city, the overreaction by both sides continues to make the situation much worse. As a result, policing in general is out of control, and anything suggesting racial confrontation leads to rioting, looting, and property destruction. Civil liberties are ignored by the police, and the private property of innocent bystanders is disregarded by those resenting police violence. When police overreact and unfairly enforce the law, it elicits a violent reaction from those on the receiving end. This only escalates the problem. It’s an invitation for outside provocateurs to rush in and aggravate the racial tensions — all the while never trying to understand the real reasons behind police militarization and the cause of poverty.

The military-industrial complex now systematically lobbies to provide to local police departments the newest and most sophisticated weaponry — just as they sell weapons to the United States government to fight undeclared wars overseas. Drug laws are pushed by many corporate interests as well. Pharmaceutical companies, alcohol companies, and private prison systems all support of the insane war on drugs. The victims are the poor who suffer with a messed up economy and have no easy access to jobs. A natural temptation is to become a drug dealer. Violent activities arising from the drug war making drug transactions a criminal undertaking create demand in communities for strict law enforcement.

Why do the race baiters have so much success in making this type of conflict a racial problem alone? Unfortunately many of them make a living off stirring up trouble. If the situation were understood in terms of police brutality and poverty, the evening news would be dramatically different. Turning it into strictly a racial conflict narrows the discussion, and the idea of responsibility for one’s action no longer needs to be discussed.

The race factor seems to stir up the emotions. Mob-like responses can be achieved, which further inflames the situation. Out of control police and an entire segment of our population taught that responsibility for one’s actions is a negative are a volatile mix.

Justice under the law requires that people cannot be punished or rewarded because of the color of their skin, but unfortunately King’s claim that only a person’s character counts is forgotten.

The entitlement mentality is a source of much anger and misunderstanding. It leads people who see themselves as victims to one conclusion: they are entitled to be taken care of. They believe that more government transfer payments are the solution. They claim that they deserve to be taken care of and that, if they are not, there’s trouble to be had — which only opens the door to more police overreactions.

There is agreement with my contention that poverty is a big problem and the source of much trouble. Therefore, it is said, someone must take care of it. If one trillion dollars per year doesn’t do the job, then make it $2 trillion. If the war on poverty’s $16 trillion hasn’t worked, make it $32 trillion. This sentiment reflects the entitlement mentality that has taught many that some people have a “right” to government handouts and that the rich must pay. This is an idea that is deeply flawed, and it stirs up class warfare on top of racial animosities and police brutality.

The blanket demand that all wealthy individuals owe support to the poor through government welfare programs is not an example of equal justice under the law. It is an example of egalitarianism gone awry. Welfare, which is the use of force to transfer wealth from one group to another, is based on a moral principle of equality that in fact is not moral and does not work. The wealthy special interests, such as banks, the military-industrial complex, the medical industry, the drug industry, and many other corporatists, quickly gain control of the system. Crumbs may be thrown to the poor, but the principle of wealth transfer is hijacked and used for corporate and foreign welfare instead of wealth transfers to the poor.

Many people do indeed gain wealth unfairly with today’s system, which adds to the envy shared by many and especially the poor. But this is a problem that is not solved by indiscriminately placing blame on successful businesses. The result would be the country and the whole world becoming poorer while resentment rises. Honest profits of successful entrepreneurs are quite different than profits of the corporate elite who gain control of the government and, as a consequence, accumulate obscene wealth by “robbing” the middle class. To blame and destroy those who make an honest living by satisfying consumers without the use of special benefits from the government is destructive to liberty and wealth.

Reforms that are driven by envy of successful people making an honest living will not address the problem of poverty. Poverty is actually made worse by an aggressive sense of victimization.

Many factors are involved in the crisis of our cities, including the following:

Police brutality, militarization of the police, excessive laws, courts and law enforcement efforts ignoring the principles of equal justice,
Racism that exists to some degree on both sides of the conflict,
Rampant crime reflecting structural poverty,
Absence of an understanding of the difference between earned and stolen wealth,
Race baiting,
The entitlement mentality, self-reliance not being a goal for many, and the breakdown of the family unit,
The war on drugs, and
The lack of economic understanding regarding the Federal Reserve, taxes, welfare, economic consequences of constant war, deficits, and excessive government spending.

True satisfaction comes from productive effort and self-reliance and not from a government transferring wealth in an effort to bring about an egalitarian society. The absence of an understanding of the nonaggression principle makes it difficult for positive reforms to develop. Unfortunately hypocrisy has come to equal “common sense.” Placing confidence in people who thrive on wielding government power and who spend a lifetime using it to benefit special interests is not a wise policy.

The people have too little confidence that most problems can be solved in a voluntary manner in a society that cherishes civil liberties. There’s never an admission that government problem-solving doesn’t work. Government-created problems are a road to poverty and resentment. Too many people believe that “free stuff” from the government can solve our problems. They mistakenly believe that deficits don’t matter and that wealth can come from a printing press.

The recent high profile episodes of racial conflict involving police killings and the violence in some neighborhoods have been a fertile environment for the demagogues and those who thrive on racial conflict.

Some have suggested that sensitivity training for all police personnel should be required, to teach proper ways to deal with the public. Though there’s a lot of extenuating circumstances that provoke overreaction by the police, I’m not optimistic that the problem will be helped much by sensitivity training. Retraining the police won’t touch the complex problems that pit the police against the victims of complex social conditions generated by hate, violence and bad economic policies. The high profile episodes of police violence and overreaction are a consequence of conditions that in many ways were generated by government policy.

If social engineering intended to produce economic equality fails, more of the same cannot possibly be the solution. Seeking and promoting equal justice has nothing to do with welfare redistribution. On the contrary: equal justice requires the end of welfare redistribution. Redistribution is a process that is always destined to help a small minority, whether in an economy like ours that endorses central economic planning or in one run by radical fascists or communists. While advocates claim that it’s the duty of government to pursue economic equality, all efforts fail to achieve that goal, while gutting the principle of equal justice.

The Rich Are Getting Richer, But Why?

Under an authoritarian regime, those in power take care of themselves. This always leads to poverty and discrepancy in wealth distribution. Eventually the social strife that is predictable leads to an overthrow of the government. The Soviet communist leaders never suffered from want, but even they were routed when the people in the Soviet system decided that they had had enough.

We must realize that we are not exempt from a breakdown of our system. The strife that we are witnessing is a reflection of a growing number of people who are recognizing the discrepancy between rich and poor, the weak and the powerful, Wall Street and Main Street. The courts are obviously failing at meting out justice fairly and impartially. Money and race have a lot to do with how arrests, convictions, and incarcerations are carried out. That provides motivation for some people to become angry and violently strike out against anyone who appears to have more than they do.

While the courts fail to follow the rules of equal justice, those who react violently believe that attacking almost anyone is justifiable in seeking what they claim is justice. Talk of the 99 percent and one percent is not just sloganeering. It reveals a problem generated by government and a situation in which some people believe that they have a “right” to be taken care of rather than just a right to live in a free and just society where all persons are treated equally under the law.

Indeed the rich are getting richer and the poor poorer. The extreme current inequality is not a consequence of free markets and true liberty. Rather it results from the welfare state that, as always, morphs into a system that provides excesses for the powerful few. Better management of the welfare system does not help. That only changes the types of authoritarians in charge. Both political parties are financed by Wall Street, the big banks, and the military-industrial complex. Getting rich by being part of the government class is the problem. Wealth achieved by hard work is quite a bit different. Opening the door to this opportunity is achievable by following the principle of life, liberty, and property.

The economic interventionist system under which we live today rewards those who benefit from government economic planning by the Federal Reserve, access to government contracts, and targeted special regulations to help one group over the other. The insiders benefit during the bubble phase of the business cycle and are the first ones in line for the bailouts. The poor, for whom welfare is supposedly designed to help and for whom the politicians justify the spending, end up with the crumbs while the Wall Street/banking elites thrive in good times and bad. There are two problems. First is conceding the principle that government has the moral authority to redistribute wealth. Second is believing the redistribution will be managed wisely and without corruption.

All government management ends up being unwise, corrupt, and wasteful. The money interests inevitably prevail. Belief that “good” bureaucrats and politicians can be found to manage the economy and achieve equity in distribution is a dream that always ends up a nightmare. To make even a modest attempt at this goal requires government to use aggression against one group for the benefit of another. This authority must be denied to government. We must limit the government’s role to protecting equal justice in defense of life, liberty, and property.

Currently the political system in America and in most of the rest of the world is not motivated to seek this limited goal for government. Thus the move toward unfair concentration of wealth in the few and a dramatic increase in the number of people living in poverty as the middle class shrinks. Since there is little understanding of the economic system that is a major contributing factor to the economic problems, it can be expected to exacerbate social and class conflict. The killing of Michael Brown in Ferguson plus many similar incidents are signs of a serious economic and political crisis that is not limited to police brutality and runaway violence.

Police brutality and militarization may well induce a violent event far beyond what we have seen in Ferguson. It also can serve as an excuse. But it is not the root cause of turmoil. The real cause is poverty, the entitlement mentality, and the breakdown of the rule of law. Moral decay and the national police state are the real culprits.

More police with improved training will not do much to deal with this growing conflict. Bowing to entitlement demands from the “victims” will not be helpful in a bankrupt system. We have too many police, too many laws, and too much exemption of government officials from the crimes they commit. Both adding police and increasing entitlements involve expanding the role of government in an effort to solve problems that too much government has already caused. Government can only be expanded by diminishing the people’s liberty. This problem can only be ended by maximizing liberty and getting people to realize that self-reliance, hard work, and the absence of coercive force by individuals and government is the only way to reverse the downward trend from which we are suffering.

The battle will no longer be to get the government to pick sides in a conflict between rich and poor, black and white, young and old, or the lawless police versus the lawless demands of entitlement recipients demanding their “fair share.” There has to be an understanding that productive effort and self-reliance on the part of everyone is required for a free society to thrive.

Our Liberties Under Attack

The economic and moral decay of American society is reflected in the loss of liberties. This problem affects all Americans and not just the poor in the inner city. Gradual erosion of personal and economic liberty has proceeded for a century. The loss of our liberty has sharply accelerated since the 9/11 attacks. We have done to ourselves what no foreign enemy could have possibly accomplished.

Government surveillance provides the state with information that enables it to know our every move. The protection of the Fourth Amendment is gone. Many Americans are comfortable with the sacrifice of liberty for safety and accept the notion that government’s key responsibility is to keep us safe. It’s a nice dream but the truth is it can’t do it. One thing for sure: if it tries, it will do so at the expense of liberty.

Welfare, for the rich or poor, cannot exist without the sacrifice of the principal of property ownership. Though it always starts small and justified for the “needy,” the principle of wealth transfer incentivizes the special interests and the rich to obtain benefit at the expense of the poor. This occurs in all societies and inevitably grows to a point where the production of wealth is diminished and the system collapses. This is what we are witnessing today.

The growth of the state necessitates government surveillance of all our financial transactions to enhance the collection of tax revenues. Because there is never enough money for the “do-gooders,” the tactics of the tax collectors have become more vicious. Violation of our liberties is excused by the majority in order to ensure that all people “pay their fair share.” When conditions deteriorate, capital controls are imposed to prevent moving assets out of the country. Our monstrous tax code reflects the hundred-years development of our income tax system and is one of the greatest invitations for our “caring” government to pursue the impossible goal of the fair distribution of all wealth.

The vicious drug war, which dates from the early 1970s, provides another excuse for knowing everything about everybody at all times. Its selling point is to keep people safe from themselves. Pursuing this principle guarantees that liberty will be decimated in the process. It invites the government’s interference in our spiritual and intellectual well-being. What one reads and believes becomes of interest to the manipulators who want to care for us for our own good. And they never rest from seeking this goal.

This concession to the state invites controls on everything we put into our bodies: what we eat, drink, or inhale. It takes a lot of bureaucrats, politicians, and money to manage the process. The people, we have been told, are “too stupid” to make their own decisions about their own lives. We are to believe that politicians who invite themselves to rule over us are all-wise and that we should be thankful to sacrifice our liberty for this “service.” Authoritarians actually believe that we should be grateful to them for all the good things that they do for us. We must remember that if the people don’t rebel against a police state it only grows in size and becomes more ruthless.

In addition to all these trends — which includes the federal government monopolizing and administering medical care and education — government surveillance becomes the darling of the gurus who love the technology that allows the government to know our every move, every day, without limits.

With the disaster of 9/11, an existing acceptance of government monitoring, along with technological advances, helped allow a new age to be ushered in that makes the horrors of George Orwell’s 1984 look less threatening by comparison.

The Federal Government’s War on Us

Tolerance is a favorable trait when it means acting without aggression toward others, but tolerance of the monster that has evolved in our government is not good. Instead of adding more government agencies to spy on the American people, we should be talking about eliminating the ones we have, at a cost the American taxpayers of over $80 billion per year.

We have lived with the global war on terrorism for over 13 years now, and the threat of terrorist attacks against Americans and American allies is worse than ever. Though a global threat exists, the greatest dangers for American citizens here at home have been caused by our own government. Our government’s attacks on our liberties have been overwhelming and worse than anything any foreign power has ever done.

It’s the federal government that leads the charge in all our domestic wars, which, in addition to the global war on terrorism, include the war on drugs, taxpayers, and poverty, all of which contribute to the constant war on our privacy. Today every American is a suspect. Our president has established a policy that an American citizen can be assassinated without even being charged with a crime. The national police are made up of over 100,000 bureaucrats and police officials who carry guns to enforce federal law on the American citizens. The Founders and our Constitution intended that policing powers would be the responsibility of the individual states. That was forgotten a long time ago.

Not only do employees of agencies like the CIA, FBI, and BATF carry guns, employees of OSHA, EPA, Fish and Wildlife, and many other agencies enforcing regulations do so as well. The notion of total homeland security being provided by a heavily armed Department of Homeland Security was foreign to America up until just recently. Today, whether it’s riots in our cities or chaos after a national disaster like a hurricane, the Feds are there taking charge over all local officials and property owners, . It shouldn’t surprise us that our local police departments have become an arm of a runaway federal police mentality that mimics an army.

The Founders did not even want a standing army. They wanted only a militia. Today we endure, at the expense of our liberties, a national police force armed like an invading military force. We are destined to see a continued escalation of violence in our cities as the internal conflicts grow. Instead of the police quelling the violence, they unfortunately have become part of it.

It’s evident we have a national police force harassing the people and failing to protect liberty and property. It fails to quell riots while. Too often it incites them. We are also stuck with a huge “standing” army, marching around the world and engaged to some degree in over 150 countries, “making the world safe for democracy” and serving as a private police force for American corporations overseas.

The US Empire: Who Does it Serve?

When Obama announced a shift in geopolitical interest to the Far East —– to keep an eye on China —– one TV anchor pointed out that the move seems quite logical since we have a lot of “business interests” in the region. It is, in fact, far from logical if one looks at the tragic mess US government interventionism has caused in the Middle East and the conflict the US government is stirring up with Russia over Ukraine.

Old-fashioned colonialism was deemed necessary by various European powers to secure natural resources along with control over sea lanes and markets for selling manufactured goods. European-style colonialism — supporting a mercantilistic economy — came to be seen as politically unrealistic and unnecessary. When free-trade principles were utilized, colonialism did not die; it only changed form. Mercantilism in various forms and degrees drove trade policies of nations with strong economies and militaries. Though the United States is the world’s military powerhouse, controls the oceans and airspace, and has a presence in the four corners of the earth, few people refer to America as a colonial power. But in many ways it is, which has prompted our interests in oil and mineral rich countries. We are frequently involved in choosing the “elected” leaders, as well as hand-picking dictators, in many countries as well. This is not exactly what the Founders had advised.

International militarization of our policies is just as dangerous to our liberties and economy as is the domestic policy that drives our authoritarian governments to regulate our every move. We are now subject to an out-of-control domestic police force while the US military maintains our Empire overseas.

The “one percenters,” generally speaking, are internationalists who are not champions of individual liberty and free trade. They are supporters of managed trade and international institutions like the WTO where the interests of the one percent can influence the rulings that frequently have little to do with advancing advertised goals of low tariffs and free trade.

The international monetary system is a powerful tool for the select few. Easy credit, government guarantees, and generous contracts are a great benefit to those in charge. Non-compliant nations, or any country that is deemed unfriendly, can be punished with severe sanctions without moral or economic justification. US corporations benefit from our military presence worldwide. The military-industrial complex profits not only by selling weapons to the US government, but also by being the world’s chief arms provider.

It is a fact that many weapons we send into areas such as Iraq, Afghanistan, and Syria frequently end up in the hands of our enemies. ISIS obtaining US weapons led to the US military then taking action to destroy the weapons. The military-industrial complex is immediately available to replace the weapons while earning generous profits. This is great if you happen to be an insider manufacturing or selling these weapons. It is quite a lucrative business, all at the expense of the American taxpayer.

The United States military presence around the world provides a “private” police force to protect US and other international companies against any local resistance or leaders that turn unfriendly. Our military presence overseas has nothing to do with protecting our freedoms and defending our Constitution. Those are lies and are used for the purpose of gaining the support of the American people for wars that should never have been fought. After long periods of tragic losses and expense, the American people generally wake up and realize what has happened. But what we need to do is wake the American people up earlier and get them to realize that the resistance has to be heard from the people when the government is preparing for war, not after the war has begun or even ended.

Military personnel are idolized, and, if any one raises a question on whether or not all soldiers are universally “heroes,” that person is accused of being unpatriotic, un-American, and unsupportive of the troops. In fact, the real heroes are the ones who expose the truth and refuse to fight foreign wars for the international corporations. Disengaging our troops from around the world and refusing to defend American neocolonialism is pursuing a course compatible with the qualities that Americans claim to stand for.

Liberty at home is never enhanced by war abroad. Preemptive wars are especially antagonistic to the goals of peace, commerce, and honest friendship. War “is the health of the state,” it has been said, and the state is the enemy of liberty. Wars overseas justify the wars at home against the American people. It is expected that liberties will be sacrificed when a country is at war. Pro-war neoconservatives are blatantly honest by arguing that for freedom to exist the sacrifice of liberty is required. This admission is truly discouraging. It hardly makes sense that voluntarily sacrificing liberty is worthwhile, if the goal is to preserve liberty. Time is short to reverse this trend.

Not only are our policies destructive to liberty, the economic costs are prohibitive. So far the bills have not been paid, but they are rapidly coming due. Both the deeply flawed policy of military interventionism abroad and the failed errors of central economic planning at home are now threatening our liberties and our general welfare. The recent breakout of violence in our cities between police on one side and people who have been thrust into the stagnation of poverty as a consequence of bad government social and economic policy on the other side should not be a mystery if one could see the forest for the trees. Economic problems are “blowback” and unintended consequences of well-meaning welfare programs that have been usurped by the powerful special interests demanding benefits off the top.

Yes, it’s tempting to believe the falsehoods of economists who claim that transferring wealth for fairness sake is beneficial, but history shows that it never works. The same humanitarians argue that all spending is crucial and beneficial, deficits don’t matter, borrowing is good, and taxing is the equalizer. If government still comes up short they say just turn on the printing presses. That is the philosophy we have been living with for 85 years, and the evidence is now in. It is clear to most Americans that these policies have not worked. Yet they are not ready to concede that it is less government and more freedom that is the solution.

The obsession with continuing all the same policies has increased our poverty, increased violence between the classes, and lowered the standard of living for all except the elite one percent. And worst of all, the sacrifice of liberty was for naught. Losing both liberty and the right to truly own property undermines the ability to create wealth. When this process gets out-of-control the economy goes into a death spiral, in the beginning of which we currently find ourselves. Without a correction to the basic understanding of the proper role of government, the downward spiral will continue.

Blowback All Around: We Are Less Safe

Economic blowback and unintended consequences is one thing, but blowback from our needless and aggressive policies around the world is another, and every bit as dangerous. As we find ourselves increasingly engaged economically and militarily around the world, we can expect many more attacks on American interests. With so many military personnel abroad, they will be the easiest targets to be hit. But attacks similar in nature to the 9/11 attacks will remain a threat to our homeland. We will not be attacked because we are free and rich. The attacks will come from angry people who have had friends and relatives killed by America’s careless and often vicious use of our military force in their countries.

It is not that difficult to feel resentment against a country that comes thousands of miles from home and bombs, invades, and punishes with sanctions, other countries that have never initiated force against it. As long as our foreign policy remains the same we can expect serious blowback attacks — and for them to increase in number as our prowess is diminished. Economic factors will determine this, and the loss of dollar hegemony will aggravate the situation.

The US government’s foolishness in foreign affairs has plagued us for 100 years. The escalation of our presence around the world since 9/11 continues. It is a policy “bubble” of gigantic proportions. This “bubble” of intervention is about to burst. Any serious look at our last 13 years of intervention around the world should convince all skeptics of how foolish, dangerous, and expensive it has been. The US operates with an attitude that it has the power and therefore the responsibility to be involved in deciding almost every foreign leader, whether elected or appointed as a dictator.

We have been engaged in picking and financing political factions in revolts in countries including Egypt, Libya, Pakistan, Yemen, Afghanistan, Iraq, Kurdistan, Syria, Ukraine, Somalia, Nigeria, the Philippines, Liberia, Georgia, Haiti, and Lebanon.

These involvements impose a huge tax and inflation burden on the American people. Trillions of dollars have been spent, and the debt continues to mount. The abject failure of our efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan elicits a loud call from the neoconservatives for more money, troops, weapons, and bombs, with zero hope of a successful mission. ISIS, now considered our greatest threat, is not even a country, but our occupation and destruction in the region motivates even a ragtag bunch to expel foreign forces from their homeland. ISIS has rallied enormous support and resources to undermine our allies in the region. That assessment is difficult, of course, since it’s hard for anyone to identify exactly who our allies are and distinguish them from our avowed enemies.

US foreign policy has helped create the disastrous situation in Syria. We declared that Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad had to go. We supported rebel factions. We armed them. They turned on us and used their American weapons against us with an amazing resistance headed by the ruthless ISIS, an outgrowth of al-Qaeda. It’s quite an irony that ISIS is well entrenched in northern Iraq, since before we decided to invade Iraq and kill Saddam Hussein no al-Qaeda were present in Iraq. Now the neocons are getting their way and American forces are returning with reinforcements and weapons to save Baghdad from the jihadists.

No one can make this stuff up. It’s too bizarre for fiction. Unfortunately, with the help of the media and our government, the American people have remained oblivious to the stupidity of our policies of the past 13 years. A day will come though when the full cost of this policy is dumped on the American people. Then they will get the message. Then it will be too late to gracefully exit and restore sanity without cataclysmic changes being forced on us. The major challenge will be the survival of our liberties.

What to expect in 2015?

Foreign Affairs

More American troops will be sent overseas to places like Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, and Ukraine. There will be no military victories to brag about. More American military personnel will be killed in 2015 than in 2014. Military contractors will be used in growing numbers and their casualties will not be counted as military casualties.

The Ukraine civil war will not end, and the United States will be further bogged down in this conflict. Relations with Russia will continue to deteriorate. The neocons in Congress will gain even more influence over our foreign policy. Punishing sanctions will continue to be made more severe and push Russia further into China’s sphere of influence. Gold will gain credibility as we isolate the Russians from the financial markets.

Sanctions on Russia will alienate Europe against the United States. The British oil industry will suffer from the “conspiracy” of the US and Saudi Arabia to drive oil prices down to punish Russia.

The military-industrial complex will continue to thrive and make even more money with the greater influence of the neocons in the new Congress. Supplemental budgets for the military should be expected, along with covert assistance and additional foreign aid to finance the management of our Empire.

Our enemies’ strength will grow and prompt even more abuse of American citizens’ privacy and free expression. We should not be surprised if there is a reigniting of the conflict in the Balkans. The first of the color revolutions in 2000 in Serbia can hardly be claimed a permanent victory. Generally, bombs from outsiders don’t solve internal problems. Those problems must eventually be solved from within a country rather than from outside interference.

The US and NATO announced that the 13 year war in Afghanistan has ended. There has been neither the pretense of “Mission Accomplished” nor an admission of outright failure, along with an exodus. In reality the war has not ended and instead will continue for a long time. No victory for US policy is possible. The conflict will actually spread and increase in intensity since our goals are undefinable and therefore the war is un-winnable.

Sanity will not return to US leaders until our financial system collapses — an event for which they are feverishly working
Domestic issues

An honest assessment of the economy will not reveal any significant improvement in 2015. Inflation will continue to plague us, possibly even with the government-rigged CPI figures showing an increase. But the true inflation of the Fed’s credit creation, as well as the subsequent mal- investment and the various bubbles bursting will accelerate. Debt in all categories will continue to increase at unsustainable rates. The Fed will not permit interest rates to rise — at least on purpose. Eventually the market will demand that rates do rise, however.

Tax revenues will continue to rise, aiding the policy of the government spending the people’s money rather than those who earned it. Regulations, even with (or maybe especially with) a Republican Congress will continue to increase and make the Federal Register more incomprehensible. Friction between the middle class and the one percent, many of whom are living off government privileges, will escalate further and be reflected in confrontations especially in the large cities. Financial currency controls will continue to expand especially with cross-border transactions.

Blowback and unintended consequences from our sanctions and foreign policy in general will continue to threaten our domestic security and our economy, as well as our liberties.

Relations with Cuba will be improved with the president’s effort to resume diplomatic relations, but the radicals and isolationists who oppose free trade will place roadblocks in the way and slow the process.

A major geopolitical or economic event, greater than the crisis of 2008, is fast approaching. The precipitating event will be a surprise to the majority of politicians and economists. There are many “next shoe to drop” possibilities, and one could happen any time or any place.

Wall Street will be protected, and the trillions of dollars of big banks derivatives will be absorbed by the Fed, the FDIC, and ultimately by the American taxpayers in the next financial crisis. There’s no doubt the poor will get poorer and the rich richer until the spirit of revolution in the people calls a halt to the systematic destruction of freedom in America.

Conclusion: Toward a Peaceful Revolution

Authoritarianism has overtaken our economic system as the welfare mentality takes over at every level of government. Once the initiation of force by government is accepted by the people, even minimally, it escalates and involves every aspect of society. The only question that remains is just who gets to wield the power to distribute the largess to their friends and chosen beneficiaries. It’s a recipe for steady growth of the government at the expense of liberties, even if official documents and laws written to limit government power are in place. Planting even small seeds of monopoly power in the hands of a few people in government, whether democratically elected or not, will always metastasize like a cancer. This was Jefferson’s concern when he advised that “[t]he tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time.” He believed the people must warn the rulers that taking up arms against the government is legitimate if the government fails to protect the people’s liberty.

This should be a consideration. But if the spirit of liberty is not alive and well in the hearts and minds of the people, violence alone against the government will not be a solution. History has shown that, more often than not, people who rebel against abusive governments, whether run by kings or modern day dictators, do not gain much — overthrowing one dictator and replacing him with another just as bad.

A clear understanding of the nature and source of liberty is required for revolutions to be beneficial. Restraining the few who thrive on the use of force to rule over us is the challenge. Fortunately they are outnumbered by those who would choose liberty yet lack the will to challenge the humanitarian monsters who gain support from naive and apathetic citizens. All positive revolutions must be philosophic in nature to make a difference. Violence alone achieves nothing.

Before we can actually restore our liberties, we most likely will have to become a lot less free and much poorer. This is sad since correct and workable answers are available to us if only the people understood them and demanded liberty and honesty, rather than being dependent on excessive government power and believing the false promises of politicians.

Even with the problems we face today and the bleak outlook for the coming year there’s much to encourage us. During this next year there will be the continuation of many more people recognizing the failure of government to create peace and prosperity. More widespread understanding of this truth is required in order to bring about a successful revolution.

The freedom movement, especially with many young people involved, will grow in numbers and influence.

Current monetary policy and the Federal Reserve will continue to lose credibility, especially with the next bailout. Although “too big to fail” will stay in place, it will further alienate Main Street America causing it to rebel against the system.

The real problem of course is that too many “stupid people” are IN our government and have high visibility on the major TV networks. There will be plenty of people, not officially associated with government, who will rebel against various governments around the world. The sentiments supporting secession, jury nullification, nullification of federal laws by state legislatures, and a drive for more independence from larger governments will continue.

We should not be discouraged. Enlightenment is not nearly as difficult to achieve as it was before the breakthrough with Internet communications occurred.  Besides we must remember that “an idea whose time has come” cannot be stopped by armies, demagogues, politicians, or even Fox News or MSNBC. The time has come for the ideas of liberty to prevail. I smell progress. Let’s make 2015 a fun year for LIBERTY.

Source

 

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
Bill to Amend the War Powers Resolution

Bill to Amend the War Powers Resolution

Bill to Amend the War Powers Resolution

By Red Pill Reports

Bill to Amend the War Powers Resolution

Japanese-American internment center 3, Manzanar, California. Image: Public Domain

Senator Carl Levin of Michigan thinks the President needs more power to make war. Below, his Senate floor statement on amending the War Powers Resolution. Among other things, Levin states,

“Today, I filed a bill that would amend the War Powers Resolution to authorize the President to act against non-State actors like ISIS, where he judges it necessary to address a continuing and imminent threat to the United States, subject to a resolution of disapproval by Congress under the War Powers Resolution.”

I believe that reads “War Powers Resolution to authorize the President to act against non-State actors like ISIS, where he judges it necessary“. Is this appearing more and more like a dictatorship?

non·state ac·tor
noun
plural noun: non-state actors

  1. an individual or organization that has significant political influence but is not allied to any particular country or state.

The “War Powers Clause” of the United States Constitution Article I, Section 8, Clause 11 vests in the Congress the power to declare war, in the following wording:

[The Congress shall have Power…] To declare War, grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water.

The Congressional Declaration of war on Japan was on December 8, 1941. Since then, the United States has only issued five other war declarations: against Germany and Italy (on December 11, 1941) and against Bulgaria, Hungary and Rumania (on June 4, 1942).

And in total, war declarations were declared by Congress in the War of 1812, the Mexican-American War, the Spanish-American War, World War I and World War II.

Some of the most life altering “Bills and Resolutions” have been passed between Christmas Eve and New years day.

The Senate passed the Federal Reserve Act December 23, 1913. It took many months and nearly straight party-line voting, but on December 23, 1913, the Senate passed and President Woodrow Wilson signed the Federal Reserve Act.

Secrecy was paramount. “Discovery,” wrote one attendee later, “simply must not happen, or else all our time and effort would have been wasted. If it were to be exposed publicly that our particular group had got together and written a banking bill, that bill would have no chance whatever of passage by Congress.”

Most members of congress had gone home for the holidays, but unfortunately the senate had not adjourned sene die (without day) so they were technically still in session. There were only three members still present. On a unanimous consent voice vote the 1913 Federal Reserve Act was passed. No objection was made, possibly because there was no one there to object.

The section of the NDAA granting the government the power to put citizens in military detention indefinitely and without the usual recourse to civil courts, was signed by the President on New Years Eve 2011.

With these things in mind, here is Senator Carl Levin’s complete Statement on the Senate floor;

Levin Senate floor statement on amending the War Powers Resolution

Mr. President, when the War Powers Resolution was passed over a Presidential veto in 1973, its supporters expected that the War Powers Resolution would ensure that a national dialogue takes place before the employment of the U.S. Armed Forces in hostilities.

The President, on the other hand, argued that the enactment of the legislation “would seriously undermine this Nation’s ability to act decisively and convincingly in times of international crisis.” In his veto message, President Nixon argued that: “As a result, the confidence of our allies in our ability to assist them could be diminished and the respect of our adversaries for our deterrent posture could decline. A permanent and substantial element of unpredictability would be injected into the world’s assessment of American behavior, further increasing the likelihood of miscalculation and war.”

The President was particularly concerned that the War Powers Resolution’s termination of certain authorities after 60 days unless extended by Congress would create unpredictability in U.S. foreign policy. The War Powers Resolution requires the President to consult “in every possible instance” prior to introducing U.S. Armed Forces into hostilities and to report to Congress within 48 hours when, absent a declaration of war, U.S. Armed Forces are introduced into “hostilities or … situations where imminent involvement in hostilities is clearly indicated by the circumstances.” After this report is submitted, the resolution requires that U.S. troops be withdrawn at the end of 60 days, unless Congress authorizes continued involvement by passing a declaration of war or some other specific authorization for continued U.S. involvement in such hostilities.

Every subsequent President has viewed the War Powers Resolution as an unconstitutional impingement on the President’s powers as Commander in Chief. As a result, the 60-day trigger in the Act has never been used to terminate hostilities, and the national dialogue envisioned by the authors of the Resolution has failed to come about.

At this very moment, our troops have been engaged in hostilities in Iraq and Syria for more than 60 days, without the enactment of an authorizing resolution by Congress. Some believe that the continuing hostilities are a violation of the War Powers Resolution. Others argue that the War Powers Resolution hasn’t been triggered, because our military actions can be justified under earlier authorizations. Either way, it is clear that the 60-day limitation in the Resolution has had no more force and effect in the case of the battle against ISIS than it did in earlier actions in Bosnia, Kosovo, and elsewhere.

I believe that the War Powers Resolution needs to be modernized to make it more relevant to the situations our military is likely to face in the 21st century – in particular, the ongoing struggle against new and evolving terrorist groups.

Today, I filed a bill that would amend the War Powers Resolution to authorize the President to act against non-State actors like ISIS, where he judges it necessary to address a continuing and imminent threat to the United States, subject to a resolution of disapproval by Congress under the War Powers Resolution. This approach would allow the President to take decisive action to address imminent terrorist threats, while reserving a clear role for Congress through a resolution of disapproval. I believe that this approach would provide for a national dialogue on the use of military force with respect to non-state actors like ISIS, while avoiding the dead end provided unworkable requirement of the current War Powers Resolution, under which congressional inaction could require U.S. troops to suddenly disengage from the enemy while in harm’s way.

My amendment would provide that the authority to use U.S. armed forces against non-state actors would terminate after 60 days unless either: (1) the President’s actions are based on a law providing for the use of military force against a non-state actor; or (2) the President notifies Congress that continued use of military force is necessary because the non-state actor poses a “continuing and imminent threat” to the United States or U.S. persons, and Congress does not enact a joint resolution of disapproval under expedited procedures.

Expedited procedures under the War Powers Resolution would ensure that Congress considers the issue. Under these procedures, if a resolution of disapproval is filed in a timely manner by any Senator, the Senate Foreign Relations Committee would have 15 calendar days to report the resolution or be discharged. The Senate would then have three days to consider the Resolution, with time equally divided between proponents and opponents of the measure. As with any joint resolution, the measure could be vetoed, and such a veto would be subject to an override vote in Congress.

I believe this approach would provide greater clarity for the Executive and Legislative branches and I hope a future Senate will consider it.

SourceWar Powers AmendmentCongressional Record – Senate for December 16, 2014.

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
The Christmas Truce of 1914 – Pinhole of Light Among a Nightmare of Madness

The Christmas Truce of 1914 – Pinhole of Light Among a Nightmare of Madness

The Christmas Truce of 1914 – Pinhole of Light Among a Nightmare of Madness

By Tony Cartalucci | Land Destroyer

The Christmas Truce of 1914

December 24, 2014 (Tony Cartalucci – LD) In the end, we have more in common with the furthest flung foreign common man than the closest corporate-fascist that presumes dominion over our lives.

During the early 1900’s, Europe was locked in the first World War. Millions would perish – tens of thousands in a single day. On one brief occasion, a pinhole of light shined through this utter madness, revealing the truth of this man-made nightmare. The men in the trenches were being driven toward each other, not by some irreconcilable difference they had with one another, but by the greed of those ruling elite residing in their respective homelands.

If only the British and Germans realized it was the greed of their own banking houses and industrialists that had them in the trenches and not some irreconcilable difference amongst themselves…

Knowledge is power, ignorance literally can mean death. When will we start being leaders in our homes, communities, counties, and provinces – driving our own destiny rather than being driven? Shall we look upon the Christmas Truce of 1914 with wonder a century on, or look toward it as evidence something was and still is tragically wrong with human civilization and work this next year with renewed vigor to resolve it?

Source

Wikipedia

The Christmas truce (German: Weihnachtsfrieden; French: Trêve de Noël) was a series of widespread but unofficial ceasefires along the Western Front around Christmas 1914. In the week leading up to the holiday, German and British soldiers crossed trenches to exchange seasonal greetings and talk. In areas, men from both sides ventured into no man’s land on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day to mingle and exchange food and souvenirs. There were joint burial ceremonies and prisoner swaps, while several meetings ended in carol-singing. Men played games of football with one another, giving one of the most enduring images of the truce. However, the peaceful behaviour was not ubiquitous; fighting continued in some sectors, while in others the sides settled on little more than arrangements to recover bodies. The following year, a few units arranged ceasefires, but the truces were not nearly as widespread as in 1914; this was, in part, due to strongly worded orders from the high commands of both sides prohibiting fraternisation

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
You Want To Vaccinate My Child? Just Sign This Form

You Want To Vaccinate My Child? Just Sign This Form

You Want To Vaccinate My Child? Just Sign This Form

By Dave Mihalovic | Prevent Disease

You Want To Vaccinate My Child? Just Sign This Form

I have yet to meet a Physician that will sign this form now downloaded by hundreds of parents. The reason they won’t sign is two-fold: First, they do not want to place themselves in a vulnerable position of being negligent for not providing informed consent to thousands of other parents; and second, many of them realize after their own extensive research that the risks far outweigh any benefits when it comes to vaccination.

It’s been over a year since hundreds of parents have downloaded this form and there are still no reports of any signatures. Many physicians won’t even look at the form while they dismiss a parent’s anti-vaccination stance as ridiculous. The behavior is a clear indication of a very misinformed Physician who does not have his or her patient’s best interests at heart. They are not willing to inform their patients of the risks, only the benefits they feel are acceptable. They are not open-minded to any other side of the debate except their own biased view passed down through the medical system.

Then are those Physicians who have questioned the vaccination schedules and will pursue their own research. Many of them are now awakening themselves thanks to ongoing research and pressure from parents and even other colleagues to look at other perspectives besides their own indoctrination. If you are pressured by any Physician to vaccinate, please download and print this form (and send us a Physician signed copy if possible). Assertively state to your Doctor that it is the only way you will fully informed to consider vaccination, and that an analyses of the risks and benefits will better allow you evaluate the decision.

100% of Physicians approached with this form have so far declined to sign it.

Physician’s Warranty of Vaccine Safety Form

The following form was adapted from Ken Anderson’s original.

Download PDF English
Physician’s Warranty of Vaccine Safety

Download PDF Espanol
Garantia Medica para la Seguridad en las Vacunas

Download PDF Francais
Formulaire a faire signer (Vaccins)


PHYSICIAN’S WARRANTY OF VACCINE SAFETY
I (Physician’s name, degree)_______________, _____ am a physician licensed to practice medicine in the State/Province of _________. My State/Provincial license number is ___________ , and my DEA number is ____________. My medical specialty is _______________I have a thorough understanding of the risks and benefits of all the medications that I prescribe for or administer to my patients. In the case of (Patient’s name) ______________ , age _____ , whom I have examined, I find that certain risk factors exist that justify the recommended vaccinations. The following is a list of said risk factors and the vaccinations that will protect against them:
Risk Factor __________________________
Vaccination __________________________
Risk Factor __________________________
Vaccination __________________________
Risk Factor __________________________
Vaccination __________________________I am aware that vaccines may contain many of the following chemicals, excipients, preservatives and fillers:* aluminum hydroxide
* aluminum phosphate
* ammonium sulfate
* amphotericin B
* animal tissues: pig blood, horse blood, rabbit brain,
* arginine hydrochloride
* dog kidney, monkey kidney,
* dibasic potassium phosphate
* chick embryo, chicken egg, duck egg
* calf (bovine) serum
* betapropiolactone
* fetal bovine serum
* formaldehyde
* formalin
* gelatin
* gentamicin sulfate
* glycerol
* human diploid cells (originating from human aborted fetal tissue)
* hydrocortisone
* hydrolized gelatin
* mercury thimerosol (thimerosal, Merthiolate(r))
* monosodium glutamate (MSG)
* monobasic potassium phosphate
* neomycin
* neomycin sulfate
* nonylphenol ethoxylate
* octylphenol ethoxylate
* octoxynol 10
* phenol red indicator
* phenoxyethanol (antifreeze)
* potassium chloride
* potassium diphosphate
* potassium monophosphate
* polymyxin B
* polysorbate 20
* polysorbate 80
* porcine (pig) pancreatic hydrolysate of casein
* residual MRC5 proteins
* sodium deoxycholate
* sorbitol
* thimerosal
* tri(n)butylphosphate,
* VERO cells, a continuous line of monkey kidney cells, and
* washed sheep red bloodand, hereby, warrant that these ingredients are safe for injection into the body of my patient. I have researched reports to the contrary, such as reports that mercury thimerosal causes severe neurological and immunological damage, and find that they are not credible.

I am aware that some vaccines have been found to have been contaminated with Simian Virus 40 (SV 40) and that SV 40 is causally linked by some researchers to non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma and mesotheliomas in humans as well as in experimental animals. I hereby warrant that the vaccines I employ in my practice do not contain SV 40 or any other live viruses. (Alternately, I hereby warrant that said SV-40 virus or other viruses pose no substantive risk to my patient.)

I hereby warrant that the vaccines I am recommending for the care of (Patient’s name) _______________ do not contain any tissue from aborted human babies (also known as “fetuses”).

In order to protect my patient’s well being, I have taken the following steps to guarantee that the vaccines I will use will contain no damaging contaminants.

STEPS TAKEN: _________________________
_______________________________________
_______________________________________
_______________________________________

I have personally investigated the reports made to the VAERS (Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System) and state that it is my professional opinion that the vaccines I am recommending are safe for administration to a child under the age of 5 years.

The bases for my opinion are itemized on Exhibit A, attached hereto, — “Physician’s Bases for Professional Opinion of Vaccine Safety.” (Please itemize each recommended vaccine separately along with the bases for arriving at the conclusion that the vaccine is safe for administration to a child under the age of 5 years.)

The professional journal articles I have relied upon in the issuance of this Physician’s Warranty of Vaccine Safety are itemized on Exhibit B , attached hereto, — “Scientific Articles in Support of Physician’s Warranty of Vaccine Safety.”

The professional journal articles that I have read which contain opinions adverse to my opinion are itemized on Exhibit C , attached hereto, — “Scientific Articles Contrary to Physician’s Opinion of Vaccine Safety”

The reasons for my determining that the articles in Exhibit C were invalid are delineated in Attachment D , attached hereto, — “Physician’s Reasons for Determining the Invalidity of Adverse Scientific Opinions.”

Hepatitis B

I understand that 60 percent of patients who are vaccinated for Hepatitis B will lose detectable antibodies to Hepatitis B within 12 years. I understand that in 1996 only 54 cases of Hepatitis B were reported to the CDC in the 0-1 year age group. I understand that in the VAERS, there were 1,080 total reports of adverse reactions from Hepatitis B vaccine in 1996 in the 0-1 year age group, with 47 deaths reported.

I understand that 50 percent of patients who contract Hepatitis B develop no symptoms after exposure. I understand that 30 percent will develop only flu-like symptoms and will have lifetime immunity. I understand that 20 percent will develop the symptoms of the disease, but that 95 percent will fully recover and have lifetime immunity.

I understand that 5 percent of the patients who are exposed to Hepatitis B will become chronic carriers of the disease. I understand that 75 percent of the chronic carriers will live with an asymptomatic infection and that only 25 percent of the chronic carriers will develop chronic liver disease or liver cancer, 10-30 years after the acute infection. The following scientific studies have been performed to demonstrate the safety of the Hepatitis B vaccine in children under the age of 5 years.
____________________________________
____________________________________ _____________________________________

In addition to the recommended vaccinations as protections against the above cited risk factors, I have recommended other non-vaccine measures to protect the health of my patient and have enumerated said non-vaccine measures on Exhibit D , attached hereto, “Non-vaccine Measures to Protect Against Risk Factors” I am issuing this Physician’s Warranty of Vaccine Safety in my professional capacity as the attending physician to (Patient’s name) ________________________________. Regardless of the legal entity under which I normally practice medicine, I am issuing this statement in both my business and individual capacities and hereby waive any statutory, Common Law, Constitutional, UCC, international treaty, and any other legal immunities from liability lawsuits in the instant case. I issue this document of my own free will after consultation with competent legal counsel whose name is _____________________________, an attorney admitted to the Bar in the State of __________________ .
_________________________ (Name of Attending Physician)
______________________ L.S. (Signature of Attending Physician)
Signed on this _______ day of ______________ A.D. ________
Witness: _________________ Date: _____________________
Notary Public: _____________Date: ______________________

=================================================

I’m really anxious to hear back from any readers whose doctor decides to sign this document in an effort to satisfy your peace of mind. I also have a lengthy list of legal professionals who are very curious as well.

Source

Dave Mihalovic is a Naturopathic Doctor who specializes in vaccine research, cancer prevention and a natural approach to treatment.

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
New Social Media Site Hosted in Iceland – Move to Seen.is Today

New Social Media Site Hosted in Iceland – Move to Seen.is Today

New Social Media Site Hosted in Iceland – Move to Seen.is Today

By Chris Kitze | Red Pill Reports

Move to Seen.is Today

Those of you who are experiencing censorship with Facebook and are tiring of this, you can now go to Seen.is and build your own community there for free.  We built this for Before It’s News and Unseen users.

You are accustomed to having quite a bit of freedom at our sites and it’s sad when Facebook censors important stories by “disappearing” them, or posting a “warning” about the site you are visiting.  Several weeks ago, I posted a story about the persecution of Falun Gong and Christians in China and Facebook put up a warning about it.  This story exposed some of the facts about the live organ harvesting happening today.  They have removed a lot of radar data from MH370, the missing airliner.

If stories like this are censored…what else are you missing?

Here are some of the differences you’ll find at Seen.is:

No censorship!  Keep in mind we do have a Terms of Service that will need to be followed for things like pornography, copyright violations and defamation.  If we receive a complaint, we’ll investigate.  If you are accustomed to the freewheeling style at Before It’s News, we think you’ll enjoy Seen.is

NO ID required.  The Face is now asking certain people for their ID’s.  That’s beyond the pale.  You can use whatever name you’d like at Seen and no ID required.  Sheesh!!

No search crawlers.  We’re blocking those critters because once they crawl a page, whatever you posted is theirs forever.  We think you should be able to delete things if you make a mistake.  We know this will hurt the traffic, but we think you’ll appreciate this.

We don’t sell your data, in fact we don’t even collect it (other than your email so you can receive notifications).  It’s hosted in Iceland and selling data isn’t allowed there.  A very good reason to go visit Iceland.  A lot of very friendly people there, too.

No limit to your account’s friends.  If you’re popular enough to get over 5,000 friends, we think that’s great!  More power to you!

Private and secure chat rooms are coming soon!  It looks like we might be able to get private chat rooms on Seen in a couple of weeks, too.  These are strongly encrypted and there’s no snooping.

Even if you have your Face somewhere else, you are always very welcome to visit Seen.is, get an account and invite your friends.  It’s always free (no charge), so feel the freedom today!

Source

 

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
Is My Mortgage Funding American Black Ops?

Is My Mortgage Funding American Black Ops?

Is My Mortgage Funding American Black Ops?

By Greg Morse | Red Pill Reports

(RedPillReports) I think it is important that I attempt to set the stage for our discussion by explaining why I am involved, how I got involved, why I am doing what I am doing, why we all are at truly great risk, how the RICO Fraud being perpetrated against us is out of control and why we must unite, RIGHT NOW, as a collective society, BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE.

In my opinion, this mortgage crisis is the most significant, destructive and all-encompassing threat we currently face as Americans. Many folks talk about the problems but seem to feel helpless when it comes to identifying solutions. I think we have solutions staring us in the face if we will simply do something about it.

Your Mortgage Is Funding American Black Ops

Image credit: The Truth About [CC-BY-SA-2.0]

I constantly hear people state that they think it is an “us against them” scenario and that there are no people in government who care to do anything to correct the wrongs we are experiencing. I do not agree with this thought and we can discuss why I disagree.

Since I attempt to factually evidence as much as I can, you can go to the website, download the documents and read for yourself, the words and desires of people like U. S. Attorney Preet Bharara in New York. (Documents: http://saveourfamilyandhome.com/ and https://redpillreports.com/red-pill-reports-documents-page#Mortgages)

Mr. Bharara is one of the good guys and clearly stated in a public speech on March 31, 2013 that he is in this fight together with us and openly solicited our help in making him aware of bad acts and evidence that he may not have. He is an honest and ethical prosecutor who does not believe that the money changers are “too big to fail, too big to prosecute and too big to jail” just as most of us feel. Mr. Bharara is the type of government official we, as a united group, need to reach out to, as he asks for help by exchanging information, providing evidence and helping him to do his job in a timely manner instead of him finding out about egregious situations that do tremendous harm, before he even knows about it.

Just like most of you, I got fed up with this out-of-control corruption decimating our Country and realized that we could not sit around, talk, complain, wring our hands and do NOTHING. I was first exposed to this type of organized corruption when I was one of a small group of people who helped to uncover the S & L Crisis in Texas in the mid-1980’s.

Jumping to the present, I refinanced my home in March 2008. The mortgage bubble became public in October 2008. Soon thereafter, I became aware that my mortgage broker had been indicted on 5 counts of mortgage fraud. With this awareness and due to my prior experience in the S & L Crisis, I began investigating my own mortgage. At this point, I realized there were many similarities between these two meltdowns.

In my opinion, the major similarity between the S & L Crisis and the Mortgage Meltdown is the fact that both were caused by the existence pre-engineered RICO Fraud Enterprises. The significant difference between the two meltdowns is that the Mortgage Meltdown is 100’s of Orders of Magnitude larger than the S & L Crisis and the Mortgage Meltdown is having a major GLOBAL impact.

I discovered over 900 individual instances of laws that had been broken and determined that corruption and fraud was rampant in all parts of my mortgage transaction. (I had never been late on or missed a mortgage payment.)

I put the “supposed lender” on legal written notice that they were in DEFAULT on my “Mortgage Trust Contract”. With Counsel, I filed a Federal Fraud Lawsuit on April 26, 2011. After being set-up, misrepresented, mislead and lied to by a very prominent legal professional and ex-Judge, my first Case was dismissed after my Counsel had represented that this would never happen. Then, after subsequently being unable to find a replacement attorney who was truly courageous and willing to stand up and fight the fraud and corruption, I realized that I had two choices, either quit or commit to go the full course. I chose the latter option.

As a Pro Se Plaintiff, I filed a Civil RICO (Racketeer Influence Corrupt Organizations Act) Fraud Activities Lawsuit that is referred to, on the Court Docket, as the “Amended Complaint” on August 20, 2012 in U. S. Federal District Court in the Eastern District of Texas. I will discuss RICO in detail and what it means to all of us in a moment.

It appeared, based upon the people expressing the desire, that someone needed to without any reservation or limitation, go VERY public, put it all on the line and strive to develop, with the help of the American public, a nationally collective effort of homeowners and others who are fed up with the corruption that is decimating their families, their homes and our Country.

I am a political atheist and this effort is politically atheistic in that it crosses all boundaries of classification.

No One Is Insulated From This Corruption

Corruption and RICO Fraud know no boundaries and operate without any legal, ethical, moral or human concern restraints.

I would like to detour briefly and discuss why Civil RICO under 18 USC Section 1964 is so important and powerful.

a. Most folks think of RICO as the group of laws that allow the government to go after organized crime.

b. That is true, but most are not aware of RICO Section 1964.

c. This Section provides for civil damages being awarded and for punishment to be levied against the perpetrators if it can be shown that you have experienced damages that have been caused as a result of RICO Fraud Activities being conducted by the offending party.

d. For me, the single most important component part of our judicial system is the JURY.

e. I am afraid that many people hold to the belief that they, if necessary, can “have their day in Court.”

f. My experiences over the last 6 years make me seriously question this belief.

g. It takes very little effort to research and discover how many people today are being precluded from having their day in Court in front of a Jury of their peers.

h. In my opinion, a judicial system WITHOUT JURIES is NOT a judicial system.

i. Without the ability to have a Jury of your peers decide the merits of your claims and evidence is tantamount to asking the fox to guard the hen house.

j. You may file a Civil RICO lawsuit without a lawyer.

k. If we unite as individual Americans in a joint effort, co-ordinate in an organized fashion, share evidence, each contribute very small and insignificant financial resources, processes already in existence and instigate a nationwide effort to properly and legally evidence and file legitimate Civil RICO lawsuits all across the Country, I have to believe and have faith that when the American people unite with a common goal and mobilize that we CAN stop this Fraud and Carnage.

l. As of this point, no one has been held criminally accountable for their actions in the Mortgage Crisis.

m. Every time a new Bail Out is rolled out by the government, the Money Changers get bigger and stronger and the homeowner gets thrown under the bus of governmental overburden and injustice.

n. At the beginning of the Mortgage Crisis, the banks who claimed they were broke and were threatening, through the mouth of Secretary of the Treasury Hank Paulsen, that martial law would be soon to follow if Congress did not give the banks the monies they demanded, are the very same banks that are today, across the board and on average, 40% bigger than they were previously.

o. If you or I attempted this malarkey, we would be thrown under the jail for extortion. To me, this is like yelling FIRE in a theater.

p. The questions to each of us should be, “Why are we, as a society, allowing this behavior to continue and why are we allowing these people and out-of-control institutions to get away with this?” when, if we unite to pool resources and skills, have tools, such as Civil RICO, to put up one heck of a fight with the very real potential of realizing significantly positive results.

Back On Track Here

As I have spoken to many who feel as I do but have not had a way to put their beliefs into action, it seemed an appropriate and logical conclusion to provide, for others, an accurate understanding, based in evidence, of what has actually taken place. The unaware homeowner is being victimized.

Many have reached out and asked that a centralized point of communication be established to give others an easy and effective way to get involved. Although we each have our own story, in almost all instances, the players on the other side are the same. As a natural result, amass the strength in numbers necessary to FORCE those in positions of Political and Judicial authority to get active and DO SOMETHING TO STAND UP FOR AND PROTECT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE THAT ELECTED THEM.

I had another decision to make at this point. Before I got involved in this crisis, I had a very comfortable life with few concerns so it made the decision difficult in some respects. After being made aware of the many people who have felt disassociated, I decided to go all in. I committed myself and resources to the process and have funded it for the last 6 years. I established Save Our Family and Home.com to be the starting point for this collective effort.

We must all STOP TALKING AND COMPLAINING and START TAKING ACTION NOW because the BAD GUYS believe we, as a people, are disorganized, disassociated, aren’t doing anything together and don’t represent a risk to them. Our lack of action as a collective society is providing for the BAD GUYS the opportunity to very easily implement the old political and social tactic of “Divide and Conquer” without even having to work up a sweat. While we remain disassociated and disorganized, those involved in the RICO Fraud Enterprise are marching us off the cliff.

We, As A Society, Cannot Continue To Stand Idly By, Do Nothing And Allow The Continued Destruction Of Our Families, Our Homes And Our Country To Take Place. Now, Today, This Very Minute Is When We Must Start To Come Together And Act As One To Begin Working To Stop This Lawlessness. We must re-establish the Rule Of Law.

I, with the help of many great people, have collected over 11,000 pages of primary source documented and court admissible evidence upon which I have based my conclusions.

After working to deal with the Federal judicial morass for three years, one year being represented by Counsel and two years as a Pro Se Plaintiff, I have come to the conclusion that those involved in the Judicial System are doing, without regard to following the law, everything they can to prevent this evidence from being made public and from being presented to a jury of my peers.

Since the Judicial System seemingly does not want this evidence to be made public, I am going to make it available, through the website, to everyone in the public who want it for their own use and to those who help the process.

It became clearly apparent that the judicial system was intentionally and seemingly uninterested in addressing the massive and provable evidence of Fraud. Again, I found myself at a decision point.

After interviewing so many homeowners during this period who have experienced lawless treatment in the Federal Judicial System, I realized that the thing missing was that we, as victims, are not successfully having our Day In Court and the Rule Of Law has been perverted.

So, on April 24, 2014, I became an official Whistleblower with the IRS and SEC in the hope that we, as a society, could cause non-Federal Judicial System Agency Investigations to take place and document and address the Securities Fraud, Income Tax Fraud and Income Tax Evasion that is at the root of the Mortgage Crisis.

Connecting the Evidence

I, by coincidence, heard Scott Bennett give his first ever interview on Project Camelot in October, 2014. I reached out and we got connected. Bennett’s evidence picks up with the Federal Reserve transferring funds to UBS and the subsequent distributions out of UBS. I introduced him to “V”, The Guerrilla Economist and subsequently we did The Guerrilla Economist’s show. (Embedded Below.)

Terrorist Funding – Is My Mortgage Funding American Black Ops?

Here is the Project Camelot interview: PROJECT CAMELOT: SCOTT BENNETT : CIA, SWISS BANKS FUND ISIS

Published on Oct 2, 2014

Discussion of the book SHELL GAME: A Military Whistleblowing Report to the U.S. Congress Exposing the Betrayal and Cover-Up by the U.S. Government of the Union Bank of Switzerland-Terrorist Threat Finance Connection to Booz Allen Hamilton and U.S. Central Command

By 2LT Scott Bennett 11th Psychological Operations Battalion (retired)

http://armypsyop.wix.com/scottbennett

Part of the reason behind Eric Holder’s immediate retirement.

BACKGROUND OF SPEAKER:

Scott Bennett

Scott Bennett

Scott Bennett is a U.S. Army Special Operations Officer (11th Psychological Operations Battalion, Civil Affairs-Psychological Operations Command), and a global psychological warfare-counter terrorism analyst, formerly with defense contractor Booz Allen Hamilton.

He received a Direct Commission as an Officer, held a Top Secret/Sensitive Compartmentalized Information (TS/SCI) security clearance, and worked in the highest levels of international counter terrorism in Washington DC and MacDill Air Force Base in Tampa, Florida. He has worked at U.S. Special Operations Command, U.S. Central Command, the State Department Coordinator for Counter terrorism, and other government agencies. He served in the G.W. Bush Administration from 2003 to 2008, and was a Social Science Research Fellow at the Heritage Foundation. His writings and lectures seek to enhance global awareness and understanding of modern psychological warfare, the international intelligence.

http://projectcamelotportal.com/video…

Kerry Lynn Cassidy

PROJECT CAMELOT

http://projectcamelot.org

Shell Game (with external exhibits) by 2Lt Scott Bennett
Proceeds from RMBS Trading used to fund Terrorist Activities and Networks – Link

Scott Bennet’s Wistleblowing Report

Shell Game CoverSHELL GAME: A Military Whistleblowing Report to the U.S. Congress Exposing the Betrayal and Cover-Up by the U.S. Government of the Union Bank of Switzerland-Terrorist Threat Finance Connection to Booz Allen Hamilton and U.S. Central Command.

By 2LT Scott Bennett 11th Psychological Operations Battalion

A MILITARY WHISTLEBLOWING REPORT TO CONGRESS EXPOSING THE BETRAYAL AND COVER-UP BY THE U.S. GOVERNMENT OF THE UNION BANK OF SWITZERLAND-TERRORIST THREAT FINANCE CONNECTION TO EDWARD SNOWDEN’S REPORT ON THE NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY, CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY, BOOZ ALLEN HAMILTON AND U.S. CENTRAL COMMAND.

Available at Lulu.

Scott Bennett,

An epiphany of political-military intelligence, failure, and opportunity.

“This is the true story of what might possibly be viewed by history as the greatest example of political corruption, military failure, and media conspiracy, in the history of the United States of America—if not Western Civilization. It spans the globe through the web of modern international banking, terrorist organizations, and the military-intelligence-media complex; and yet has remained hidden to most Americans because of Congressional cowardice and corruption, the Patriot Act’s unconstitutional authoritarianism, and the brain-numbing paranoia of constantly combating Islamic extremists (now, like National Security, conveniently redefined as an endlessly evolving term).

… a rallying cry which exposes a lie, emboldens readers to demand answers from their government officials, military officers, and journalists who’ve metastasized the lie, and leads people toward the renaissance of freedom and peace which only an information-privacy revolution can inspire—both in American and the world.

This is the story which occurred before Bradley Manning overflowed with conviction, and the story which eventually prompted and inspired Edward Snowden to help reveal the same information to the American people and the citizens of the free world.

The book “SHELL GAME” provides the paradigm for Americans to confirm their identity, shift their government and laws around, and firmly establish their future upon. The choice to read and be renewed, is entirely the reader’s.

It is hoped this information will empower you with the knowledge, confidence, and relationships that will make you powerful in the arena of public policy. As a leader of your community, and a liaison to the highest levels of the intelligence community, you now have the duty, the burden, and the blessing to enlighten your family, friends, and neighbors about your discoveries—and the feelings they inspire. Make no mistake, your family and friends’ freedom is dependent upon your work to awaken them; and as difficult, and sometimes uncomfortable, as arousing people content in their sleep can be, it is our spiritual calling and duty to do so. So I encourage you in your challenge.

Thank you for choosing to nourish your mind with truth, make a stand and fight against the tyranny of lies, and sojourn boldly into the kaleidescopic adventure of intelligence.”

Screen grabs from 3 pages of the PDF file linked above ..

Shell Game page 34

Shell Game (PDF page 34)

Shell Game page 40

Shell Game (PDF page 40)

Shell Game page 77

Shell Game (PDF page 77)

Greg Morse and Scott Bennett together on V The Guerrilla Economist’s Broadcast

“V” Guerrilla Nov. 14, 2014 Bombshell! The Mortgage Crisis And Funding

On Friday night, November 14, “V” The Guerrilla Economist and his guests Greg and Scott called for open and public Federal Joint Congressional Investigation Hearings and Testimony regarding “The Mortgage Crisis” and funding Of terrorist activities.

Note from Red Pill Reports:

 

Related Articles: https://redpillreports.com/tag/mortgage-crisis/

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
We Need to Talk about Sandy Hook: Video

We Need to Talk about Sandy Hook: Video

We Need to Talk about Sandy Hook: Video

By Independent Media Solidarity | | Red Pill Reports

Since 9/11, no event has spawned more conspiracy theories that have been met with coordinated efforts to discredit them than Sandy Hook. The idiom, “If you’re not catching flak, you’re not over the target.” if applied to Sandy Hook speculation indicates there’s something there they wish to protect.

Immediately after the events of December 14th, 2012 the speculation began that what was being reported was not the truth. Although many anomalous reports were deemed to be innocent mistakes, a pile of unexplainable oddities began to grow. In the first days after the event, the public was told to give it some time for the facts to emerge. When those facts didn’t make a dent in the pile of oddities, the public was told to wait for the investigation to get underway. When, throughout those many months more questions emerged than were answered the public was told to wait for the final report. That report has been released. There are no further milestones to wait for in the hopes that the questions will be answered. We have reached a proverbial dead-end and each day that passes means public interest drops as they grow more comfortable with not knowing the truth.

We Need to Talk about Sandy Hook

Despite our many differences of opinion, we all agree that this event has been and will continue to be of such historical significance that the true details must be revealed.

Independent Media Solidarity is a loose knit group of independent journalists that have come together to tackle the issue of Sandy Hook. We are normal people with normal lives, who have families, children, and jobs. Although many of us haven’t physically met each other, we are united. All we seek are answers to the many inconsistencies. But most importantly, we just want the truth made available to all who might seek it.

Sandy Hook School Massacre Timeline

James Tracy | Memory Hole Blog

The following timeline of the December 14, 2012 mass killing of 20 children and 8 adults in Newtown Connecticut attempts to demonstrate how the event was presented to the public by corporate news media. The chronological assemblage of coverage is not comprehensive of all reports published on the incident but rather seeks to verify how the storyline was to a substantial degree constructed by federal and state law enforcement authorities and major media around the theory that 20-year-old Adam Lanza was the sole agent in the massacre.

This scenario became an established reality through the news media’s pronounced repetition of the lone gunman narrative and meme. This proposed scenario significantly obscured the fact that police encountered and apprehended two additional shooting suspects on the school’s grounds within minutes of the crime. These suspects remain unaccounted for by authorities but the roles they may have played arguably correlate with the shifting information presented by authorities and major news media on injuries and weapons vis-à-vis the mass carnage meted out in the school. While the certain detainment of additional suspects was pointed to by alternative news media, including Natural News, Infowars, Veterans Today and Global Research in the days following the tragedy, the untenable lone gunman narrative has become firmly established in the public psyche via an overwhelming chorus of corporate media reports and interpretations.

Note: Times of occurrences referenced are Eastern Standard Time and in some instances signify time of publication rather than the specific incident cited. Time of publication does not always correlate with exact time of incident. “n.t.” denotes “no time” of publication referenced.

1955

May 17

First Selectman A. Fenn Dickinson of Newtown, a 42-year-old Democrat serving his third term as Newtown’s foremost public servant, is killed when a truck backs over him at a road project in Sandy Hook. Dickinson Drive, the road leading to Sandy Hook Elementary, is named after the local leader. “Do You Remember?” Newstimes.com, May 22, 2005.

2006

June 26

President George W. Bush signs Executive Order 13407 to establish a Public Alert and Warning System for national emergencies potentially involving the public at large. “It is the policy of the United States,” the EO’s policy summary reads,

to have an effective, reliable, integrated, flexible, and comprehensive system to alert and warn the American people in situations of war, terrorist attack, natural disaster, or other hazards to public safety and well-being (public alert and warning system), taking appropriate account of the functions, capabilities, and needs of the private sector and of all levels of government in our Federal system, and to ensure that under all conditions the President can communicate with the American people.

The Department of Homeland Security is designated as the government entity for establishment of the integrated mass communication system. “Executive Order 13407 (PDF),” Government Printing Office, June 2006.

December 4

Attorney General Richard Blumenthal, New York State Police (NYSP) Superintendent Wayne E. Bennett, and Connecticut Department of Public Safety (DPS) Commissioner Leonard C. Boyle release a 207-page report chronicling shortcomings in the Connecticut State Police (CSP) internal affairs system and recommending reforms thereof. The investigation was requested by state troopers filing whistleblower complaints with Blumenthal’s office on the DPS internal affairs process. Commissioner Boyle also asked the NYSP to investigate those complaints and others received from state troopers about the internal affairs system. The report caps a 13-month joint investigation by Blumenthal’s office and NYSP involving 262 interviews, 207 of them with current or former sworn DPS employees, thousands of pages of documents, and 112 formal requests for information. “Attorney General-NY State Police Report Finds Shortcomings in CT State Police Internal Affairs System, Calls for Reforms,” State of Connecticut Attorney General’s Office, December 4, 2006.

2010

September 22

8:00AM-5:00PM
US Department of Homeland Security, Federal Emergency Management Agency and State of Connecticut Division of Emergency Services and Public Protection conduct Homeland Security Exercise and Evaluation Program (HSEEP) Training Course at Sandy Hook Fire Department. The training consists of “instructor-led course presentations” in addition to “small group activities, videos, and group discussions.” According to the description, “the course also provides overviews of HSEEP-related initiatives such as technology (e.g., the HSEEP Toolkit) and capabilities-based planning (e.g., Target Capabilities List [TCL]). This blended approach will give participants hands-on experience that readily translates to real-world exercise skills. Activities include creating exercise documentation, conducting exercise planning conferences and briefings, and practicing exercise evaluation.” “September 22: The HSEEP Training Course,” Connecticut Division of Emergency Services and Public Protection, n.d.

2011

February 23

n.t.
Connecticut State Senators Steven T. Mikutel, Leonard A. Fasano, Michael A. McLachlan, and Len Suzio introduce SB 1054, a bill “to allow the parents of a child who was a homicide victim to request that the autopsy report not be publicly disclosed.” SB 1054: An Act Concerning the Disclosure of Autopsy Reports, Sunlight Foundation/Open States, retrieved March 1, 2013.

February 25

n.t.
In a memorandum to the state legislature’s judiciary committee Connecticut Chief Medical Examiner H. Wayne Carver II questions the necessity of SB 1054. “The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner as an institution and I are very concerned about the privacy rights of individuals who are examined through our office and particularly with respect to homicide victims whose family find their privacy and grieving invaded by a curious public. I believe that the proposed legislation is redundant of current statute, regulations, and practices. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner does not now and has never released autopsy reports to the general public, let alone autopsy reports of a pediatric homicide victim.” Dr. H. Wayne Carver II to Chairman Coleman, Fox and Members of the Connecticut State Judiciary Committee, Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, February 25.

March 9

State Police spokesman Lt. J. Paul Vance, a regional celebrity, announces on WPLR radio that he will try out for the next season of the Survivor television series. Tryouts are next Wednesday at Foxwoods. Vance tells the Connecticut Post that he will “do the interview (with Survivor) and explore the process.” Vance’s son, J. Paul Vance Jr. called WPLR’s “Chaz and A.J.” show earlier to nominate his father as a candidate, and Vance Sr. subsequently called in to say he was up to the “tall order,” of trying out for the show. The show’s hosts said that wardrobe will be important. “Wear your shirt, with the police hat and a grass skirt,” said show co-host Chaz. “State Police Lt. J. Paul Vance to Try Out for ‘Survivor’,” Connecticut Post, March 9, 2011.

August 16

Connecticut Governor Dannell P. Malloy appoints J. Paul Vance Jr. as the state’s new claims commissioner. The Republican politician was appointed to the job with a $114,000 salary, where he will more or less decide who can sue the state.Penelope Overton, “Vance Appointed State’s Claims Commissioner,” August 16, 2011.

October 1

n.t.
Existing law preventing disclosure of autopsies to the press or public is bolstered through passage and enactment of recommendations encompassed in SB 1054 by Connecticut State Senate and General Assembly.

Section 1. Subdivision (3) of subsection (b) of section 1-210 of the general statutes is repealed and the following is substituted in lieu thereof Effective October 1, 2011

(3) Records of law enforcement agencies not otherwise available to the public which records were compiled in connection with the detection or investigation of crime, if the disclosure of said records would not be in the public interest because it would result in the disclosure of … “the records of an investigation and examination by the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of the death of a person under eighteen years of age caused by an apparent homicide, including the autopsy report and other scientific findings.”

SB 1054 An Act Concerning the Disclosure of Autopsy Reports, Sunlight Foundation/Open States, retrieved March 1, 2013.

2012

September

At the start of the 2012-13 academic year Sandy Hook Elementary School Principal Dawn Hochsprung announces in a public letter to families the Newtown School District’s new security protocol “in all elementary schools.” Under the newly-announced security regimen, “exterior doors will be locked during the day. Every visitor will be required to ring the doorbell at the front entrance and the office staff will use a visual monitoring system to allow entry. Visitors will still be required to report directly to the office and sign in. If our office staff does not recognize you, you will be required to show identification with a picture id. Please understand that with nearly 700 students and over 1,000 parents representing 500 SHS families, most parents will be asked to show identification. Doors will be locked at approximately 9:30 a.m.” “Principal Outlined New Security Procedures at Sandy Hook Elementary,” Hartford Courant, December 14, 2012, 8:25PM EST.

October 17

9:47AM
Sandy Hook Principal Dawn Hochsprung Tweets photo of emergency drill held at Sandy Hook fire station with Sandy Hook Elementary faculty and students participating. Esther Zuckerman, “The Sandy Hook Principal’s Twitter Feed is Haunting,” The Atlantic Wire, December 14, 2012.

November 7

n.t.
Following Obama’s reelection Senator Diane Feinstein is believed to be meeting with relevant federal agencies to lay groundwork for reenacting assault weapons ban. “Senator Diane Feinstein Moves to Ban All Assault Rifles, High Capacity Magazines, and Pistol Grips,” Market Daily News, November 7, 2012.

November 27

11:00AM
U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder and Connecticut Governor Dan Malloy announce Project Longevity, a joint venture by the Justice Department and State of Connecticut, at a news conference in New Haven, Connecticut. The endeavor is described by one law enforcement officials as “a statewide approach that targets repeat criminals, creates alternatives for potential gang members and rallies neighborhoods against violence.” Federal money is being directed to engage Connecticut-based agents, academics and social workers who will work for or with the FBI and the U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. Dave Ingram, “Project Longevity: Justice Department, Connecticut State Officials Target Gun Violence,” Reuters/Huffington Post, November 27, 2012. See also, Erin Logan, “Attorney General Eric Holder Discussing Gun Violence,” WTNH.com, November, 27, 2012.

December 10

Newtown Schools superintendent Janet Robinson speaks before the Newtown Board of Finance discusses closing one of the town’s schools given the area’s 25-year-low in elementary school enrollment. “When asked about space needs,” the 12-10 meeting minutes read, “school closing declining enrollment Dr. Robinson said that the Ad Hoc Facilities group vetted every option. Their recommendation was when elementary enrollment is projected to be 1500 a study should be commissioned to begin looking at closing a school.” Robinson proposes embarking on a study to determine the feasibility of closure. “Our problem is [that] our parents really cherish their neighborhood schools,” Robinson notes, “even though these are not small neighborhoods. So, we have to prepare the parents for this in advance.” Janet Robinson, “State of Schools Presentation,” in Town of Newtown Board of Finance Meeting Minutes, and 2012-12-10 Board of Finance.wmv (electronic record at 1:18:13) Town of Newtown, Newtown, CT, December 10, 2012.

December 11

n.t.
Adam Lanza reportedly visits a sporting goods store in Danbury and attempts to purchase an assault rifle but was denied NBC reports. Julia Terruso, “Reports: Gunman Had Altercation at School Day Before Shooting,” Star Ledger, December 15, 2012.

December 13

4:13PM

Connecticut State Representative John Frey Tweets his presence at the Sandy Hook Elem. Holiday concert, 4:13pm. “At the Sandy Hook Elementary School concert cheering nieces Joan and Bridget.” http://twitter.com/johnfrey/status/279378604469657601

n.t.

The alleged gunman at Adam Lanza has an argument with four staff members at Sandy Hook Elementary School, officials tell NBC. NBC reports that Lanza went to the school on December 13 and was in an altercation with four staff members, three of whom are killed in the December 14 shooting. The fourth person will not be at the school the day of the shooting, NBC says. Julia Terruso, “Reports: Gunman Had Altercation at School Day Before Shooting,” Star Ledger, December 15, 2012.

December 14

9:00AM
“Planning for the Needs of Children in Disasters” emergency exercise conducted jointly by FEMA and the Connecticut Department of Emergency Services and Public Protection commences 14 miles from Newport in Bridgeport Connecticut. “The goal of the course,” the description reads,

is to enable participants to improve their community’s mitigation and emergency operations plan specifically regarding the needs of children. The course will provide them with the information needed to address the unique needs of children prior to, during and following disasters. It will also provide them guidance and direction on how to form coalitions and how to become advocates for the unique needs of children in all aspects of emergency management.

Shepherd Ambellas and Alex Thomas, “Sandy Hook Shooting: Active Shooter Drill Confirmed By Law Enforcement Raises Suspicion of False Flag Operation, [News Analysis]” theintellhub.com, January 12, 2013.

9:00AM [estimate]
“Active shooter drill” exercise commences by Putnam County Emergency Response Team in Carmel Connecticut, 45 miles away from Newtown. “By grim coincidence, even as the terrible events were unfolding in Newtown on Friday morning,” the Southeast Brewster-Patch reports,

the Putnam County Emergency Response Team (“ERT”) happened to be assembled for regular training in Carmel, and team members were at that very moment engaged in a mock scenario of an active-shooter in a school. The ERT is comprised of specially trained and heavily armed officers from the Sheriff’s Office and the Carmel and Kent Police Departments. When news broke of the Newtown shooting, the Putnam County ERT commander called Newtown Police and offered to have the ERT respond to the Sandy Hook school, but that response was not needed because Connecticut police had already secured the scene.

Ashley Tarr, “Sheriff: Putnam Officials to Talk School Safety This Afternoon,” Southeast Brewster-Patch, December 18, 2012.

9:30AM [estimate]
Only 35 minutes away from Newtown an active shooter drill is taking place at a school in Carmel, Putnam County. The operation is conducted by the Putnam County Emergency Response Team (“ERT). “The ERT is comprised of specially trained and heavily armed officers from the Sheriff’s Office and the Carmel and Kent Police Departments,” the Southeast Brewster Patch newspaper reports. “When news broke of the Newtown shooting, the Putnam County ERT commander called Newtown Police and offered to have the ERT respond to the Sandy Hook school, but that response was not needed because Connecticut police had already secured the scene.” “Sheriff: Putnam Officials to Talk School Safety This Afternoon,” Southeast Brewster Patch, December 18, 2012.

(9:30AM [see below])
CNN reports local authorities take the first 911 calls from Sandy Hook Elementary School. “‘Sandy Hook school. Caller is indicating she thinks someone is shooting in the building,’” a dispatcher told fire and medical personnel, according to 911 tapes. “Sandy Hook Shooting: What Happened?” CNN, December 14, 2012. (Recording of fire and law enforcement radio dispatch [below] indicates CNN’s 9:30AM time and account of events is incorrect.)

9:30AM [estimate]
Attorney Joel T. Faxon of Newtown, who serves on the town’s five-member police commission and is a strong advocate of strengthened gun control measures, claims he is taking one of his three children to the local middle school. As he approaches the school’s front doors, he receives a text message that all the town’s schools are on lockdown. This precaution takes place on occasion because of the school’s proximity to a state prison. “I told my son, ‘Okay, something’s going on. Let’s get out of here.” Returning to his vehicle, Faxon sees

the chief of police in his official car, headed to the Sandy Hook school, and I looked at my son and I said,”‘Oh my God, there must have been a shooting.” The chief doesn’t respond to anything other than a very serious incident. Within a minute of that time, I got a news report text from the Hartford Courant, that said police were responding to incident on Dickenson Drive, and I thought, “There’s only one thing on that street. And that’s the school.”

Faxon pulls over to the side of the road. “At that point, literally 50 state police and Newtown police cars went by us, and they all went to Sandy Hook Elementary School. I knew there had been some kind of a catastrophe there,” Faxon recalls. Faxon texts Bridgeport police captain James Viadero, who he works on a the police commission with. “He was filling me in on what was happening, in real time.” As the story took shape in the news only a single death was reported. Yet Faxon said the numbers the Viadero relayed “were just shocking.” Faxon’s other son goes to another elementary school and was at the the doctor’s office for a checkup. His daughter, a student at the high school, also in lockdown, was texting her father, “‘Daddy, what’s going on?’ I knew she was safe.” Faxon observes ambulances heading to the scene. “There were ambulances going down there [to the school], but there were no ambulances coming back to go to the hospital” with survivors, Faxon said. “Just like in 9/11, when the hospitals were all racing to be prepared for the wounded, who never arrived.” Thomas B. Scheffy, “Joel Faxon Has Been Part of the Gun Debate in His Hometown,” Connecticut Law Tribune, December 21, 2013.

9:34AM [estimate]
Sandy Hook Elementary School reading consultant Becky Virgalla said she was in a meeting with Principal Dawn Hochsprung, school psychologist Mary Sherlach and other colleagues when the shooter broke into the building. When they heard the commotion Hochsprung, Sherlach and lead teacher Natalie Hammond proceeded into the hall “to check out the noise that we didn’t know [were] gunshots at first,” Virgalla told Reuters Television at a December 23 Newtown memorial. “The three of them were shot and they yelled back ‘shooter, stay put.’ And they saved my life and the life of four others who were at that meeting,” Virgalla said. “Becky Virgalla, Newtown Shooting Survivor, Says Principal, Others Saved Her in Sandy Hook Rampage,” Reuters/Huffington Post, December 23, 2012.

9:34AM [estimate]
Fourth grate teacher Ted Varga arrives for work at Sandy Hook. Moments later, according an the account Varga related to the New York Daily News, he and four colleagues narrowly escaped a hail of bullets. “You hear screams and gunshots, but it is still surreal,” Varga said. “This is an elementary school. … I heard someone say, ‘Oh my God.’ And then you hear shot after shot after shot.” Undaunted, Varga ran down a hallway “filled with smoke and the smell of gunpowder,” according to the press account, “to escape through an emergency exit and then returned to help three colleagues flee through a window. An unidentified teacher hid underneath a mound of donated Christmas gifts for the needy, hoping the killer jiggling the door to the conference room would move on. “She heard heavy breathing,” Varga says. “She knew it was him. … It’s a miracle we’re alive, but it’s still such a tragedy. You’re exposed to a myriad of emotions that even now I can’t really understand.” Henrick Karoliszyn, “Five Teachers Escape Death as Massacre Rages in Newtown,” New York Daily News, December 19, 2012.

9:35AM [Estimate]
In the Sandy Hook library three faculty members hear noises and move 15 or so students to a storage closet in the library filled with computer servers. “Hold hands. Be quiet,” one teacher tells the children. One child questions “whether there are pots and pans were clanging. Another thought he heard firecrackers. Another worried an animal was coming to the door,” the Washington Post reports. “They were children in a place built for children, and the teachers didn’t know how to answer them … ‘It’s a drill,’ said a library clerk named Mary Anne Jacobs.” Eli Saslow, “Sandy Hook Massacre: Teachers Sought to Soothe Children in Moments of Terror,” Washington Post, December 15, 2012.

9:35:52AM
Recording of Newtown and Connecticut emergency fire and law enforcement radio dispatch indicates potential of active shooter situation at Sandy Hook Elementary School. “6-7. Sandy Hook School. Caller indicates she thinks there’s someone shooting in the building.” RadioMan911TV, “Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting Newtown Police/Fire and CT State Police,” Youtube, December 14, 2012.

9:36:20AM [estimate]
Newtown Bee Associate Editor Shannon Hicks is among the first on the scene at Sandy Hook Elementary. Hicks says she was at the Bee‘s offices about one and one quarter miles from the school when she heard about a possible shooting on the police scanner. A volunteer firefighter, Hicks is “behind the first dozen police officers,” according to John Voket, also associate editor at the weekly. This is because the Sandy Hook firehouse where Hicks is stationed shares a driveway with the school. When Hicks proceeds down the driveway she begins frantically taking photos of the scene “through the windshield of her car, with one hand on the steering wheel and one holding her camera, Voket says. One well-knonw photo featured in news coverage may have been of the first cluster of evacuating students, Voket further notes. Julie Moos, “How the Newtown Bee is Covering Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting,” Poynter.org, December 15, 2012.

9:36:38AM
Newtown and Connecticut emergency fire and law enforcement radio dispatch suggests arrival of law enforcement at scene; “front glass has been broken [unintelligible]. They’re unsure why.” RadioMan911TV, “Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting Newtown Police/Fire and CT State Police,” Youtube, December 14, 2012.

9:37:15AM
Newtown and Connecticut emergency fire and law enforcement radio dispatch indicates continuance of gunfire at Sandy Hook school. “All units: The individual that I have on the phone is continuing to hear what she believes to be gunfire.” RadioMan911TV, “Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting Newtown Police/Fire and CT State Police,” Youtube, December 14, 2012.

9:37:40AM
Newtown and Connecticut emergency fire and law enforcement radio dispatch indicates law enforcement units and backup continual arrival at Sandy Hook Elementary. RadioMan911TV, “Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting Newtown Police/Fire and CT State Police,” Youtube, December 14, 2012.

9:38:15AM
Newtown and Connecticut emergency fire and law enforcement radio dispatch indicates “the shooting appears to have stopped. It is silent at this time. The school is in lockdown.” RadioMan911TV, “Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting Newtown Police/Fire and CT State Police,” Youtube, December 14, 2012.

9:39:05AM
Newtown and Connecticut emergency fire and law enforcement radio dispatch indicates citing of shooter suspects fleeing crime scene. “Reports that a teacher saw two shadows running past the building–past the gym, which would be rear [inaudible] the shooting.” RadioMan911TV, “Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting Newtown Police/Fire and CT State Police,” Youtube, December 14, 2012.

9:39:20AM
Newtown and Connecticut emergency fire and law enforcement radio dispatch indicates officers’ encounter with and apprehension of additional shooter suspects fleeing scene. “Yeah, we got ‘em. He’s comin’ at me down Crestwood Way! Coming [inaudible] up the left side.” RadioMan911TV, “Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting Newtown Police/Fire and CT State Police,” Youtube, December 14, 2012.

9:40AM
Chris Manfredonia, alleged father of a 6-year-old Sandy Hook Elementary student, claims he is on his way to the school “to help make gingerbread houses with first-graders when he heard popping sounds and smelled sulfur.” Manfredonia runs around the facility in attempt “to reach his daughter and was briefly handcuffed by police. He later found his child, who had been locked in a small room with a teacher. ‘The whole reason we moved here a year ago is because when you drive down the subdivision, it’s a happy place,’ said his wife, Georgeann Manfredonia. “‘There’s a ton of children here and the families are very kind and supportive.’” Richard A. Serrano, Allen Semuals, Tina Susman, “Gunman Kills 20, 6 Adults at Connecticut Elementary School,” Los Angeles Times, December 14, 2012.

9:40AM [estimate]
First responders initially believe there may be two gunmen and are unaware of the carnage in the school until they find 18 children and a teacher in a classroom closet, a recording of the police dispatch authenticated by police indicates. Tracy Connor, “Call For Everything: Police Scanner Recording Reveals Early Moments of Newtown Tragedy,” NBC News, December 19, 2012.

9:40:45AM
Newtown and Connecticut emergency fire and law enforcement radio dispatch indicates “one now in room one who [unintelligible] injury to the foot. [unintelligible] call for an ambulance [unintelligible]. RadioMan911TV, “Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting Newtown Police/Fire and CT State Police,” Youtube, December 14, 2012.

9:45:48AM
Newtown and Connecticut emergency fire and law enforcement radio dispatch indicates officers’ discovery of “bodies here” and requests for ambulatory/first responders’ backup. RadioMan911TV, “Sandy Hook Elementary School Shooting Newtown Police/Fire and CT State Police,” Youtube, December 14, 2012.

(9:50AM [see below])
CNN reports police and first responders arrive at Sandy Hook Elementary. Police did not discharge their weapons. The gunman took his own life with a handgun. “Sandy Hook Shooting: What Happened?” CNN, December 14, 2012. (Recording of fire and law enforcement radio dispatch [above] suggests CNN’s 9:50AM time and account of events is incorrect.)

10:14AM
Hartford Courant publishes online Google map of Sandy Hook Elementary School. “Map of Sandy Hook Elementary School,” Hartford Courant, December 14, 2012.

10:15AM [estimate]
Emergency medical technician Peter Houlahan and other EMTs are told their expertise is not needed inside the school or elsewhere on school grounds. “A person who experiences tragic events will inevitably look back and try to identify that last moment where there was still hope,” Houlahan recalls, “that instant before all was lost and their life changed forever. For the EMS teams staged in front of Sandy Hook Elementary School on Dec. 14, that moment came when the Newtown EMS captain ordered us to stand down, that there was no one left to help, no one left alive.” Peter Houlahan, “Sandy Hook EMT and Former Whittier Resident Reflects on Massacre,” Daily News, December 23, 2012.

Read more

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
Real Mind Control Sex Slaves We Know

Real Mind Control Sex Slaves We Know

Real Mind Control Sex Slaves We Know

By Red Pill Reports

Jamie Hanshaw, self confessed ‘Conspiracy Theorist’ goes deep into the rabbit hole and talks about the history of mind control sex slaves and the many current manifestations. She delves into the music industry’s connection and key players. She also gets into Monarch programming. Nazi scientists brought in after WW2 in ‘Project Paper Clip’, followed by ‘MKUltra’, with experiments using LSD, psychotronic weapons and mind control. Jamie writes,

If you believe that slavery is a thing of the past, you are still a slave. The continuity of the practice of slavery on planet earth is staggering. The idea of owning another person is as old as civilization itself, going all the way back to ancient Sumer. Predating all other forms of coerced labor, not only is it ancient, but it is oh, so contemporary…and fashionable!

Some individuals, abused at an early age, begin the cycle of victimization and complete it as adults. Misdirection, confusion and fantasy play are used to confuse victims until they are not able to differentiate between fantasy and reality, creating disassociation in their minds.

Mind Control Sex Slaves

The process used to create split personalities has to do with trauma-torture. By stressing the brain to a degree that it causes amnesiac barriers. If this protocol has been generational, the torture begins very early. This goes so far as a mother who carries the child is being tortured during pregnancy.

Signs and symbols we see in popular culture are clues to the widespread use of this. Listen to this riveting interview below, and decide for yourself. Are some of our most popular ‘Pop Culture’ icons really ‘Mind Control Sex Slaves’?

Psychotronics

Wikipedia
Psychotronics is a term coined in 1967 by Zdeněk Rejdák for the study of parapsychology. Extensive research programmes and numerous conferences into the field during the 1970s and 80s sparked Cold War fears of mind control and other psychotronic weaponry being developed by Eastern Bloc countries which led to popularisation of the term in the West.

Since the mid-1990s, rumors of secret research into psychological warfare have led to a number of conspiracy theories. Campaign groups in Russia and the US have alleged that their governments are using psychotronic weapons against them to torture them, track their movements or control their minds.

Monarch Programming

A former military officer connected to the DIA, told this writer, “In the ‘big picture’ these people (MONARCH victims) are in all walks of life, from the bum on the street to the white-collar guy”. In corroboration, a retired CIA agent vaguely discussed the use of such personnel to be used as “plants” or “chameleons” for the purpose of infiltrating a designated group, gathering information and/or injecting an ulterior agenda. Ron Patton (Project Monarch: Nazi Mind Control)

See Also: http://freemantv.com/celebrities-under-mind-control-release-the-stars-weird-stuff/

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports
Illegal Mortgage Securitization – Did Banks Gamble Your Home & Distort Chain of Title?

Illegal Mortgage Securitization – Did Banks Gamble Your Home & Distort Chain of Title?

Illegal Mortgage Securitization – Did Banks Gamble Your Home & Distort Chain of Title?

By Robert Smith | Red Pill Reports

The future of everything America holds dear is at stake

Illegal Mortgage Securitization - Did Banks Gamble Your Home & Distort Chain of Title?

Image credit: © Ralf Roletschek [GFDL or CC-BY-SA-3.0-2.5-2.0-1.0], via Wikimedia Commons

(RedPillReports) During the Banker Bailout of 2008 the financial centers of power came under examination. The deceptive and illegal practice of mortgage securitization was brought to light and showed the banking industry’s willingness to distort chain of title involving property ownership and gamble with America’s most cherished possession—their homes. Groundbreaking evidence has now appeared which begs the question of just how deep the rabbit hole goes and quite frankly might make the Watergate scandal look trivial. Through a secret shell game, played with proceeds derived from mortgage manipulation, underground “black funds” seem to have been created and used to fund terrorism throughout the world. To the point…the very extremists killing our soldiers and beheading Americans overseas might have been funded by money funneled from the MERS-created mortgage securities sold on Wall Street by some of the largest banks in the world. Greg Morse and Scott Bennett have followed the breadcrumbs and now ask for your attention.

It doesn’t take a whole lot of research to create a scenario in your mind where this is possible. Banks laundering money for criminal elements are hardly something new. More often than they care to admit the banking industry has been caught laundering large sums of drug money. HSBC even paid a billion dollar fine because of it.

http://www.theguardian.com/business/2012/dec/11/hsbc-bank-us-money-laundering

Traditionally, and by law, banks who loan money to home buyers are required to track all transactions involving an interest in the home through the County Recorder. This process ensures proper accounting and allows everyone to have confidence in the property ownership records of the country. Because of the freedom to act without the oversight of the publicly elected County Recorder, MERS (Mortgage Electronic Registration System) allowed the banks to separate the note from the property itself. Instead of being registered with the public record they were now recorded by the banks themselves. The proverbial fox guarding the hen house.

They were then able to turn the “notes” into financial instruments traded and leveraged on the stock market beyond the ability of the average homeowner to envision. By derivatives and insurance and securitization a $100,000.00 home mortgage could be worth well over a million dollars. Furthermore, anytime a homeowner defaulted on payments complicated insurance plans were activated and allowed the banks to cash in. Every mortgage was paid whether the homeowner made a payment or not. It was brilliant. Why do you think banks gave anybody with a pulse a loan in the early 2000’s? They made money either way. Up or down, foreclosure or no foreclosure, banks won at America’s expense. The mortgage notes were just a piece of paper to be toyed with. It didn’t matter who got hurt by the practice or its questionable legality.

The large sums of money generated by these complicated schemes created huge pools. Plenty of money hush-money to go around and keep the wheels greased and the carousel spinning.There is no question proper accounting would make us look at the foreclosure crisis in a whole new light. Why have homeowners been ripped out of their houses when banks have suffered no financial loss and where did all the money go the banks made cheating America?

The work of Greg Morse and Scott Bennett seem to show a significant portion of this money was used to fund off the record activities.Some of them being to spread unrest through violence and topple governments. Laundering drug money, wrecking chains of title, defrauding investors and homeowners alike…it has all been proven in court many times over and there is a good chance the bank you deposit your paycheck and got your home loan from have paid billions in fines to settle these type of suits. Banks funding the very foreign gangs our soldiers have died for is sickening. Although Greg and Scott’s work is the most complete and provable case proving the link between terrorism, the banks and your mortgage, it is not the first. The families of several American soldiers have seen a link and sued because of it.

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014/11/11/veterans-families-sue-six-banks-claiming-helped-iran-fund-terror-groups/

How Greg and Scott got this earth shattering information sounds like a Tom Clancy novel. Scott was an analyst working on an American military base. His job was to unravel complicated money trails like these. As he began to find trails of money leading to Al Queda and ISIS, among others, he brought it to the attention of his bosses. Instead of sending him to the Middle East to investigate further he was arrested for drunk driving and banned from the base. A trumped up baseless trial and he was sentenced to 36 months in jail. In jail he realized he was surrounded by other whistleblowers. He made friends with a European counterpart who noticed similar activity as Scott had. Scott asked him if he told anybody. He replied; “yeah, how do you think I ended up here?”

The information Scott received did two major things. 1. It was the other side of the same coin he had been going after and confirmed everything he had found and believed to be true. 2. He obtained the information from some means outside his former job or government database. Because of this no one could accuse him of hacking into sensitive areas or revealing classified information from his job.

Greg was coming from a different angle entirely. While Scott was chasing the end result of the accounts Greg was tracking down the beginning of the mortgage fraud. How banks got from your home purchase to Wall Street. Greg was able to prove how the chain of title has been broken. This means you can make your last payment on your house and still not have a clear title to home ownership. It is a sentence to a lifetime of indentured servitude by stealing what rightly belongs to you without you even knowing it.

The two of them together painted a near complete picture demanding our attention. They are on the forefront of this issue. Their great challenge now is to do something with the information they have found…not to let it stay hidden–to free the American People from the criminals pulling the financial levers of the Nation. Simply, their mission is to turn information into ‘actionism”, as Greg calls it.

In the early 1800’s Thomas Jefferson and John Adams warned the American People about the dangers of central banks. Most of the Founding Fathers understood the natural progression of power an unchecked banking industry captures as time goes by. Our ignorance of these issues has proven to be harmful to our way of life. The economic upheaval we have seen has served to benefit the very interests who claimed to be the most damaged—the banks. Greg and Scott have evidence proving the cries for a bailout in 2008 were a scam and another example of our Founder’s most dire warnings.

“All the perplexities, confusion and distress in America arise, not from defects in their Constitution or Confederation, not from want of honor or virtue, so much as from the downright ignorance of the nature of coin, credit and circulation.” John Adams

“If the American people ever allow private banks to control the issue of their currency, first by inflation, then by deflation, the banks and corporations that will grow up around them will deprive the people of all property until their children wake up homeless on the continent their Fathers conquered…I believe that banking institutions are more dangerous to our liberties than standing armies…” Thomas Jefferson

Greg Morse and Scott Bennett have suffered greatly to uncover the truth. They are risking everything by being so bold. They deserve and need support. Greg’s website, http://saveourfamilyandhome.com/ is a storehouse of information. He implores each one of you to find out if your own mortgage may have been compromised by going to “Learn If Your Mortgage Is Compromised”.  Their great plan is to force a Congressional hearing on the matter. To this point their effort to alert politicians, DA’s and Media have largely been ignored. The silence on the subject shows the extent of the banking control in this country. What they are calling for is an authentic uprising from the People through a petition. Greg Morse and Scott Bennett have suffered greatly for this cause and they will not rest until they are able to wheel the trunks full of court-ready documents through the halls of Congress and reveal what they have found.

As both of them come from military backgrounds they are familiar with asymmetrical warfare and are confident the tide can be turned. But their effort will only succeed with your support. Greg asks all those who took an Oath to defend the Constitution, or anybody who cares about it, to rise up now and get involved. Share this article with everyone you know. You can help their effort by going to Petition Calling For Open And Public Federal Joint Congressional Investigation Hearings And Testimony Regarding The Mortgage Crisis or Petitioner’s Letter, and demand a public hearing today. The future of everything America holds dear is at stake.

Petition Calling For Open And Public Federal Joint Congressional Investigation Hearings And Testimony Regarding The Mortgage Crisis

Posted by K. Robert Smith in Red Pill Reports
“V” Guerrilla Bombshell! The Mortgage Crisis And Funding Of Terrorist Activities

“V” Guerrilla Bombshell! The Mortgage Crisis And Funding Of Terrorist Activities

“V” Guerrilla Bombshell! The Mortgage Crisis And Funding Of Terrorist Activities

By Red Pill Reports

(RedPillReports) On Friday night, November 14, “V” The Guerrilla Economist and his guests Greg and Scott called for open and public Federal Joint Congressional Investigation Hearings and Testimony regarding “The Mortgage Crisis” and funding of terrorist activities.

They have made a petition available online, and ask your participation. This Petition demand is, in part, based upon that certain joint IRS and SEC Whistleblower Package (IRS Claim Number: 2014-007601 & SEC TCR Number: TCR1400871145384) submitted on April 24, 2014 that disclosed, outlined, described and evidenced massive trillion dollar Federal Income Tax Evasion and Securities Fraud stemming from the 2008 Mortgage Crisis that is being currently perpetuated by the continued illegal and fraudulent securitization and sale of Residential Mortgage Backed Securities (RMBS).

Petition Calling For Open And Public Federal Joint Congressional Investigation Hearings And Testimony Regarding The Mortgage CrisisThis Whistleblower Package detailed criminal Federal Income Tax Evasion and Securities Fraud committed by several Major Financial Institutions including, in part, Ally Bank, Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank, Residential Capital and its affiliates, GMAC Mortgage, Wells Fargo Bank, Union Bank of Switzerland, Homecomings Financial, L.L.C., the Depository Trust Clearing Corporation, Depository Trust Company, Cede & Co., Euroclear and Clearstream.

Copies of this same Whistleblower Package were filed simultaneously with all Members of the U.S. Senate, elected officials in the Executive Branch, thirty-six (36) Federal Inspectors General, the Appropriations, Budget, Energy and Commerce, Financial Services, Oversight and Government Reform, Ways and Means, and Small Business Committees in the U.S. House of Representatives. In their written responses, the Inspectors General of the DOJ, DOD, GAO and FTC have fraudulently lied and misrepresented their jurisdictionally mandated responsibilities and authorities by publically stating that the issues raised and voluminously evidenced in the above-referenced Whistleblower Package are not within their jurisdiction.

Read more: Petition

Posted by Red Pill Reports in Red Pill Reports